My brother is looking to get into riding and he's got $1000 Cdn ($900 US) to spend on a hardtail. I'm gonna be pushing him to get into dirt jumping and I want it to be a bike I can steal sometimes for assorted freeriding when I want a break from a full squish but realistically it's probably gonna be used for riding casually around town (ie. to work) quite a bit and also for XC trail riding occasionally.
I've been pushing him to get a Specialized P2 Cr-Mo because Cr-Mo bikes are so cool but why don't they make a Cr-Mo P3? I realize it's out of his price range but what's wrong with Cr-Mo that they won't use it for their top of the line bike? I though Cr-Mo is the more 'legit' material to make a HT from due to it's feel. Many of the top HTs (ie: Blk Market Mob) are Cr-Mo.
Anyways, he's gonna wanna buy from a brand like Specialized, Norco (BigFoot?) or Kona (Scrap?) that offers a lot of good components for the buck. What do you guys think is a good choice?
I've been pushing him to get a Specialized P2 Cr-Mo because Cr-Mo bikes are so cool but why don't they make a Cr-Mo P3? I realize it's out of his price range but what's wrong with Cr-Mo that they won't use it for their top of the line bike? I though Cr-Mo is the more 'legit' material to make a HT from due to it's feel. Many of the top HTs (ie: Blk Market Mob) are Cr-Mo.

Anyways, he's gonna wanna buy from a brand like Specialized, Norco (BigFoot?) or Kona (Scrap?) that offers a lot of good components for the buck. What do you guys think is a good choice?