Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

Why I'll Buy A Frame Only Next Time

3.1K views 54 replies 42 participants last post by  Hurricane Jeff  
#1 ·
I am pretty sure that I'm going to end up replacing the brakes on my current bike.

Once that's done, the only stuff on my current bike that's going to be stock is the frame and suspension. Why did I pay for the whole bike, when I really only used 1 out of every 10 components? Ha! That's how they get ya, I guess.
 
#35 ·
On my MTBs I’m lucky enough that I can buy complete. My only real requirements are Performance level Fox suspension and GX. I may upgrade a wheelset and tires on an XC bike but almost never on my trail bikes.

My road bike is a completely different beast, I am mucho picky about what hangs on the skinny tire beast. Mainly from a fit perspective but I also won’t ride SRAM brakes on the road.
 
#41 ·
I've done it both ways (build a new frame with used parts) and also purchased used with most of the components to my liking and swapped a few things (always a different wheel set).

Most of what I buy/build is not the absolute newest/latest/greatest/most popular so costs can be somewhat more realistic.

These days, for new frame vs complete bike: laziness, and a "good enough" mix of components on a pre-built steed wins over buying a frame (+ maybe fork) and building.
 
#42 ·
Making your own a la carte build is I think more interesting and you are chosing the components you want.
 
#50 ·
Pre-built bikes are usually more economical than custom builds so long as you're not changing any components. As soon as you start "upgrading" parts you are whittling away the value. If you look at a new bike and immediately think to yourself "That bike will be perfect . . . as soon as I change X, Y and Z", you're in trouble. This is especially true if the shop is not doing any kind of exchange/swap or discount on the changed parts.

Swapping parts to get proper fit is one thing. A shop should be willing to work with you on things like cranks and stems if you legitimately need different sizes than what comes on the bike. Most shops have a collection of "take-off" parts from previously swapped out items that they should be able to dig into without incurring any cost. But don't expect a shop to do this for more than one or at most two fit related components without upcharging you. If they have to open a new crankset to swap out the cranks already installed on a bike, expect a charge. They can't resell those take-off cranks that were installed, test ridden and have no packaging for the same price as the new-in-the-box cranks you're getting.

If you're immediately upgrading drivetrain or suspension parts on a new bike because you think you need better performance, you should just build a frame up from scratch. If you have that mindset, chances are nothing on a pre-fab bike will satisfy you. Especially when you start digging into the nitty-gritty of the build. Nearly all pre-built bikes skimp on components that most buyers don't immediately consider like bottom brackets and headsets. You are not getting a Wheels Mfg BB or a King headset off-the-rack. If you're already coveting such parts before you even buy a bike, just do a custom build.
 
#51 ·
My first MTB that I got in 2018 started out as Jamis Dragonslayer, and ended up as a Stanton Sherpa Gen3. The only original part left, is the front hub of my Plus sized wheelset.

I learned a lot along the way, and now I know exactly what type of bike and fitment I prefer.

Part of all this was trying to find the perfect fitment, but also filling that void I've always had from never owning a cool BMX during my childhood.
 
#53 ·
All of my bike builds were build up to the frame. The two builds that required intensive spare parts searching were these two:
this one because of the rims and the fork
Image

and this one too because of the rims and the fork
Image