Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

wondering about rear rack

3.5K views 10 replies 9 participants last post by  nowhereyonder  
#1 ·
hey people :)

i'm Tom from ISRAEL. new here. looks very impressive forum.

i ride on 29' treck superfly 9.7 carbon hardtail 17' frame.
i'm looking for a solution for carrying things for long journeys.
my frame dosent have any holes for rack.

i found this rack and i wonder if its can fit with pannier.
https://www.aliexpress.com/store/pr...ack-Mountain-Bike-Bicycle/1719349_32608683220.html?spm=2114.12010612.0.0.BKAoKX

anyway i'll be happy to haer what you think and if you have any tips for my situation.
thanks :)
 
#3 ·
I'm looking at this rack, https://ridepdw.com/products/bindle-rack, by Portland Design Works. I like the design. It's lightweight, comes with securing straps to keep it from swaying back and forth, and can be used in conjunction with the Revelate Terrapin drybag.

I'm blowing the dust off of my old Marin Pine Mountain hard-tail and gonna set it up and use it this summer on the Idaho Hot Springs Tour. I'm planning on using a Cane Creek Thudbuster ST seat post for this tour. Has anyone out there used the Bindle with the ST? I'm just concerned about the front of the rack interfering with the ST and would like to hear from others out there who have used it.

Thanks
 
#11 ·
I have a Bindle rack with a Terrapin. I like it- it's stable, holds the terrapin well, and was reasonably priced ($50 from Amazon, shipped by Niagra Cycles. They seem to be more now...)

The weight of the load in the Bindle system is supported by nylon webbing running through the seat rails of your saddle. It's similar to a Mr. Fusion system by Porcelain Rocket. Thus, a dropper seatpost or a Thudbuster won't work since the height and fore-aft of the saddle are changing. With the seatpost bracket providing a hinge, every bump would cause your thudbuster to flex and the Bindle would sag up and down.

A more appropriate seat post mounted system would be the PR Albert or any of the other dropped compatible seat bags provided the Thudbuster can handle the extra leverage, weight and bracket space.
 
#7 ·
I would not use P clamps on a carbon frame, that's asking for trouble!

I would also discourage the use of those racks that mount onto the seatpost. They are fine for a short commute or something with a very light load, but that's it. I've seen too many pictures of broken ones.

I would suggest and OMM or Tubus and get hardware to mount it o the rear axle. For the top get one of the seatpost collars that have rack mounts built in, Salsa and I think Problem Solvers make them.
 
#9 ·
If you want to utilize a rack, whether it be front or rear, I would suggest seriously considering Old Man Mountain racks. He has mounting solutions for thru axle, QR axle, front, rear, whatever.

I have had one for four years now, mounted on a number of different bikes, and it has survived a number of good trail thrashings.

Not inexpensive, but extremely durable.