Strange journey.
I got the Chisel because I wanted to do Gravel/Greenway with the option of jumping onto an MTB trail (which around here are mostly XC with some occasional technical) I was steered well to this bike. I had and MTB bike, so I didn't want to spend much, thinking of it as a training bike.
Jump ahead a year. I mostly stay on greenway/gravel and do road/sidewalk. Hard surfaces 90% of the time. So I thought "get a gravel bike or a road bike and avoid the gravel". SO I tested a Diverge. I jumped on a Ruebaix and a Domane. Even tried a cyclocross bike (Crux) I didn't like the road bikes that had little clearance (what if a rock gets caught there?) The cyclocross gearing was too limiting. So, back to the Diverge. But maybe I should just avoid gravel and get the bike I liked the most: Ruebaix (and I liked the Domane steering a lot)
Well, this is a bad time to buy a bike. Little stock, new year about to drop but not yet. So I took off the Fast Track 3.1/3.3" and put on Trigger Pro 38c to test out the "Do I really want gravel tires or slicks?" to help me find the bike I want. I even, for shits and giggles got on a $5k Roubaix with Di2 and Ultegra set that had me DREAMING of Di2, haha.
So I put on the Trigger and went out. Blew my previous times away, hands down. Went for a looong ride today. PRs all over the place. Interestingly, PR's over my Demo runs with the Diverge AND the Roubaix. (On a hill, the Roubaix was 8 seconds faster, but I was also fresher) but the ability of the Chisel with it's shock to just roll over root bumps in the greenway, bridge bumps, etc had me going faster overall. It climbs pretty good.
Damn. I NEVER expected my Chisel to be within 10 seconds of the Roubaix. I BOOKED on that Roubaix when I tested it. I was about 1.5 hours into my ride today when I beat that time away with the Chisel. Which tells me, they are close enough for greenways. I just don't have the higher gears for the road (hence higher road speed)
Maybe, one day, I'll want a Roubaix for a road bike. But for now, it seems the Chisel is an entirely new bike that rolls much faster with less effort, but also can handle so much with confidence, because of that shock.
So now I'm thinking of re-reading this forum and just upgrading some parts here and there.
Nothing like STRAVA times to get past your "new bike" desires with some cold hard facts: Your old bike with better wheels is pretty darned good.