Hi everyone,
I'm about to buy the Chisel 2021 model, either the base model or the Comp, depending on which I'm able to find. Here's what I'm wondering: I have an older Rockshox SID XX 100mm (the 2016 A4 model) which is well operating, recently a full service done. I'm wondering how the older SID compares to the Judy Gold that's specced on the Chisel Comp with regards to performance? I realize the weight is about 500g lighter but is it worth keeping the Judy Gold as it has newer technology than the older SID ? I also believe the Judy is convertible to 120mm if I want to do that (the geometry has enough wiggle room for that), whereas the SID doesn't allow this (there's a thread on MTBR about it). Also the service interval seems to be (twice?) longer on Rockshox forks from 2017 onwards. I do think that the Judy Silver TK version on the base model is probably still lower spec than the SID, but I'm more interested in how the Judy Gold fares against the older SID.
Also I'm 6ft tall with very long legs (35.5" inseam) and arms, generally like riding a larger bike than I should be. The size XL is recommended from 185cm (about 6ft 1 in) onwards, has similar reach to my current Kona Unit XL which I've found to be fine with 60mm stem. I would think a Large might fit, too, but I might need to use 80 to 90mm stem as the reach is about 30mm shorter than on the XL. That said, I did own a Specialized Epic HT 2017 in size Large and it was fine with a 80mm stem and 20mm setback seatpost. Also, if I decide to convert to 120mm then it also shortens the reach slightly, which would favor the XL. Stack is not an issue for me, as a long-legged I need stack and I can always play with spacers. What do you think which size I should have? Have no opportunity to test one unfortunately.