Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

Friend has pedal strike crash on 1st e-bike ride

2.9K views 69 replies 21 participants last post by  William P  
#1 ·
Last Saturday our (female) friend who rides moto on techy terrain visited our area with her new e bike. All we ride is diamond and double diamond terrain. She is a very capable rider and has done the trails we headed out to do

After 2 hard rides we got on a faster flow section where she takes the lead and BAM pedal strike. She had just used the assist to gain some speed so that coupled with the abrupt full tilt stoppage caused a violent crash into deadfall barely missing a 4" branch that could have impaled her.

She's a tough gal and soldiered on despite being clearly shaken.
Poop happens stay frosty!!
 
#19 ·
Got up early to test out the short crank arms before it got too hot. Figured I'd try them w/o changing anything else and found out pretty quickly the seat would have to go up some. Too cramped pedaling uphill. Made a quick adjustment and felt much better. Still could tell I was spinning shorter, faster circles but not in a bad way. Descending, I really didn't notice my feet being closer together, so that was good.
Best thing was NO strikes! I had one slight scuff late in the ride totally being lazy and not paying attention 🙄. Previously, I'd get at least 2-3 strikes on this test/tune ride of varying intensity. The trail has some techy, rocky climbs requiring some ratcheting to clean.
Only other downside is I'll need some taller bars to go with the increase in seat height to make my jacked up neck happy.
The climb gets worse from here around the corner. I don't always pick the best lines either....monster truck!
Image

Saw a couple of coyotes out roaming the trail too.
Image
 
#20 ·
Hmmmm, after a few more rides I'm seeing a few drawbacks to the shorter cranks. Had to raise the seat a bit more due to knee pain which makes it feel like I'm too up in the air instead of 'in' the bike. Higher seat also makes the bars too low causing back/neck discomfort. Might pick up a cheap taller bar to try out but I'm afraid that might negatively affect climbing/cornering, making the front too light. If that doesn't work maybe I'll try some 160mm arms. Going from 165's to 152mm might have been too much. But then 5mm isn't much difference.
There is no free lunch...
 
#35 ·
My Scott RC Comp standard mtb has 170mm and the Rail 7 emtb 165mm. The Scott's pedals are noticeably closer to the ground, and I even hit them on a paved trail corner if I am not careful. I really pay attention to pedal strikes on the Scott but has almost been non-existent on the Rail. I am sure I my muscle memory is automatically adjusting because the Scott is such a problem, but even then I smack them on occasion. Pedal strikes are user error, but some bikes are significantly worse that others with this whether is it an e-bike or standard.
 
#36 ·
Matching the rear shock with frame leverage curve, and running lower sag has helped me. I also started using a shock that allows me to change the positive and negative chamber volumes independently, THAT has been a godsend on South Mountain. I didn't have to give up suspension compliance to reduce pedal strikes. Fewer rib fractures is a major fringe benefit. Revel Ranger with a Mara Pro.
 
#38 ·
Think I found my goldilocks setup!
The 152mm cranks were hurting my right knee for some reason. I put the 165's back on and found a used Lyric with 170mm travel, push acs3 and hc97 for dirt cheap. Also put the flip chip in the high position. Coupled with the 170mm fork it feels pretty close to the 160mm in low. Just did a ride this morning and only had a few grazes in the techy bits.
I thought the Yari with an avalanche damper and dsd runt was going to be hard to beat but I gotta admit, coil is the shizz! Practically nothing fazes it and small bump compliance is insane. It really excels at climbing tech, just stays glued to the ground and eats rocks like they aren't there. Bonus points for having a bit longer steering tube that allowed another spacer under the stem. My neck and back felt much better after the ride and it's easier to look farther down the trail. Very happy camper!
 
#40 ·
Thats not going to help with pedal strikes. It will likely make pedal strikes more common on the Rail. A progressive shock to match your frames leverage curve is your best friend. The RS has an upgrade air can called Megneg that increases the negative chamber volume and makes the shock travel higher in midstroke without losing compliance. You can install it yourself. You live by me and I have a brand new one you can have for cheap. I am certain that a linear coil shock will be a step backward. The fork doesnt have a leverage curve problem, definitely a good move.