Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

1up USA Bike Rack Review

1 reading
17K views 17 replies 18 participants last post by  Gwen1  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
Tire Motor vehicle Wheel Automotive tire Mode of transport


1Up USA is famous for their bike trainers so we were excited at the opportunity to try their bike racks. At first glance, it looks like a science project as the whole unit looks CNC'd and the bike retention mechanism looks unlike any we've seen before. But as we used it extensively, we learned about the logic behind the design. We took a look at the user reviews on Mtbr and it exhibited a staggering 4.8/5 stars with 96 reviews.

This is a unit of the highest quality and it folds up in to such a small package when shipped or stored. It can get work with one tray or be expanded like a Lego system in to a versatile multi-bike rack.

Furthermore, it plays on both ends of the spectrum. It can be the smallest, incognito rack available. Or it can be a massive four bike carrier ready for biggest road trip you can outline on Google Maps. In both configurations, it uses all the same trays. It's a modular system so you just add trays on to the base carrier.

For our road trip from San Jose, CA to Bend, Oregon, we recruited one of these four-bike behemoths and were surprised to see our friend deliver the rack to us inside his Toyota Prius. "What," I asked?? Did he forget to bring all the trays? It turns out the rack collapses into a very compact unit in a transformation that would make any Transformers fan happy. Bend your knees when you lift it though as this configuration weighs close to 100 lbs. It is all aluminum but with beefy trays to handle such a load.


For a bike rack, a hitch mount unit is the best solution. It is out of harm's way from low garage roofs and overhangs. It is much more quiet than a roof rack since it doesn't whistle or roar with the wind. And most important, it doesn't degrade your fuel mileage. A roof rack will degrade your gas mileage by about 1-2 mpg when empty and a staggering 4-5 mph when bikes are mounted. These numbers get worse too if you drive over 70 mph. Over the life of the car, that is just a lot of money wasted on gas.

We wish all autos came with hitch mounts as it is the perfect bike carrying solution. But alas, it is always assumed that you want to tow something big when you want a vehicle with a hitch so very few cars offer it as an option from the factory. But it is not difficult to get a hitch installed in your car from outfits like U-Haul or Etrailer.com

What you want from a hitch rack is that it's out of the way when you don't need it but versatile when you do. You want to be able to load the bike easily and remove the bikes without much drama. And when you're driving, you don't want to be bothered by the rack. It should be quiet, secure and wobble free with the bikes not damaging each other.

So this is where the 1upUsa shines. Mounting the bike cannot be easier as you open the tray arms, load the bike and close the tray arms. It really is that simple. Small bike, big bike, road bike, fat bike, 29er, etc. When unloading the bike, you have to lift up a lever then you can open up the arms. This is done one at the time and the pro move is just to open one arm and roll the bike out. To open the second arm requires three hands as the bike will be unsupported and will want to fall sideways unless you support it.



The bike can be mounted on the center of the rack or it can be moved almost a foot back or forward as the arms will lock it in its final position. This movement is key as it allows you mount two bikes on adjacent racks with minimal contact. There's always interference between handlebars, seats or pedals so flexibility in positioning the bikes is key. With this flexibility, 1upusa was able to place the trays very close to each other. This means the bikes take less room and there is less weight away from the car that can produce leverage stress on the rack.



Key Strengths:
  • No rubber, foam, or plastic pieces to degrade in the sun.
  • No part of the rack contacts the frame of the bike.
  • Folds up small enough for any trunk.
  • Small fold-up size allows for storage anywhere - even the floor of a small closet.
  • Very sturdy. Zero wobble in the hitch (2-inch version)
  • No assembly at all. Just take it out of the box and insert into hitch.
  • Very solid, extremely well built to last
  • Easiest rack I've ever used to fold up, rock back, install on vehicle, add/remove bike, even assemble cause it comes assembled!
  • Doesn't stick very far out (can close garage door without removing or folding up)
  • They shipped the same day from order
  • Can run with just 1, and easily throw the add-ons for 2 more when I take my kids riding
  • The rack looks awesome with its materials and construction
  • Just an ingenious design for compactness and modularity
Weaknesses:
  • 2 rack system is a bit heavy at 50 lbs.
  • Not cheap and a bit more expensive than the competition
  • Can block license plate when folded up
  • Very small company and customer support delays have been reported
  • Lever mechanism can be stiff and creaky
  • Opening the second arm can require three hands since the bike needs to be supported from falling.

Bottom Line:

We're really stretching here to find weaknesses as this is one of the best designed racks today. In the areas where it really matters, ease of use and out of mind, this rack is a home run.

What do you think? Can you compare this to others that you've tried?

 

Attachments

#2 ·
I have been looking for a new rack. This would be perfect if the height when folded could be adjusted as to not block the license plate of a pick up. My ancient Yakima gets me pulled over without bikes and that's a square tube blocking 2 1/2" of the plates center.
 
#4 ·
I bought one of these after several encounters with the Yakima warranty dept.(he asked me if I was using my rack during the winter,What is that?)

Hauled my 50lb Sinister R9(long) no problems. Best money I ever spent,IT IS!!!!!
 
#6 ·
I love mine, I had another brand on the back of my Samurai but it bounced so much it wore through the rubber and scratched my Fargo frame ( unacceptable, it's a constant embarrassment). The One-Up works great and takes the horrible Samurai suspension in stride. Plus it's from Wisconsin what could be better?
 
#11 ·
Francis: If you just roll the bike to the left or right, or turn the handlebars slightly, when loading or unloading, the entire "three arm problem" goes away. For any readers, this is as easy as any other mount I have ever used.

To be specific, open the arms to the vertical or slightly past vertical position. You will learn in one try what works best for your specific bike(s). Load the rear wheel then either rolling your bike a little further backwards or twisting the handlebars, load the front wheel. Center the bike, then holding the bike with one hand, use the other to close/compress the arms, one at a time.

The mechanism to tilt the rack is a bit awkward to reach, but once you are used to it, it uses much less effor than the Thule mechanism.

Hope this helps.
 
#16 ·
I'm trying to imagine how one person could unlock the pivot to drop the bikes to lift the hatch of your vehicle with 4 bikes on there. That is a monster lever with a fair amount of weight. Do you need a second person to lift on the end while you pull that lever to unlock it?
 
#17 ·
Just received my 1up and cant say enough good things. I ordered on Monday and rack was at my house in 3 days. I was amazed that there was no building required. With previous racks I had to enlist a mechanical engineer. The rack was honestly from the box on the car in 5 minutes. It's a little pricy but the warranty is rock solid. If you are looking for a new rack, do yourself a favor, skip the plastic POC racks and buy a 1up!