Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
61 - 70 of 70 Posts
Seems like the normal experience for American and Japanese companies kind of apply.

If you buy a Toyota everything from the Lexus to the Corolla will be quality - differences between the two performance-wise but you can be assured of getting a decent product.If you buy a Ford F-150 or a Mustang you'll have a decent experience. If you buy a Fiesta with an automatic transmission...

On a side note - to make my SRAM SX groupset functional - since I have a HG freehub the choice is between the SRAM NX Eagle cassette or this Sunrace cassette -


The Sunrace cassette is lighter and a few bucks more - all I care about is shifting though. Should I go SRAM NX or Sunrace?
 
I have SRAM on 2 bikes. GX and X01. So finicky and shifts are and never have been smooth. Will replace with Shimano when the drivetrain wears out.
Adjust/check the B screw with the suspension at 30% sag (if FS) Every time I encounter a poor shifting SRAM drivetrain, an incorrectly adjusted B screw is the main problem.
 
Speaking strictly low end here - but "low end" being $2500 - $3000 full suspension nowadays, I just switched from Deore SLX 10 speed to SRAM Eagle SX w/ NX rear derailleur.

So far after a handful of rides, the experience has been abysmal. First ride, SX shifter eats a cable. Everything was shifting OK before, no indication that this would happen. Dump it back at the shop (it's a brand new bike, I don't want to touch it if the shifter pod is bad) , they replace the cable, everything seems OK, maybe a fluke.

Everything shifts like crap after a few days. I say screw it and go back to my old tinkering ways. Get the SRAM B-limit gauge. Set up everything perfect. Seems OK-ish.

Next ride- Start out OK, by end of ride it's shifting terrible. Look at the cable, seems to ghost shift both up and down regardless of tension. Turns out two of the twelve cogs are straight up bent. Bend them back like truing a disc brake. Shifting back to normal. I've been extremely gentle on this bike.

Never had this happen in like 15 years of riding. I can't speak for higher end groupsets but SX is borderline unuseable for just normal riding.

Also my Rockshox Judy had a broken damper and leaking fork seals brand new (manufacturing defect? warranty fixed though I guess)

For anyone saying "well that's their lowest end groupset", the $3300 Stumpjumper Alloy comes with full SX nowadays for reference. This is like department store bike levels of reliability.

I sold the Judy and might put on an NX cassette (bike has a hyperglide freehub) just to make this thing rideable.
SX is probably de worst derailleur ever made. It's that bad.
 
My current experience, top level is all good. I have never used anything recently below mid tier, so no experience.

-I had a negative experience with some 2015ish XTR brakes. My current XTR brakes are great.
-I did not like the feel of the "Hyperglide+" on my XTR. Also don't like how four cogs of the cassette are aluminum and wear much faster than the Sram cassette. Also, they are expensive, so no postives there at all. But I did buy a Garbaruk cassette to replace the XTR and put a KMC chain on. I now like that setup better than my Sram bike. Shifts feel much better to me all around, cassette is way cheaper, and machined like a Sram cassette.
-Code brakes are still currently my favorite.
-Prefer XD driver over MS. But that's a minor issue.

Just switching out the cassette on the XTR bike totally changed the way I feel about Shimano.

If you buy a Fiesta with an automatic transmission...
Buy a real transmission, and it is a wonderful car ;)
 
Have done that already on both the hardtail and FS bike with SRAM. I've come to the conclusion SRAM is junk.
Maybe you just don't like the 'feel' of SRAM's shifting? I personally prefer it over Shimano... Got 5 bikes in the garage with either GX or X01 on them and the 6th has XT. The Shimano bike shifts nice, but I definitely prefer SRAM over it.
 
Not only do I not like the feel, it never shifts well and often skips. Make some adjustments and it works for a while then goes back to being finicky.

I have 3 other bikes with Shimano and they all shift perfectly and smooth as butter.
Rarely or ever have to futz with adjusting them.
 
61 - 70 of 70 Posts