Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
61 - 78 of 78 Posts
I don't really see why you're offended. Also, I don't believe everything, but I do follow them on social media and I see a lot of people complaining. Your experience 5 years ago is grand, but doesn't do much for me right now.
Never said I was offended. Just offering up a counter point, including when everyone’s customer service sucked. Hopefully whatever you buy doesn’t suck.
 
Discussion starter · #62 · (Edited)
Never said I was offended. Just offering up a counter point, including when everyone’s customer service sucked. Hopefully whatever you buy doesn’t suck.
Sorry, maybe I misinterpreted your last line from your last response. I thought you were being snarky. The same way this last line seems kind of snarky. I can’t tell. Anyhow, thanks for the counter point.

In general-

I’ve been checking out the Propain still, but their frame warranty is only 3 years. Giant’s is only 2. I guess that’s not bad, necessarily, just not as good as other makers have become. The Enduros in the S4 size look ok, but still pricey for 2-4 year old nos. Ari doesn’t have anything until at least September.

The geo of the Spindrift is like exactly perfect with a 50mm stem though. The Pivot seems like a really good choice except for the price. Honestly after this latest maintenance nightmare I’m realizing that any bike that’s working well is better than any bike that’s not- durability and reliability along with customer service are really first in my mind at this exact moment.
 
Sorry, maybe I misinterpreted your last line from your last response. I thought you were being snarky. The same way this last line seems kind of snarky. I can’t tell. Anyhow, thanks for the counter point.

In general-

I’ve been checking out the Propain still, but their frame warranty is only 3 years. Giant’s is only 2. I guess that’s not bad, necessarily, just not as good as other makers have become. The Enduros in the S4 size look ok, but still pricey for 2-4 year old nos. Ari doesn’t have anything until at least September.

The geo of the Spindrift is like exactly perfect with a 50mm stem though. The Pivot seems like a really good choice except for the price. Honestly after this latest maintenance nightmare I’m realizing that any bike that’s working well is better than any bike that’s not- durability and reliability along with customer service are really first in my mind at this exact moment.
I definitely wouldn’t buy the Enduro if you are worried about maintenance. Mine needed several bearings every year. Before that I had an Ibis Ripmo AF and that was even worse with the bushings. Before that I had an alloy Giant Reign SX and that only needed one bearing in two really rough years of riding.
 
I rode my Enduro for a while in some really nasty conditions and never had issues with bearings seizing or failing, they did a good job with sealing them using secondary seals IMO. YMMV and I gather their QC on those frames went downhill after I got mine, but it replaced a bike that I had to do bearing work on monthly. The biggest issue I had with it was keeping the main pivot from coming loose, it would loosen and start creaking badly, no matter how I put it together, the bearings were fine though.

A lot of issues can also be solved by unbolting the linkage entirely and re-torquing to spec using the factory specified order. There is a specific order to torque the fittings to maintain alignment and I don't think it's always done by the factory correctly. Out of alignment frames will eat bearings.
 
I definitely wouldn’t buy the Enduro if you are worried about maintenance. Mine needed several bearings every year. Before that I had an Ibis Ripmo AF and that was even worse with the bushings. Before that I had an alloy Giant Reign SX and that only needed one bearing in two really rough years of riding.
I went through several sets of bearings a year with the 2016 Reign I had.
 
Discussion starter · #67 ·
Keep in mind the seat post insertion on the Spindrift is abysmal (same with Vampire). Not sure what size you’re looking at but it’s significantly shallower than almost anything else. Once they have that sorted it’ll be a real winner in my opinion.
Yeah, I saw that. My issue is generally the opposite, I have mine up towards the upper limit. I'm running a 200mm and the collar is a full 11cm above the frame insert. Long inseam and I tend to like my bikes like Garth likes his underwear- teeny and toasty. (Well not really, but I'm 6'1" which means I'm almost always in the middle of frame sizes, but my inseam is longish and my torso is short-ish, so going up tends to leave me too stretched out, so I tend to go with a L frame instead of XL). That's actually one thing that appeals to me about the Propain, I'm right in the sweet spot for one of their sizes.

I definitely wouldn’t buy the Enduro if you are worried about maintenance. Mine needed several bearings every year. Before that I had an Ibis Ripmo AF and that was even worse with the bushings. Before that I had an alloy Giant Reign SX and that only needed one bearing in two really rough years of riding.
Great to know. I had heard of frame problems, but had also heard Specialized was really good about replacing them.

---

Well, looks like it's down to the Pivot or Propain I think, unless I find an outrageous deal on a Megatower, which even though it's not what I had originally thought about because of the weight/climbing, looks like they can be pretty sweet deal from time to time and they seem bombproof.
 
Well, looks like it's down to the Pivot or Propain I think, unless I find an outrageous deal on a Megatower, which even though it's not what I had originally thought about because of the weight/climbing, looks like they can be pretty sweet deal from time to time and they seem bombproof.
I feel like i see megatowers for pretty good deals on Jenson more than occasionally.
Also is there a reason you're not looking at a SJ15? I had an Enduro and its a good bike but i was using the climb switch on that thing at all times.
 
