This is actually borne out of my use of pogies this year. I am wearing summer gloves and it is amazing. The issue is on longer rides I am losing the war of attrition to the cold. Once I get to the 4 hour mark I am starting to notice the cold and it gets exacerbated if I need to stop and do some out of pogie work. I don't get unride-ably cold hands, but I want to do what I can to push that point out as far as possible.
2 things.
Carry a 2nd pair of gloves or thin large mittens (hard to find, but I've found a few). Put these in a pocket inside your jacket, ideally low and closer to your waist, so unzipping the zipper won't affect them much. Sometimes I just throw them down my base layer, which is tucked into my pants, so they aren't going anywhere. Pull these out and they are toasty warm from your body. You don't need to throw them down there at the beginning of the ride, but probably more than 10 minutes. You need to be dressing so you aren't sweating all over the place, but with that in mind, this works pretty great. THen just alternate as you need to for the rest of the ride. If you can't figure out how to dress to not sweat, you can do the same with a frame bag/pouch and throw them in there with a chem heater long before you need them. When it's real cold, I'll do this with some better mittens and pulling out 140F mittens mid-ride is bliss. Without handwarmers, this can run-out depending on the conditions, hands can get cold and it's just too much to keep them warm by alternating. See below. I'm all about the mitten backups too, I've found several thin extra large types that allow me to use controls with them on, far warmer than gloves and you can cram hand warmers in there.
The other thing is use the foot-warmer chem heaters, grip them to your handelbars, if it's rubber type grips, they'll stick pretty well on their own, but otherwise, it's not too hard to grip them to the bar while riding and they are much thinner and easier to deal with than hand-warmers. You need to directly heat your fingers IME and these help a lot. Do not throw them in cold after just opening, open them first, heat them in a pocket for 15 minutes, then use them. Otherwise, they tend to not always get over the "hump" of coming up to heat and warming your fingers. I find just throwing handwarmers into your pogies is generally not very effective...it takes a LOT and you gotta seal off all the gaps, etc. I suspect people that report this works for them have much better circulation than I. I use this method for races, when my hands start getting cold, etc.