Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
21 - 36 of 36 Posts
I had 500+ miles on a set of Maxxis Minion DHF and DHR II with the Finish Line sealant and it did really well for small goat head type punctures. I would see small "wet" spots where the puncture occurred with minimal pressure loss. I will say it wept through the sidewalls of those tires, but I suspect it may be a thing with the Maxxis tire construction.
I switched over to my summer/XC racing tire setup this past weekend on a set of Vittoria Mezcals and suffered a 1/4-3/8" cut near the center of the tread. Needless to say the bike and myself were covered in sealant splatter as the Finish Line product ultimately failed to seal. This was a fairly catastrophic and large cut so I'm not too surprised that it couldn't seal.
Ultimately, I'm not done with their product and will see how the reason of the season goes.
 
Hi Jordan.

We're sorry to hear about your experience with our sealant. Getting 2 pinch/sidewall punctures that wouldn't seal in rapid succession sounds like some pretty bad luck. In our extensive and thorough testing our sealant performed at least as well as all of our competitors' latex based offerings when sealing punctures.

There are obviously many factors that can contribute to why any sealant will or will not successfully seal a puncture. I would love to get some more details about the specifics of your testing if you would like to respond to me off-line.

Thanks!
-Dave from Finish Line.
 
I hate seeing such a negative review after seeing such a positive video review from another site. Makes me feel like I'm flipping channels between Fox and CNN. I'm hoping the Finishline works as I've switched over three bikes so far...

 
I'm sorry but this review seems to be too biased, full of flaws and has too many unanswered questions. The fact the review itself doesn't match the final score says a lot about it's credibility. I myself have been using the sealant since it came out and have yet to get a flat..... and its easy to get a flat with the sharp coral rocks down here.
 
This review could not be more wrong. I have been using this sealant for about
a month now in my Surly Dirt Wizards (Not actually a tubeless tire) and have not had any issues.

Further, this review is not very thorough. There are many factors here that we simply don't know about. What PSI was being used? What rim model? What trail conditions? How specifically did the flat occur?

The photo of the sidewall cut also shows the threads of the tire casing, usually an indication that the tire is dried out or worn out. Further, getting a snake bite style flat while running tubeless is no easy feat. I have bottomed out against my rims several times and never had this happen before.

"Messy when installing tube after failing to seal" I am still waiting for a bottle of sealant that is magically clean to work with and doesn't go everywhere.

This review seems hasty, poorly detailed and is no surprise with all of the Stan's advertising on this website. I think I'll be going to back to Pink Bike for unbiased product reviews.

10/10, will keep using Finish Line.
 
You don't get a flat because the sealant sealed, or you didn't puncture anything?
 
Agree 100%. It seems the tester was riding at a much lower psi than any tire is intended to be ridden in. The sidewall cut / snake bite comment is also spot on. I also felt the "messy" comment sounded like it came from someone who has no experience setting up tubeless tires. News flash.... the product is supposed to be in liquid form and not dry out. If it got messy its because you were unable to manipulate your tire properly while removing it from the rim.
 
New to tubeless after trying it unsuccessfully a long time ago. I had done 2 wheelsets (29x2.25, 2.35) with Schwalbe tires and then read this review and thought I had made a mistake. Then I had a tire that wouldn't seal. If the tear is in the center of the tire where you roll over it every time, you will have sealant spray onto your seattube every once in a while. That said, even with 1 oz. it held air enough to get home (1hr ride). However, I had only put in 1oz of sealant when the bottle instructs 4-5oz for 29er tire. As soon as I put in 4oz, the tire sealed up and has maintained air. I'm going to try the sealant in 40c 700 gravel tires Maxxis Ramblers tubeless ready. I like that the sealant is water soluble and doesn't need "topping off" or refilling (dried out boogers)... also, I recommend stan's style packaging tape in yellow, blue colors rather than the Gorilla tape that ENVE chooses. That's because gorilla tape is a PITA to remove with all the residue.
 
I bought a 240mm (8oz) bottle yesterday as I've been itching to try this new sealant. It is utterley useless!!! The tyre is a Schwalbe Furious Fred, which is a few years old and on my full rigid MTB. I removed the tyre and removed all the Stans latex that had been sealing well. I cleaned the tyre to point where there was no dried latex remaining on the inside of the tyre what so ever. Refitted and added half the bottle (120mm) of Finishline Sealant. Rolled it around and pumped up to 30psi to start with. I got it to seal eventually, put the wheel back on the bike and pumped up to 40psi, straight away it started to leak fast again. I managed to get it to seal again. repressurised to 40psi it leaked again. I repeated this several times, it kept leaking from small thorn holes (not around the rim). I tried ridding the bike and everything I would normally do when using latex. I have now inflated the tyre at least 15 times and every time the tyre leaks through a small thorn hole. I wouldn't dare to try and ride the bike anywhere, I have absolutely NO confidence in this product what so ever! I will be demanding my ÂŁ14.99 back when I go to the bike shop next. Stick to latex! I never had an issue with this same tyre with the same small holes whilst using latex.
 
Really interested to read all this negative comment. I have this sealant in my road bike (LBS said it was better than Stan's) and I think it is fantastic. I heard a hissing yesterday about 5 miles into a 30 mile ride, it stopped after a couple of secs and that was it. I have never had a problem with it and I do get quite a few punctures. Just thinking about getting the mid fat out for a blast but I run the front tyre on the mid fat (Schawlbe Nobby Nic) at 17 psi, the road bike is about 80 (25c tyres and bad roads round here). So kinda thinking, Stan's on the MTBs, Finish Line on the road bike.
 
I bought two new bikes last year and requested the finish line sealant be installed in all four tires because of the claim of it holding up for the life of the tire. First timer to the tubeless world and having to clean out and replace sealant sounded like a pain in the butt. Went on a few good rides and the bikes have been hanging upside down in a cold garage all winter since with barely any pressure loss! Haven't dealt with a puncture or flat yet so I can't speak to its performance in that situation but as of now, I am still a fan of finish line!
 
21 - 36 of 36 Posts