Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 8 of 8 Posts

Freda

· I like all members! LOL
Joined
·
66 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
Well I never considered a Giant unil today and I think I'm sold. But I have a delima. First this bike is for my Fiance. He rides hard and he weights 195lbs. Now we don't jump big or take big drops. I would say 3 feet or so to both of thosee and he never really drops onto flat ground.

So... Trance or Anthem for him? Currently we ride a lot of single track with short steep up and down hill sections where handling is important due to rough rocky terrain. There is one bowl in the course with a few drops a couple feet to a down hill landing and some jumps to get a couple feet of air on the trail. Many tree gates. A person we ride with has a Trance but I'm wondering if an Anthem would be better. Would it handle this?

More, we are moving to Germany at the end of the year so that terrain will also be a consern for this decision. What if the terrain is worse with more jumps or drops... I'm sure it will have more climbs than we currently see in North Texas...

Tonight is my fiance' first race and I think this might be something he does a couple times a year... So which would you choice? Please help...

Oh ya, which model of each is spec'd the best for the $$ and where is the best place as far as prices to find one?

Thanks!!! :thumbsup:
 
Discussion starter · #5 ·
Ok, so if we go with an aluminum Trance, which one has the best bang for the buck? Thanks for all of your help!! :)
 
I would have to vote for a Trance as well. It is a great all around bike. The Anthem is a good bike as well, depends on terrain and how you ride. Anthem is more XC, Trance is more all mountain. Anthem for a climber/racer, Trance for a more all around rider, especially a bigger/taller one. I have a 2009 Trance X2, a great value. If you have the cash, go X1. Save a little money for an adjustable seatpost, it makes a huge difference.
 
Discussion starter · #8 ·
What would a good deal be on a 2009 X2? How much is the 2011 X1 at the LBS's?
 
1 - 8 of 8 Posts