Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 24 Posts

xmangox

· Registered
Joined
·
502 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
I'm going to upgrade my shifters, derailluers, crank, casette to either a full SRAM X0 or Shimano XT or XTR system.

Which one would be the best for a 210lb XC rider? I ride 5 to 6 times a week, lots of technical and XC stuff. I'm afraid the XTR would be too fragile but I want an opinon from the masses.

I'm worried about durablity and ease of maintance.
 
If really is personal preference. I have bikes with both groups here at home, and they both perform great. I do seem to have to do fewer adjustments with the sram groups I have, but part of the problem is that I use the shimano shadow rear derailleur, which is know for losing adjustment easier. So pick which you like and run with it.
 
XTR is not fragile, its lighter because it uses more expensive materials that are equal or stronger to what it use on XT. The only weak part on the XTR group is the carbon cage of the shadow derailleur but you could use an XT or Saint here. The XTR cranks are probably some of the stronger cranks you can buy other than Saint which are made of the same alloy, XT are made of different alloy that not as strong or as light. If you go Shimano you could do XTR cranks with XT everything else since they perform about the same. I have been using a complete 07 XTR drivetrain on my bike since it came out and the only thing I have replaces is the rear derailluer because I wanted the Shadow.
 
X0 triggers and rear derailleur, XTR front derailleur, XTR crankset, and XT cassette. I like SRAM shifters/derailleurs a lot more for mountain (the 1:1 ratio is a lot less finicky) but shimano cranks and cassettes are my favorite.
 
Discussion starter · #5 ·
theextremist04 said:
X0 triggers and rear derailleur, XTR front derailleur, XTR crankset, and XT cassette. I like SRAM shifters/derailleurs a lot more for mountain (the 1:1 ratio is a lot less finicky) but shimano cranks and cassettes are my favorite.
I've just ordered this exact setup!! Thanks guys for the help.
 
I agree with this setup, you practically never have to adjust the shifters esp. if you use a sealed cable system. You're probably not going to notice much of difference between XT or XTR for the FD. If you can afford XTR cranks than those are great, but I think Raceface Deus cranks beat the rest of the shimano line esp. when you consider the price.
 
iceaxe said:
I agree with this setup, you practically never have to adjust the shifters esp. if you use a sealed cable system. You're probably not going to notice much of difference between XT or XTR for the FD. If you can afford XTR cranks than those are great, but I think Raceface Deus cranks beat the rest of the shimano line esp. when you consider the price.
XT cranks are just a good too, just heavier. I prefered to lose the grams in my belly instead of my wallet. It's still tempting to buy but no benefit other than weight doesn't make much sense.

I run XTR RDR with XT cassette and shifters. I am thinking about switching to twist shifters because alot of racers I know use them and swear by them. A lot of pros use them. They are crazy light too and very inexpensive. XTR triggers are stupid expensive.
 
flip a coin, both great. i used to be a bandwagon anti-shimano guy but i LOVE the 2009 stuff and am now sold on shimano for sure, and that includes Hubs and Brakes and in fact Shimano brakes are my favorite now for sure
 
I'd rock the Shimano cassette, cranks, and front derailleur. I'd use SRAM shifters and rear derailleur. I've never been able to justify the cost of the x0 for the marginal weight savings. x9 works just as well.

I feel that the Shimano cassettes and front derailleur shift better. The SRAM cassettes seem to have the occasional QC issue and wears out quicker. But I prefer the crispness (almost clunkiness) of the SRAM rear derailleurs. The new Shimano Shadow stuff is pretty good though.

I've never liked Raceface cranks because of the crank/spindle interface. It can wear out and develop slop. The Shimano design with pinchbolts is much better. Though the new XTR still seems to do quite well without them.
 
I had a really good set up on my Commencal last year: SLX crank (cheaper than XT, arguably better looking and just as stiff at only the slightest weight penalty), xt cassette, front d and rear d (shadow) and xtr shifters. System worked very well, have since switched the bike to full XTR which I prefer, but this one is waaaay more affordable. Chuck sram in for shifters/ rear der, - go shimano xt ish for front d, if you go sram.
 
mtnkiwi said:
I had a really good set up on my Commencal last year: SLX crank (cheaper than XT, arguably better looking and just as stiff at only the slightest weight penalty)
The weight will almost equal out if you get an XT aluminum small chain ring. You could get it even lower with an XTR BB.
 
theextremist04 said:
X0 triggers and rear derailleur, XTR front derailleur, XTR crankset, and XT cassette. I like SRAM shifters/derailleurs a lot more for mountain (the 1:1 ratio is a lot less finicky) but shimano cranks and cassettes are my favorite.
Complete newby here.
Can you mix and match SRAM and Shimano components?
If I like a certain Shimano shifters, I can get those and SRAM rear Derailleur?

Thanks
WP
 
I am a twisty man, so my choice is easy, and I have enjoyed a painfree drivetrain for 15 years. Shimano FD's are on my bikes though, they seem to be the easiest to dial in for me compared to others.
 
widespreadpanic said:
Complete newby here.
Can you mix and match SRAM and Shimano components?
If I like a certain Shimano shifters, I can get those and SRAM rear Derailleur?

Thanks
WP
Yes and no... you can't mix and match the rear shifting because shimano has a 2:1 cable pull ratio, SRAM is 1:1. Front der. shifting can be mixed, though.
 
Personally, i think you should look at the individual components as oppose to looking at the group (or brand), and i think that should go for all components. But as for the drivetrain...

Crankset: XTR M970 - Ultra stiff, ultra light, superior shifting performance. Don't be deceived by it's lightness as most people associate this with having compromised strength. It in fact uses higher grade aluminum (duralumin or 2000 series aluminum) to achieve increased strength but lowering weight. This series of aluminum is second strongest to 7000 series, which is what Thomson stems use.

Front derailleur: XTR M970 just to go with the crankset. But i'm not sure if there's much discrepancy between an XTR and XT FD, so i probably wouldn't notice the difference.

Rear derailleur: XT M772 shadow - because i don't trust the carbon cage on the XTR and at the time of deciding which to get, apparently the XTR shadow had some manufacturing faults.

Cassette: SRAM PG-990 - i like the red bits :cool:, but seriously, it's SRAM's flagship cassette and the XTR is much too expensive.

Shifters: XTR M970 - Shifting features, such as double release shift, instant shift when you press the trigger (as in you don't have to press and release, it shifts as soon as you press), use thumb or finger for the trigger, buttery feel, ergonomics. Why not SRAM? I prefer the 2:1 ratio because it (inherently) allows me to shift gears with less stroke of the paddle, so i find that i can shift faster. Likewise, SRAM only 'inherently' has less margin for error in shifting because of it's 1:1 ratio, but if you tune your shimano stuff right, you will also achieve accurate shifting. I also don't like the ergonomics of the SRAM shifters.

Chain: Not sure, i go with SRAM for some unknown reason.

But anyways, this is me of course. Everyone is different. :)
 
I ran SRAM XO for about a year. It was light, and shifted fine in all kinds of conditions. After longer rides, I noticed that my thumbs were very sore. I attributed this to using my thumbs for both up- and down-shifting. I tried some XO twist-shifters, but that actually resulted in more soreness. Long story short is that I'm now running Shimano M771 stuff now because (1) my thumbs don't do all the shifting work, and (2) the spring tension is much lighter.
 
1 - 20 of 24 Posts