Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

Anyone making non-slack frames?

8.1K views 65 replies 41 participants last post by  BansheeRune  
#1 ·
The best geometry I ever rode was the Transition Badit. Ever since the frames have gotten more and more slack as the rise of flowy manicured trails for normie shuttlefucks has taken over the entire market.

Unfortunately, some methhead stole my Bandit, so I have to ask: does ANYONE make non-slack frames? I've been riding a Spot Mayhem V1 (a far more expensive build) and it's just not as nimble going up or down. The v2 is even more slack. When my bike was stolen I first tried a Transition Smuggler and absolutely hated it!

Image

(your typical mtbike geometry these days)
 
#9 ·
So for comparison (no, I didn't normalize for a specific fork, just googling some stats):
Bandit: 68.5°
Smuggler: 65°
Mayhem v1: 67°
Izzo: 66° (looks way more slack than that even based on the photo)
JEFFSY 66°
Exie: 67.2°
Ripley: 65.5°

Some of these suggestions are extremely slack
 
#11 ·
My Specialized Chisel is 68 and my Epic HT is 68.5. My Chumba Sendero on order will be 67.5. All pretty close to what you like and there are lots more out there. 68.5 is more on the “XC” side of things nowadays but I have no issues riding any of mine in CTX. Looking at XC frames would be the thing to do in my opinion.
 
#13 ·
Slightly beside the point.
But you should get 51mm offset fork instead of 44mm if you prioritize fast handling.

That 7mm extra offset, though increase wheelbase length by 7mm, reduce trail value by 7mm. 7mm reduction in trail value help making the handling feel snappier.

While the trend is to transit to 44mm offset on every mtb fork for extra stability.
Manitou R7 Pro and Fox 34 SC still can be bought with 51mm offset and Cannondale Lefty is available with 55mm offset.
 
#14 ·
A reversed angleset can steepen up the HTA by 2 degrees. That would bring a bike with a 66 HTA pretty close to your preferred 68.5. Could open up some possibilities.

 
#24 ·
A reversed angleset can steepen up the HTA by 2 degrees. That would bring a bike with a 66 HTA pretty close to your preferred 68.5. Could open up some possibilities.

Hrm, interesting. How bomber are these? I run 140mm and bottom out as it is and once even bent a steer tube (although that was free riding). My interest is definitely piqued.
 
#20 ·
So for comparison (no, I didn't normalize for a specific fork, just googling some stats):
Bandit: 68.5°
Smuggler: 65°
Mayhem v1: 67°
Izzo: 66° (looks way more slack than that even based on the photo)
JEFFSY 66°
Exie: 67.2°
Ripley: 65.5°

Some of these suggestions are extremely slack
The Ripley has a HTA of 66.5, the Ripley AF is 65.5.

So, a Ripley at 66.5 then slap a 1 degree angle set headset in it and you’re at 67.5…