Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
21 - 37 of 37 Posts
Let me know if you come up with something printable. I’ve got a nice printer and could try it out.
I'm a ways off from that at the moment - I'm stuck in between "I tried a prototype with wood and foam and confirmed the shape could work" and "I need to buy a 3d printer and learn how to model a saddle and print it with variable density infill and multiple filaments"

If you're curious, this is as far as I got:
 
Most of the trails here are twisty singletrack - where noseless helps most is being able to stand up and have a wider range of motion leaning the bike from side to side. Even with a dropper all the way down, a traditional saddle still blocks off a few inches over the top tube in front of the post.

I wholeheartedly agree that most all the noseless options being sold are far too wide for technical riding - that's why I cut mine down. (the Nexride is surprisingly hacksaw friendly)

Especially with it cut down, I'd argue it's more of a butt support than a saddle. Think resting on the edge of a table vs. sitting in a chair.

As mentioned if it works for you that's great but I can barely make it around the block on one. I haven't tried the one reviewed here but I can't imagine it's a whole lot different.
 
DVO makes saddles? That's not the one that the Vseat replaced, was it?

I went full geek, not caring for fashion, when I went ebike, too. I picked an SMP saddle. It worked even for unplanned 6+ hour epic rides without chamois, just going out in casual clothes. Was open to checking this out, but it makes sense that the width would cause issues with fore/aft freedom of movement.
 
At first it looked good for my fat friends, but then I saw the 250lb weight limit.
Read through Don Norman's "The Design of Everyday Things" a while back and one of the sections that was interesting talked about failures in product design.

The assertion was that on average successful designs took about 6 iterations of failure before settling on a working combination of luck / market / materials / technical design.

Sometimes the idea is good, but the business is bad.

Sometimes things launch at a bad time or before the right materials are available.

A lot of good ideas never make it through the gauntlet.
 
That's true. We'd need an adjustable air spring with tokens for the saddle that can do it all.
This takes that general idea and uses different weight coil springs for different weights:
 
21 - 37 of 37 Posts