Well after pretty well reading most of the 1450 posts and a year of tinkering I have finally found the magic setup! I have a 160mm Diamond D1. I ride aggressive angled hardtails and was finding compression spiking in stock configuration. With a hardtail on fast bumps or loam holes, the ride was very harsh. Plush is a relative thing but done right, a decently tuned fork can mute a lot of the feedback coming from the hardtail end. IMHO, the suspension dynamics on a hardtail is complex. As the fork goes over the bump, the fork compresses, the rear hits the bump milliseconds later, forcing the rear up and pushing the handlebar forward and down. The fork is having to work much harder to not give the rider feedback through the bars to your hands and arms. Anyway, I figured to counter this feedback, I would do a piston flip and shim mod to open the circuit more. Still harsh and spiking. I then, put the piston to the stock position, which improved the ride somewhat. I left it there for 6 months. I recently got a Kona Honzo ST and one day rode it fast on some rough logging road. The fork was so harsh that I couldn’t brake anymore from hands being numb. I started looking for another fork as a replacement throwing in the towel, but I decided to reread the forum on my harshness issue and decided on full tuning restart keeping in mind to tune for a hardtail. Return to the stock shim tune, piston in the modified position, more air for a sag of 15%, less OTT, faster rebound. Oh. My. God! Finally the fork rides sublime! More mid support but still getting full travel, better grip and I have way more confidence hitting single and double blacks! Here’s my setup information that I’m very happy with.
Piston flip
Return to stock shim stack
19% sag - 31mm
OTT - 8 turns from open
Air - 120-130 - use 125psi
Rebound 15 clicks from closed
HSC - 1/2 turn from open
LSC -4 (5 on steep grades over 40% with root steps)