Haha did you do it your self or did you bring it to a shop?
So I have a 150mm Pike Select+ Charger 2.1 that came stock on my bike. Pretty much the same as the Ultimate but without the HSC adjuster. Stock the fork felt just "dead", it was either very easy to bottom out, or had zero small bump sensitivity and no mid stroke support. The rebound just felt strange as well. I weigh 64-65kg.
First I got an Everflow air spring. Then I sent the fork to M-Suspensiontech in Germany for a damper tune and bushing burnishing. He makes custom pistons as well, so it's much more involved than just changing the shim stack to another factory tune.
The fork has been completely transformed. The small bump sensitivity is great, yet the fork is supportive and hard to bottom out. It feels much much more controlled and calm on bigger hits, the rebound feels fast yet controlled. I can't really explain it, but I really love the fork now, I trust the bike so much more. It simply just works. It also highlighted how bad the rear suspension works with a stock Super Deluxe.
I bought another 120mm Pike Ultimate Charger 2.1 for a hardtail build (mainly because I love my tuned Pike so much), and I was reminded again how bad the fork feels in stock form. It just feels dead, and the compression dials just make things worse.
I highly recommend M-Suspension, I think they still charge a €150 for a damper tune. That includes dissasembly, assembly and everything. I think it's an awesome deal for that price.
What air spring do you have in your fork?