Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
81 - 100 of 741 Posts
Discussion starter · #82 ·
Finally pulled the HSC stack from my 2011 Minute Expert to see what shim stack i have. Turns out it came stock with the XC stack, not the Trail stack.
I had a total of 2 shims on top of the piston (diff than the OP) & the normal 1 below like the OP.
Just thought i'd share. i'll be calling Manitou to see what i can do about ordering some more shims to play with.

Oh and it looks like Manitou switched the piston (HSC) from an anodized alum to red plastic....not a big deal, but My 2011 is definetly diff than the OP.
sent from my hand-held computer
I will be super disappointed if they are using a plastic piston.......

Side note: I talked to a Manitou tech a few days ago and they said there may be a long travel fork (160-180mm coming out, but not until 2013. Hopefully this is true.
 
Well, be disappointed. I was told today by Manitou tech, that the Pro comes with the alum piston. Expert gets plastic. Waiting to hear back from them about my shim stack. Their website definetly says 'Trail Tuned' and i most definetly have the XC pack..... Hopefully they will be sending me a Trail stack, but i was told the tuning 'kits' aren't available yet...?!?

sent from my hand-held computer
 
Discussion starter · #84 ·
Well, be disappointed. I was told today by Manitou tech, that the Pro comes with the alum piston. Expert gets plastic. Waiting to hear back from them about my shim stack. Their website definetly says 'Trail Tuned' and i most definetly have the XC pack..... Hopefully they will be sending me a Trail stack, but i was told the tuning 'kits' aren't available yet...?!?

sent from my hand-held computer
I wonder it the Match comes with a piston made out of a wicker basket......

Im very disappointed with that news. Especially because My 2010 drake came with a aluminum piston and the Minute Expert is suppose to be the exact same fork.
 
Manitou have almost always used plastic damper pistons. The only exceptions I have owned are 99 Xvert Ti (aluminium rebound piston) , 2000 Xvert carbon (aluminium rebound piston), 03 Minute SPV (aluminium piston), 06 Nixon (TPC+ removable cartridge) and Nixons.

All the rest of the EFC's, FS Ti's, Xverts, Blacks, Mars etc that I've owned are plastic pistons, none of them have suffered because of that.
 
Discussion starter · #86 ·
Manitou have almost always used plastic damper pistons. The only exceptions I have owned are 99 Xvert Ti (aluminium rebound piston) , 2000 Xvert carbon (aluminium rebound piston), 03 Minute SPV (aluminium piston), 06 Nixon (TPC+ removable cartridge) and Nixons.

All the rest of the EFC's, FS Ti's, Xverts, Blacks, Mars etc that I've owned are plastic pistons, none of them have suffered because of that.
I dont see why it would have any effect on performance, but its still disappointing IMO.
 
Discussion starter · #87 ·
Finally pulled the HSC stack from my 2011 Minute Expert to see what shim stack i have. Turns out it came stock with the XC stack, not the Trail stack.
I had a total of 2 shims on top of the piston (diff than the OP) & the normal 1 below like the OP.
Just thought i'd share. i'll be calling Manitou to see what i can do about ordering some more shims to play with.

Oh and it looks like Manitou switched the piston (HSC) from an anodized alum to red plastic....not a big deal, but my 2011 is definetly diff than the OP.

sent from my hand-held computer
You can order shims here by the way
 
Finally pulled the HSC stack from my 2011 Minute Expert to see what shim stack i have. Turns out it came stock with the XC stack, not the Trail stack.
I had a total of 2 shims on top of the piston (diff than the OP) & the normal 1 below like the OP.
Just thought i'd share. i'll be calling Manitou to see what i can do about ordering some more shims to play with.

Oh and it looks like Manitou switched the piston (HSC) from an anodized alum to red plastic....not a big deal, but my 2011 is definetly diff than the OP.
What is the OP?
 
Good news & bad news....

Good news, always first:
After speaking to Manitou tech last week about my valving, i recieved a small envelope today. Inside was the 'speed shim' as Manitou calls it. This is essentially the only diff between the XC & TRAIL valving. It lies on top of the piston and then the 2 platform shims on top of that. Everything mic'd out as per Manitou's charts.(that link rules!)

Installed the Speed Shim along with both Platform shims (removed 1 before) in the proper order. Reassembled & rode around the block a couple times.
Initial impression is a much livelier feel & less platform. This setup also ramps up considerably compared to the XC valving that was real linear after the platform. Will be taking it out for a real ride thurs.
This is my kinda feel. A couple clicks of comp damping and we should be good to go.

Bad News: i didn't take any pics!
(I hate messing with my camera while wearing oily latex gloves)

I've got about 10hrs on mine so far and all i can say, are good things.
 
Discussion starter · #92 ·
Good news & bad news....