Discussion starter · #70 ·
Just wanted to update this- I ended up pulling the trigger on a Yeti SB160. In the end the geometry fit what I was looking for and the price was borderline crazy. Plus the spec is AXS, which I like because my current bike is AXS, so being able to share parts easily is a huge plus. Yeti's have always seemed..kind of dentist bikes to me...but I guess I'm getting older ha.

It should be here next week hopefully. It's less travel than I originally wanted, but I think realistically for a bike that I actually want to pull out of the garage and ride on a daily or semi-daily, it's going to be perfect. The Propain was right there and honestly right now they are a really, really good deal too, but at least from what I can gather it's really more suited to park riding, which only works out to a small % of where I ride. Maybe next year I'll get a cheap double crown if I end up going to the park more. I do wish the Yeti came with Mavens or something other than Codes, but not that big of a deal to swap them out I guess.

FWIW, I also demo'd a Megatower in the process, but even sizing down it just felt too muted, too plush and maybe a little vague all around. Definitely a Cadillac bike.

Stoked!
 
Discussion starter · #73 · (Edited)
I’ve bought two bikes from them, one in the midst of Covid and I never had a problem with shipping, tracking, support when a box was delivered with a big hole in the side from the shipping company and stuff was damaged. Unlike most brands I can go on their site and buy all the weird linkage bolts, shock bolts, bearings, seals, axles and whatever else I may need. Most brands don’t even have info online much less actual parts availability.

Don’t believe what I or anyone else says on the internet. But whatever you think is right.
Lol, I'm sorry, but I just had to give a big old, "I told you so," after reading Pinkbike and the industry news along with the comments all over the place regarding YT....
 
Discussion starter · #75 · (Edited)
I wanted to touch back in on this, because I'm sure at some point someone will be Googling and it will lead to this. For reference, my other bike is a 150/160 "trail" bike with a wheelbase of 1260.

So, I've had exactly 5 rides on the SB160. The first two were on blueish black XC type trails, and I definitely felt over-biked. That said, with the rear shock set to the firm position, if I wasn't comparing directly to a very lively bike, I don't think I would have noticed. The next rides were on legit black/double black enduro and downhill trails.

Here are my take-aways:

- Climbing/pedaling. The bike climbs surprisingly well. Yes, it's a more muted and truck along feel, but in terms of efficiency, it climbs really well with the shock open or "firm." It feels really, really good out of the saddle on short punchy sprints. I honestly think the only thing that could/should be improved is to include a remote for the "firm" setting. Why not? I'd love to snap it on and off during punchy sprint climbs. Maybe on the V2.

-As to what the suspension is "good" at- I would say if you think about a graph, where Y is "goodness" and X is "speed+chunk" there is like a bimodal curve. For cruising along on moderately rough ground, slow to up to maybe 8-12mph let's say, the suspension is like riding on air. It's amazing. Pick up the the chunk a bit, and it starts to feel much firmer. Not bad, but definitely firmer in that riding envelope and it doesn't feel particularly plush.

Keep going with speed and chunk and you get to this zen like place where the travel feels infinite and you just seem to glide over everything. This includes cornering. It is like you're stuck to the ground, but at the same time hovering above all the rough stuff. Everyone's already said it before, but it's really amazing.

After the infamous fallout in a thread I started in General Discussion and mentioning actually knowing empirically how fast you're going, I'm not going to mention specifics, but empirically this bike absolutely flies down chunky, technical legit double black downhill- exactly what I was looking for. Confidence inspiring is an understatement, even without DH casings or inserts, and having tire pressures fairly high.

- I can't say enough good things about the Fox 38 so far. I'll probably take it in to our local shock wizard, but it feels really good from the get-go, especially in terms of stiffness compared to the Lyrik I'm coming from. It took me a while to get it dialed, and it still feels a little too firm, but that's just fiddling with it more.

-I love the X2 rear shock as well.

- Weight with Exo+ Assegai + Exo+ DHR II on DT Swiss 1501s and sealant, was 15.2kg with the stock saddle. Pretty dang good.

- This is the fastest bike I've ever ridden in and out of corners. I can't explain how it not only seems to hold speed, but generate speed effortlessly.

-Every review I read mentioned that the bike seemed to want to stay stuck on the ground, and my experience is the same. That's exactly what I was looking for, but if you want a "poppy" bike, this doesn't seem to do that very well.

-SRAM Code RSC brakes are horrible. Even coming from absolutely average XT brakes, these are terrible. Sram is just not impressing me with much these days. Extreme fade on even short downhills, an exceptionally stiff lever pull, and all the while it feels like trying to stop with two glass plates rubbing against each other. Zero bite whatsoever, except when you're going super slow and could actually use the modulation- then they have this insane bite. Ughh. Replacements are already ordered, these things would kill me at some point.

