Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 34 Posts
Discussion starter · #5 ·

Smuggler frames $1,999. Don’t think Spur has frame only option but builds are cheap.
Didn't think to check transitions closeouts. Unfortunately not touching the Optic deal but I'll still keep my eye on their site!
 
Ibis has a nice sale on the previous gen Ripley frames in size XL.

 
I'm not sure what you want out of it but neither the 2nd nor 3rd gen Optic ride like downcountry bikes. They ride badass all mountain bikes but with a little less travel, and neither pedal particularly well for being 125mm out back. If you're thinking you want the pretty well-defined 115-120mm rear downcountry bike experience every other brand is giving you, look elsewhere. If you want one of the greatest trail/AM bikes of all time, then get the Optic. The deal is better and having ridden the current one for a few weeks, I'd probably choose it over the newest one in stock form.
 
Discussion starter · #12 ·
The Optic looks great, was concerned about dropper insertion, looks like it may be plagued to similar shorter insertion lengths like Banshee to keep from running longer droppers. Anyone have any first hand experience with the dropper insertion on the Optic?

Also, Banshee has their frames on sale at the moment too including the Phantom.
 
Discussion starter · #14 ·
Ibis has a nice sale on the previous gen Ripley frames in size XL.

If I could also order a toptube straightener I'd jump on that immediately!
 
The Optic looks great, was concerned about dropper insertion, looks like it may be plagued to similar shorter insertion lengths like Banshee to keep from running longer droppers. Anyone have any first hand experience with the dropper insertion on the Optic?

Also, Banshee has their frames on sale at the moment too including the Phantom.
I have a size large Optic and it can take a 210 post. I tried a 240 One Up shimmed to 220 and it wouldn't work for me. Maybe in an XL
 
Discussion starter · #16 ·
I'm not sure what you want out of it but neither the 2nd nor 3rd gen Optic ride like downcountry bikes. They ride badass all mountain bikes but with a little less travel, and neither pedal particularly well for being 125mm out back. If you're thinking you want the pretty well-defined 115-120mm rear downcountry bike experience every other brand is giving you, look elsewhere. If you want one of the greatest trail/AM bikes of all time, then get the Optic. The deal is better and having ridden the current one for a few weeks, I'd probably choose it over the newest one in stock form.
That's good to know, appreciate the insight! I'm looking to have a shorter travel bike to compliment/ let me build up a burlier enduro bike. Having it be more trail oriented would be beneficial for the places I typically like to ride.
 
I'm not sure what you want out of it but neither the 2nd nor 3rd gen Optic ride like downcountry bikes. They ride badass all mountain bikes but with a little less travel, and neither pedal particularly well for being 125mm out back. If you're thinking you want the pretty well-defined 115-120mm rear downcountry bike experience every other brand is giving you, look elsewhere. If you want one of the greatest trail/AM bikes of all time, then get the Optic. The deal is better and having ridden the current one for a few weeks, I'd probably choose it over the newest one in stock form.
^^^Great point/distinction^^^

It maybe only now, after the industry recognized the attraction/market for these bikes that seem to fit in between what had been the traditional categories of XC and trail, that we can start to more clearly agree on what defines/defined DC.

I have narrowed it down to 65.5-66.5 HTA and STA 75.5-77 (or ability to get there) AND flex stay rear suspension (or kinematics that make it feel like that).

Chain stay pivots add weight and dynamics that make the bikes feel more like “trail” bikes (IMHO), and again same IMHO if your outside this geo range (with aligned stem lengths/fork offsets).

Norco didn’t really have a DC bike as the revolver stayed more on the XC side and the Optic on the trail side (just like Kona with the Hei Hei and the Process). And then the new Optic clearly moved more into trail while CC race bikes Blur, Epic adopted versions that are more “trail.”

It was and remains easy for bikes like the Spur (smack in range) to be made more like the trail side with a shock designed to mellow the flex stay feel or become the Smuggler with some geo tweaks.

Great bikes all around but as stated perfectly above one needs to define what they are really looking for to decide which bikes will deliver.

All that said, buying “previous gen” bikes right now on top of the general economic situation makes for some excellent value starting points for experimentation.
 
1 - 20 of 34 Posts