Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 23 Posts

Yootah

· Registered
Joined
·
253 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
I finally blew up the venerable coil fork on my venerable Fuji Outland 29er. NBD is a loooooooooong ways off and I'm broke as, so I'm stuck looking for the most budget friendly upgrade I can find. Here's what I'm looking at (if you know of a better price for either of these or a better fork in the same price range I'd be much obliged):

Recon Silver

XCR 32

I'm assuming that the Rockshox is better out of the gate than the SR, but price counts, so how much better? I'm a moderate rider at best and was mostly happy with the performance of the old Suntour coil fork I was on, so I'm thinking more in terms of durability (I'm a clyde) and serviceability (I do all my own work, can't afford the LBS mechanic). The one thing I definitely didn't like about my old fork was the terrible slop in the stanchions, I don't know if that's because it was worn out or because it sucked or both - is either of these forks I'm looking at particularly better than the other in terms of stiffness? Is there any difference in ease of service, any "factory" tools required that I won't have? And durability, whatever I get will need to last me a couple years, I'm assuming the Rockshox will be better here too, but ~$80 better? I'm flat bust so every penny counts. Performance is my last criteria, but I've never owned an air fork and may not know what I'm talking about - if the Rockshock is going to absolutely blow my mind vs. the Suntour then I'll wait a paycheck or two, where if it's only an incremental upgrade I'll likely save my bucks.
 
The XCR has 1 plastic bushing and 1 metal per side. RS has 2 metal. So it'll last longer as far as sloppiness goes. The Raidon has 2 metal bushings. The Suntours have a sealed damper so they need less maintenance.
 
Discussion starter · #3 ·
The XCR has 1 plastic bushing and 1 metal per side. RS has 2 metal. So it'll last longer as far as sloppiness goes. The Raidon has 2 metal bushings. The Suntours have a sealed damper so they need less maintenance.
Thanks, that's definitely helpful. I found a Rockshox service video on Youtube, it doesn't look too bad so the durability of the metal bushings might be worth the extra cost and more frequent maintenance.

I found this Manitou Markour air shock for a little less than the Rockshox, so let's throw it in the mix too.
 
I think it’s tough to go wrong with any of them if you’re not a super aggressive rider.. they are recreational air forks that should all work a lot better than your old coil fork so if you can save a little on one vs the other you’re still doing good and improving your ride.
 
If you can do a raidon your good, cant go wrong there.

Xcr is garbage

Recon vs the manitou fork, their about even honestly. Some people dont realize Manitou is in the entry OEM market too. And their about even with recon.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
 
Had the crappy xcr or scr whatever suntour, It's made to open screen doors at best.
Upgraded to the raidon
That was a very good fork.. transformed my ht

Had the RS xc30,, It got the job done.

Now on the Recon and It works just fine, Big tubes, good and stiff, responds well to my adjustments, Mine has a remote lockout and I use it.
Am very happy with this $200-$250 Recon fork

BUT have never owned better !

Starting my second year on the Recon, still feels like new but when It needs a rebuild'
I will upgrade, Not going to spend money on a $200 fork.

I won't move up much, just up to a $400 or maybe a $500 fork, It will be a RS
 
Discussion starter · #14 ·
Had the crappy xcr or scr whatever suntour, It's made to open screen doors at best.
Upgraded to the raidon
That was a very good fork.. transformed my ht

Had the RS xc30,, It got the job done.

Now on the Recon and It works just fine, Big tubes, good and stiff, responds well to my adjustments, Mine has a remote lockout and I use it.
Am very happy with this $200-$250 Recon fork

BUT have never owned better !

Starting my second year on the Recon, still feels like new but when It needs a rebuild'
I will upgrade, Not going to spend money on a $200 fork.

I won't move up much, just up to a $400 or maybe a $500 fork, It will be a RS
Ok, so Recon Silver vs. Raidon, you like the Recon better? Stiffer?
 
Discussion starter · #15 ·
Found a Fox F29 for sale locally, $50. It'll need service, at least oil if not a rebuild. Any thoughts on this fork? I've heard stories about Fox stuff needing frequent service that only the factory can do, should I run?
 
My older hardtail came with a recon silver and it performed reasonably for over 2 years of hard use. I have since gotten a FS trail bike, so the hardtail sees mainly gravel and smoother flow type trail use. BTW, I was about 290lbs when I got the older bike.
 
1 - 20 of 23 Posts