Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

Fake Avid CS GS 3 rotor?

4.6K views 5 replies 3 participants last post by  abelfonseca  
#1 ·
Caveat emptor...

I ordered a new Avid CS GS 3 160 mm rotor off ebay for $7 shipped. When I got it and examined it closely I began to suspect it was a fake.

Using the info found in the thread "Rotors "striping," I noted that:

1. There is no "Multi-directional surface grounding," it's all one direction.
2. The "Sharp laser-like engravings" do seem somewhat sharp, but after I rubbed over the lettering it appears white, not black. The arrows and text do appear in the same areas on the rotor, though.
3. I cannot weigh it, so that is moot.
4. The Avid site has a CS GS 3 shown in the 2012 parts catalog, for the same size. This one is new, and I don't care if it's 2 year old.
5. The inset color is black.

I can't find any occurrences of any CS GS 3s on the 'net IDd as fakes. Attached is a pics but it doesn't show the detail very good.
The red arrow points to the Avid logo, while the yellow lines denote direction of surface grounding.
 

Attachments

#5 ·
Here's the reply I got from the seller after describing the fakery:

"1. We apologize for all upset and inconvenience that we bring to you.
2. Thanks for your advise on our product.
3. Our resource department will fallow up with this issue and go deeper into the manufacture.
4. Returning is accepted anytime if needed. (full refund)"

I'll just go ahead and keep it and see how it performs. At least I get to trot out this gem:
 

Attachments