Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

Recommendations for 300+ pounds?

4.3K views 7 replies 6 participants last post by  Nubster  
#1 · (Edited)
I was previously very active in MTB, but in 2017 I was in a serious accident that put me in the hospital for about a month, with many months of recovery after that, and this triggered a whole slew of associated neuropsychological problems that caused me to stop riding... then in 2019 my old bike, a 2013 Trek Rumeblefish Elite was stolen out of my garage.

My weight is finally coming down after we were able to get my health problems under control, today I'm at 312 pounds, and I'm finding the motivation to want to ride again. However, I've always been a clydesdale though, and once I get back in shape I'll probably level out at around 260 pounds.

I would prefer a used bike, but I'm open to anything. I did all of the maintenance and upgrades on my previous bike, I still have all of the tools to service every component, including bike repair stand.

Height: 73.5"
Inseam: 34"
Weight: 312 lbs

Preferences:
Style: Full Suspension
Frame: Aluminum (as then I can afford a better groupset)
Groupset: Shimano Deore XT, or SRAM equivalent. (I upgrade components often, so I can go down a level with the groupset, i.g. SLX, in exchange for a better frame, suspension, or wheelset).
Rear Derailer: must have clutch mechanism.
Crankset: I don't really care, but I did love my Shimano Deore XT triple as I have to ride about 4 miles on the road to get to the mountain bike park. I'm built like a linebacker, I can squat 700 pounds easily, so I have very powerful legs.
Wheelset: I don't really care, but broken spokes have consistently been a failure point in the past, probably need at least 36 spoke count with like DT Swiss spokes.
Tires: 29er, 2.4" - 2.6"

Budget: I'm thinking about $2k, which is why I would prefer a used bike, because you get more bang for the buck.

I don't plan on doing anything crazy like what put me in the hospital, I'm mostly oriented to cross-country cycling, something that can accommodate casual bikepacking would be nice too.
 
#2 ·
A rear derailleur with a clutch will be found on most 2014+ bikes. A triple chainring went the way of the dodo several years before that. I wouldn't worry about a triple. An XT groupset and a full suspension bike will be at the high point of your budget. Also, a 36 spoke count wheel may very well require a custom build.

If I was in your position, I'd be looking at a 29+ wheeled hardtail. Something like a Surly Krampus.

Sent from my SM-N986U using Tapatalk
 
#3 ·
A rear derailleur with a clutch will be found on most 2014+ bikes. A triple chainring went the way of the dodo several years before that. I wouldn't worry about a triple. An XT groupset and a full suspension bike will be at the high point of your budget. Also, a 36 spoke count wheel may very well require a custom build.

If I was in your position, I'd be looking at a 29+ wheeled hardtail. Something like a Surly Krampus.

Sent from my SM-N986U using Tapatalk
Yeah a hardtail might be better given my weight at the moment, as high-end rear shocks are not cheap. I suppose I could do this in steps... i.g.

Step 1: Hardtail with mid-range groupset.
Step 2: Get myself in shape, and once I wear out the mid-range groupset replace with Deore XT or SRAM X1 / X01.
Step 3: Once I get all my components upgraded to the level I want then swap out the hardtail frame with a full suspension.
 
#5 ·
If you want to go full suspension, you’ll need a bike with a low leverage ratio. At your weight, you will not be able to set a proper sag at any in spec psi on any available rear shock.

You might be able to get a custom spring for a coil shock, but I’m not sure what’s available for riders over ~260ish pounds. You’d still want a low leverage ratio though.

I know the YouTuber B1ker recently was in that 300+ lbs range. Might want to shoot him a message and see what he was riding.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
#6 ·
Your wish list requires a previously owned bike. Check the classifieds on mtbr.com and pinkbike frequently. Also, search out "clydesdale" cycling groups on facebook. I've seen a few used SantaCruzs and Transitions online which hit all your requirements.

One note-you will fail an aluminum frame once you start putting the miles on.
 
#7 ·
I have a Diamondback Release frame with Manitou McLeod shock that was custom-tuned for 300+ pound rider for sale. Shock is amazing...it actually works as a proper shock for us heavy riders. Probably only other option will be coil with a heavy spring.

The suspension leverage ratio is also ideal for heavy riders which is one reason I opted for the DB over some other brands. It uses a rip-off of Santa Cruz's VPP suspension system. XL frame. I'm 6'2". It's listed on Pinkbike under NoGears user name.