- The only thing this bike is just outright bad at so far (which is like saying a Ferrari is bad at towing) is climbing over technical stuff. While the geometry and balance are perfect for getting around corners and downhill fast, that makes the front end feel really heavy on climbs. I only mention in because to climb up to the great downhills around my area, there is usually some tech and I definitely noticed it. Not impossible, but it definitely takes a substantial amount of effort.

Your mileage may vary :LOL:
 
I wanted to touch back in on this, because I'm sure at some point someone will be Googling and it will lead to this. For reference, my other bike is a 150/160 "trail" bike with a wheelbase of 1260.

So, I've had exactly 5 rides on the SB160. The first two were on blueish black XC type trails, and I definitely felt over-biked. That said, with the rear shock set to the firm position, if I wasn't comparing directly to a very lively bike, I don't think I would have noticed. The next two rides were on legit black/double black enduro and downhill trails.

Here are my take-aways:

- Climbing/pedaling. The bike climbs surprisingly well. Yes, it's a more muted and truck along feel, but in terms of efficiency, it climbs really well with the shock open or "firm." It feels really, really good out of the saddle on short punchy sprints. I honestly think the only thing that could/should be improved is to include a remote for the "firm" setting. Why not? I'd love to snap it on and off during punchy sprint climbs. Maybe on the V2.

-As to what the suspension is "good" at- I would say if you think about a graph, where Y is "goodness" and X is "speed+chunk" there is like a bimodal curve. For cruising along on moderately rough ground, slow to up to maybe 8-12mph let's say, the suspension is like riding on air. It's amazing. Pick up the the chunk a bit, and it starts to feel much firmer. Not bad, but definitely firmer in that riding envelope and it doesn't feel particularly plush.

Keep going with speed and chunk and you get to this zen like place where the travel feels infinite and you just seem to glide over everything. This includes cornering. It is like you're stuck to the ground, but at the same time hovering above all the rough stuff. Everyone's already said it before, but it's really amazing.

After the infamous fallout in a thread I started in General Discussion and mentioning actually knowing empirically how fast you're going, I'm not going to mention specifics, but empirically this bike absolutely flies down chunky, technical legit double black downhill- exactly what I was looking for. Confidence inspiring is an understatement, even without DH casings or inserts, and having tire pressures fairly high.

- I can't say enough good things about the Fox 38 so far. I'll probably take it in to our local shock wizard, but it feels really good from the get-go, especially in terms of stiffness compared to the Lyrik I'm coming from. It took me a while to get it dialed, and it still feels a little too firm, but that's just fiddling with it more.

-I love the X2 rear shock as well.

- Weight with Exo+ Assegai + Exo+ DHR II on DT Swiss 1501s and sealant, was 15.2kg with the stock saddle. Pretty dang good.

- This is the fastest bike I've ever ridden in and out of corners. I can't explain how it not only seems to hold speed, but generate speed effortlessly.

-Every review I read mentioned that the bike seemed to want to stay stuck on the ground, and my experience is the same. That's exactly what I was looking for, but if you want a "poppy" bike, this doesn't seem to do that very well.

-SRAM Code RSC brakes are horrible. Even coming from absolutely average XT brakes, these are terrible. Sram is just not impressing me with much these days. Extreme fade on even short downhills, an exceptionally stiff lever pull, and all the while it feels like trying to stop with two glass plates rubbing against each other. Zero bite whatsoever, except when you're going super slow and could actually use the modulation- then they have this insane bite. Ughh. Replacements are already ordered, these things would kill me at some point.

- The only thing this bike is just outright bad at so far (which is like saying a Ferrari is bad at towing) is climbing over technical stuff. While the geometry and balance are perfect for getting around corners and downhill fast, that makes the front end feel really heavy on climbs. I only mention in because to climb up to the great downhills around my area, there is usually some tech and I definitely noticed it. Not impossible, but it definitely takes a substantial amount of effort.

Your mileage may vary :LOL:
Superized you went for an sb160. it aint what i call big travel...

Side note im back into thinking about a change.

2025 Slayer is winning my tick list currently.
 
I have a Spindrift CF5 and it pedals fantastic. All dressed out with a coil, Mavens and cushcore it weighs 32.2 lbs. So far about 100 miles of trail riding and 10 days of lift-served, and i have zero regrets. That said, seatpost depth is just barely enough for a transfer 150.
 
Discussion starter · #78 ·
I have a Spindrift CF5 and it pedals fantastic. All dressed out with a coil, Mavens and cushcore it weighs 32.2 lbs. So far about 100 miles of trail riding and 10 days of lift-served, and i have zero regrets. That said, seatpost depth is just barely enough for a transfer 150.
Wow, that’s crazy for inserts and a coil. Seems almost impossible, but guess not. What size and wheel set?
 
61 - 78 of 78 Posts