Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 21 Posts

bovinda

· Registered
Joined
·
51 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
Got a new bike a couple months ago. It's great, but there's nothing to indicate what gear I'm on when I shift - I have to look down and see if I want to know for sure. Is it possible to get some sort of indicator showing approximately where my gears are, so I can just look at my handlebars rather than down at my feet? Or would it require an entirely new gear system?

Maybe I'm lazy, but it would be handy... :) Having had other bikes with them, I miss them!
 
He may have a set of grip shifts that dont have the numbers, my first bike was the same way
But here is the thing does it really matter? I mean at least for me I didnt care which number gear I was in and I did everything by feel.
 
The only way you can get an indicator is by getting a new set of shifters...and if they're already high-end, you don't want to downgrade just for that. You'll become accustomed to it after a few rides. My bf just got a new bike without the indicators, too and it only took him a couple of rides to be able to tell me exactly what gear he was in at any particular point in time. I rarely even look at my shifters, either. All I need to know is that if it's getting hard to pedal, I need to shift. :p
 
Berkley said:
Higher end shifters can come without them (SRAM X.9, X.0, Shimano XTR?).
but lets not get confused here, jsut becasue the little numbers aren't pictured dosent at all mean that it is not a great shifter... Ex. the X.7 have the numbers and they are some of the greatest and most widely used shifters ever
 
And if they are grip shifts (you still havent stated what kind of shifters they are) you could get clear label-maker sheets and print out 1-9 or 1-8 or whatever and slap it on there... just an idea
 
Discussion starter · #13 ·
I believe they're SRAM X-9, according to Specialized's web page (I'm riding a 2008 Enduro SL Expert.)

It's no problem when I'm riding flat 'cuz I can feel the difference easily, but the variability of trail riding keeps me double-checking - it's harder to get a feel for what I'm at.

Could I use one of the indicators that mrbisoy posted?
 
I recently shifted from X-7 shifters with gear indicators to X-9 trigger shifters. At first it was a pain in the butt and frustrated me. It has taken me a little while to get used to them but now I find myself relying and paying attention more closely to my pedal cadence, knowing how hard I am pedaling and maintaining an even rhythm rather than worrying about what gear I am in. It may sound stupid but I think it has made me a stronger rider.
 
I have X9 shifters and I love that there's no gear indicator. I agree that it is all about FEEL. I find it strange when I'm out in trails and my buddies ask what gear they should be in.
 
Discussion starter · #17 ·
I guess I'm just worried about inadvertently stretching my chain out by crossing my gears. Sometimes I find I've shifted most of the way up on my rear before I shift out of first on my front, for example. How do you guys avoid that? Is it just experience?
 
My previous bike, a Trek 4500 didn't have numbers on the shifters, but it had "dividing" lines spaced at gear 3 and 6 vertically. There was a little "needle" that moved left or right when you shifted up or down respectively.

I also found it funny when my mates would ask what gear I am in, as it made no difference to me whatsoever. I purely went by feel.

My new bike has SRAM X.7 shifters and I think it's nice to see what gear I am in, but it doesn't affect my riding at all. I still shift and ride based on what I feel. Regardless of what gear I am in, or what gear my friends are in.

:)
 
bovinda said:
I guess I'm just worried about inadvertently stretching my chain out by crossing my gears. Sometimes I find I've shifted most of the way up on my rear before I shift out of first on my front, for example. How do you guys avoid that? Is it just experience?
i dont have indicators and always know what gear im in.. it should never, ever be necessary to look down. you only have to remember what your left shifter is in, the rest is logical and habit.

you only have 3 clicks on the left shifter. if you're in the smallest ring up front (first click) you should be in the biggest ring out back. theres not much need for any gear spread at all in the small ring.. so only use the biggest and second biggest rear gears.

so now you know if you're in 1st up front, you're on one of the two big gears out back.

so if its a hard climb, you're always in small up front big out back. if thats too easy, shift your left up to the middle ring. you can use any and all gear combos in the middle ring..

if you're spinning too fast, click the right shifter down a gear.. keep doing that until you have no more gears. this puts you in the middle front small rear combo, which is a smooth shift to the big ring.

if it gets harder, click the right shifter up until you're out of gears. if its still too hard you can shift your front to the small ring, and you already know the rear is in the big gear too, which is a smooth shift to the small ring.

you never need to hop from the big front small rear to the small front small rear because you would have first shifted to the middle front ring and shifted through its range.

so the only thing that matters is if you're in 1, 2, or 3. your pedaling effort reminds you what one you're in as well. proper shifting tells you what gear you're in!

its in your best interest to utilize your gear spread properly.. you'll always know you're in the right gear!
 
1 - 20 of 21 Posts