Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 21 Posts

bren5279

· Registered
Joined
·
2 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
Hi guys. I'm looking for the strongest 4 piston setup available (for a ~500lb custom off road cart)- Ive done some searching around and the 3

Ive come upon are The Magura MT7, the Shimano Saint M820, or or the Gustav M but those appear to be discontinued.

Are there any other 4 piston setups preferably on the cheaper side available thats as strong or stronger? (applied grab force isnt important)

Thanks in advance guys!
 
Check out the Shimano Zee's. Cheaper than the Saints but just as good for your purpose.
Jenson USA has them for $150 each.
 
AFAIR, Magura MT7 is the new Gustav. However, it's a new brake, so you have to wait for some real life reviews.
4 pot Shimano brakes are pleanty of power.
New Avid Guides a not bad, either.
 
Yeah those Zee's are pretty weak actually. Go with hopes for sure. (I have both on 2 different DH bikes). The zee's fade quickly on anything remotely steep.
Interesting on the Zee being that weak compared to the Hopes. I always read that the Zee's were the poor mans Saints with less bling and weigh more, but were just as strong.
Gemini, are you running the same size rotors on both bikes and do you know what compound the pads are?
 
AFAIR, Magura MT7 is the new Gustav. However, it's a new brake, so you have to wait for some real life reviews.
4 pot Shimano brakes are pleanty of power.
New Avid Guides a not bad, either.
Magura MT7 and Avid Guides are about the same power as Shimano XTs, they're nowhere close to the Saint or Gustav.

Interesting on the Zee being that weak compared to the Hopes. I always read that the Zee's were the poor mans Saints with less bling and weigh more, but were just as strong.
Gemini, are you running the same size rotors on both bikes and do you know what compound the pads are?
Most Zees come with the non-finned resin pads, which IMO are total crap for anything other than winter riding. I haven't been able to fade a Zee yet, but I've had some less than happy experiences with resin pads on my Deore and SLX brakes. I run metallic pads on all my brakes, though I do switch to resin pads in the winter since they work better when cold.
 
Thanks for the info aerius on the Zee's not coming with the finned pads. I'm running Saints that came with semi-metallic finned pads
and have no problems with fading at Whistler with my DH bike.
 
I know alot of guys are having great luck with the Saints, but with my experience I could not recommend them. I went through 3 sets of Saints that leaked either at the caliper, lever or both. Shimano's warranty service is great but down time from biking is terrible.
Hope Tech V4s are money!!!
 
Still got a set of Gustavs, the saints and Zees are very good, but the Gustavs still have more stopping power... and weight to match.
Yep. I used Gustavs back in the day. Supremely powerful.
 
Interesting on the Zee being that weak compared to the Hopes. I always read that the Zee's were the poor mans Saints with less bling and weigh more, but were just as strong.
Gemini, are you running the same size rotors on both bikes and do you know what compound the pads are?
Anyone who says Zee's are adequate for legitimate DH is riding really flat trails. Mine have a great bleed on them. Stock pads. Just horribly inadequate. I've heard this from multiple people who ride real DH with them. They just have really small brake fluid volume in the caliper which causes them to heat up badly. I've never had to use 2 finger braking on modern brakes until the Zee's.

Hopes are another world (even avid codes are better!). I just did a long descent (6k feet, but not that not steep) on some 2014 XT brakes on my new XC bike with the fancy ice tech rotors today. Same story. I can't comment on latest gen Saints. I haven't tried them. Although my buddy who is a bit lighter was running the saints on his XC bike today, he seemed okay with them. I'd still go with something besides shimano though. They've really sacrificed performance for weight with the latest generation. It's very disappointing. Everyone I know running XTs, Zees, SLX has the same conclusion.

I was able to do Garbonzo runs (~3k feet of vert) down the steepest whistler trails on my hopes with no fade and no loss of power. But 30 seconds into a steep descent the Zee's become quite sketchy (identical rotors).
 
1 - 20 of 21 Posts