Good news, always first:
After speaking to Manitou tech last week about my valving, i recieved a small envelope today. Inside was the 'speed shim' as Manitou calls it. This is essentially the only diff between the XC & TRAIL valving. It lies on top of the piston and then the 2 platform shims on top of that. Everything mic'd out as per Manitou's charts.(that link rules!)

Installed the Speed Shim along with both Platform shims (removed 1 before) in the proper order. Reassembled & rode around the block a couple times.
Initial impression is a much livelier feel & less platform. This setup also ramps up considerably compared to the XC valving that was real linear after the platform. Will be taking it out for a real ride thurs.
This is my kinda feel. A couple clicks of comp damping and we should be good to go.

Bad News: i didn't take any pics!
(I hate messing with my camera while wearing oily latex gloves)

I've got about 10hrs on mine so far and all i can say, are good things.
Thats great! Manitou costumer service is top notch.
 
Discussion starter · #94 ·
Why does it disappoint you? I would myself say an aluminum piston is more stiff and durable than a plastic one. But is this the case indeed?
I would agree, My Drake came with an aluminum piston. When they switched the name "Drake" to "Minute Expert", They also must have switched from an aluminum piston to a plastic piston. Its really not a big deal, But its a little disappointing. I would much prefer my aluminum piston over the plastic.
 
This seems like a good place to ask..what is the difference with the "jump stack" in the new circus forks? Does it still have tunable shims?

I've got a circus on my dj bike..seems to work very well. I'm almost interested in picking one up for my AM rig and tuning it to work better on the trail. I like the fact that it is such a stout durable fork and i feel if i can tune it different, a 130 would make a good AM fork. what do you guys think?
 
This seems like a good place to ask..what is the difference with the "jump stack" in the new circus forks? Does it still have tunable shims?

I've got a circus on my dj bike..seems to work very well. I'm almost interested in picking one up for my AM rig and tuning it to work better on the trail. I like the fact that it is such a stout durable fork and i feel if i can tune it different, a 130 would make a good AM fork. what do you guys think?
Yes, I think you can tune the Circus, although I'd probably take the Minute, which is already tuned for trail riding and it seems stiff and durable as well.

Regarding the jump stack, have a look at a couple of previous posts:

I recently wrote to Manitou to ask the difference between the trail tuned ABS+ of Minute forks and the standard XC ABS+ of R7 forks.

They sent me a useful document that explains the different configurations (XC, trail, linear) and how to tune the ABS+ damping system. It has lots of interesting graphs and drawings.

This document isn't in their website, but they told me I can publish it. It is very informative and I think it could be helpful. You can find it here: ABS+ Tuning REV 3-10-2011.pdf
I'm not sure, but I think it should be like this:

- Production XC Stack: Marvel, R7, Tower, Match;
- Production Trial Stack: Minute;
- Production Jump Stack: Circus.

I would have said that Tower had the same stack as Minute (being the same fork as Minute but for 29er), however Manitou's webpage doesn't specify trail tuning.
 
This seems like a good place to ask..what is the difference with the "jump stack" in the new circus forks? Does it still have tunable shims?

I've got a circus on my dj bike..seems to work very well. I'm almost interested in picking one up for my AM rig and tuning it to work better on the trail. I like the fact that it is such a stout durable fork and i feel if i can tune it different, a 130 would make a good AM fork. what do you guys think?
I think it would be overkill for an AM fork, but it certainly could be tuned to perform. It has all the same internals, just a different shim configuration. Considering you can find the Minute Expert for about the same price, I'd rather go that route, save about a pound and a half...
 
thanks i read over that pdf and it seems like the damper is the same and thie difference is simply in the shim stack.

I am weighing the differeces between the minute and another circus..weight isn't really a concern for me as much as reliability. I've got a lot of downhill components on my bike that are a little overkill haha but i dont usually have to replace them thats for sure. Theres some great info in this thread i cant wait to tear into this new fork lol
 
I've got a 2011 R7, and I just did the shim stack mod last night.

I ordered a bunch of shims to play with from these guys: www.racingsuspensionproducts.com

What I really wanted was to swap from the stock XC stack to the Trail stack, which means adding one 17.5x0.2 Speed Shim. I couldn't find a perfect match for that, so I went with a 17x0.15 instead.

With the stock XC stack I had found:

1 click from fully open was beautiful on really rooty, technical stuff, but it had seriously unpredictable brakedive.
3~4 clicks mostly eliminated the brakedive, but was significantly harsher
2 clicks was kindof the worst of both worlds.

So I put in the speed shim last night (took maybe 20 minutes) and went for a nice long ride today. The new stack is definitely a better fit for me, because I was able to run at 4~5 clicks and have no brakedive, but still a nice supple ride. With this setup I still have more platform than I need, so I may add a second speed shim or remove/swap one of the blowoff shims with something smaller. Definitely a nice mod, though.
 
81 - 100 of 741 Posts