Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
581 - 600 of 658 Posts
Mongoose takes a beating and maybe deservedly so. I can only speak for myself, but I rode (on MTB trails) a Mongoose Malus last year for 2200 miles without a single problem and very low maintenance.

I now have a Farley and it's obviously a superior bike in every way, but I cannot speak badly of the Malus. A friend who had never ridden a fat bike road it Sunday on the trails and loved it.

Again, this is just my personal experience. Those reviews above are brutal. HAHA.

*
 
Mongoose takes a beating and maybe deservedly so. I can only speak for myself, but I rode (on MTB trails) a Mongoose Malus last year for 2200 miles without a single problem and very low maintenance.

I now have a Farley and it's obviously a superior bike in every way, but I cannot speak badly of the Malus. A friend who had never ridden a fat bike road it Sunday on the trails and loved it.

Again, this is just my personal experience. Those reviews above are brutal. HAHA.

*
I appreciate your input! IMO, if the frame is decent, you can always change out the low tier components over time. Of course, there's a point of diminishing returns and it's always more expensive to do this then buy it pretty much the way you want it. I'm just unsure if I would really like and keep a fat bike so hence my trepidation for spending more $.

My immediate thoughts were hydraulic disc brakes, maybe a Microshift Advent X 1by setup and a dropper if I were to like it and keep it...
 
So?

What is the cheapest fat bike that is minimally acceptable to you?
How much does it cost?
The original dolomite and its close cousins (I think the newer ones have drilled rims but otherwise nothing has changed in 8 years really) is probably the number one selling fat bike model in the western world. Hell the thread on the bike on here has over 3000 posts in it. In my experience, people who refer to them as Bicycle shaped objects have never known what poverty is, used a food bank, been homeless, etc... and generally are stuck up snobs.

 
Risking getting flamed here but thoughts on a Mongoose Dolomite ALX?

For whatever reason, I've always wanted a fat tire bike, though I live in southern California. I remember seeing some well spec'd fat bikes from bikesdirect and framed back in the day for ~$600-$800, but it now seems that the price is $1k these days.

I've seen this Mongoose drop down to just under $500 at times and the weight doesn't seem bad at under $500. Seems like a decent rig to upgrade over time. The only bummer is that it's not thru axle, but are any at the $1k price point?

Lastly, I'm fortunate my work gives me a stipend of $375 per quarter that I could apply to this bike...
I wrote a review of the dolomite ALX... other than sharing the dolomite name its a completely different model, sharing more in common with the Argus Trail.

 
I wrote a review of the dolomite ALX... other than sharing the dolomite name its a completely different model, sharing more in common with the Argus Trail.

Great review and comparison, angry updates thoughts on the ALX?
 
I wrote a review of the dolomite ALX... other than sharing the dolomite name its a completely different model, sharing more in common with the Argus Trail.

Great review and comparison, angry updates thoughts on the ALX?
 
If you have $800 to spend, The House is selling Framed Minnesota for $899 then 11% cashback from Activity Junky

But I know this is the "Under $1K" thread but for $1200, can get the Framed Minnesota LTD and get you hydraulic brakes, tubeless ready wheels, 27.5x4 Cake Eaters, thru axles and tapered headtube.
 
On sale today only on Woot
NOTE: The sale price at WOOT is for a size SMALL.

The Argus Trail and the Dolomite ALX use the same frame. The size SMALL frame is listed as being 17".

I confirmed with an owner of a size SMALL ALX that the seat tube measurement is actually just over 15".

The Mongoose website lists the Argus Trail in size SMALL as be suitable for riders 5'3"-5'6".

Image
 
NOTE: The sale price at WOOT is for a size SMALL.

The Argus Trail and the Dolomite ALX use the same frame. The size SMALL frame is listed as being 17".

I confirmed with an owner of a size SMALL ALX that the seat tube measurement is actually just over 15".

The Mongoose website lists the Argus Trail in size SMALL as be suitable for riders 5'3"-5'6".

Image
Good to know, when I purchased my Dolomite I didn't know about sizes because I wasn't a bike rider. All in all I have over 10,00 miles on mine and I'm 6'.
 
Good to know, when I purchased my Dolomite I didn't know about sizes because I wasn't a bike rider. All in all I have over 10,00 miles on mine and I'm 6'.
Good to know, when I purchased my Dolomite I didn't know about sizes because I wasn't a bike rider. All in all I have over 10,00 miles on mine and I'm 6'.
striker64,

AFAIK, all of the Mongoose steel-frame fat bikes are one size only. Very few steel-framed bikes from any manufacturer are offered with sized frames.

The seat tube on my Malus measures 17" (top of the tube to the center of the spindle). That would be a "Medium" in most bikes that come in sizes. Most of the steel-frame one-size fat bikes have 17-18" seat tubes.

Ride safe,
jpz0883
 
If you have $800 to spend, The House is selling Framed Minnesota for $899 then 11% cashback from Activity Junky

But I know this is the "Under $1K" thread but for $1200, can get the Framed Minnesota LTD and get you hydraulic brakes, tubeless ready wheels, 27.5x4 Cake Eaters, thru axles and tapered headtube.
You couldn't pay me to ride that $900 framed. My buddy and i bought two of them last year, i opened the box and saw the horrible tires they put on the bike and immediately closed the box. he brought his over and we put it together. It is not really good at anything. he has also had nothing but problems - 3 flats, 2 busted chains and one bent his cassette. So glad i sent mine back and spent the extra $ for a Trek Farley 5 - @ $2000 the trek is way more than 2x as good as the framed if for nothing else the tire quality and the abillity to run studs on the factory tires.
 
You couldn't pay me to ride that $900 framed. My buddy and i bought two of them last year, i opened the box and saw the horrible tires they put on the bike and immediately closed the box. he brought his over and we put it together. It is not really good at anything. he has also had nothing but problems - 3 flats, 2 busted chains and one bent his cassette. So glad i sent mine back and spent the extra $ for a Trek Farley 5 - @ $2000 the trek is way more than 2x as good as the framed if for nothing else the tire quality and the abillity to run studs on the factory tires.
Bought a bike and didnt look at the build spec? Flats, broken chain, bent cassette is all rider error. Framed to fail from the start.
Agree Trek 5 is the way to go but not everyone has $2K.

And to keep on topic for Under $1K fat bikes, guess what? Framed Minnesota discounted to $700 plus another 11% cashback with Active Junky.
 
And to keep on topic for Under $1K fat bikes, guess what? Framed Minnesota discounted to $700 plus another 11% cashback with Active Junky.
still over priced crap.
 
The Minnesota fat is just fine for me. Only thing I didn't like was too much toe overlap. But now my brain is programmed to avoid that. Its a nice bike. Good components all around. Supposed to get a ton of snow here this weekend. Can't wait. Local trails are groomed. Love it.

Image
 
Other than Framed…are there currently any x < $1,000 options for a 6’3” rider?

I’ve been doing a lot of research and there does not appear to be many options aimed at those above 6’2”. Even some supposedly aimed at 6’2” riders (I.e. Northrock)…I’m seeing feedback that they’re a little small.

Is there such thing as a x < $1,000 fatbike that’s sold in a LBS?

I’ve got dozens of bike stores within a reasonable driving distance, but it appears that not a single one carry them.

I would consider used. There just aren’t a lot of XL framed used bikes on the market in my area.
 
581 - 600 of 658 Posts