Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 34 Posts

ron m.

· Registered
Joined
·
1,158 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
I did the search and had these options:
1) find a short stack headset
2) find a low profile stem (Spank Spike Stem)
3) use this extender (BBB - Extender Steerer Extender 28.6-25.4mm)

Well, since this was a cheap build and I didn't want to spend unnecessarily, I came up with an idea (based on option 3). Remove the star nut on the fork if it has one. The modification will pre-load the headset. Just an FYI, I still had enough steerer tube that the lower bolt was able to secure the fork in place. I just didn't feel comfortable being an inch and a half short so I figured I'd do this. I wouldn't recommend this if you barely have any steerer tube sticking up from the headset.

a) First, you have to find an old quill stem (1 inch of course).
b) Cut the lower part (and in my case, I shaved off part of the diameter because it wouldn't fit (there must be an older quill stem that would fit a 1 1/8 tube)
c) find an excess 1 1/8 inch steerer tube (I called my local shop) to use as shim
d) mark the part of the tube that sticks out of the stem. That inserted portion will be your shim.
e) remove the tube and cut the shim (ideally 1/8 inch shorter than your marked length)
d) make a vertical cut on the tube (to allow the tube to pinch into the quill body later
e) insert the shim and press down so it sits at least 1/8 below the stem surface
f) insert the quill unit along with the bolt and cap
g) tighten the bolt until the headset bearings are pre-loaded
h) tighten the stem bolts

The fork looks tight and because the quill unit is between the steer tube and shim, I think it will make the mend fairly strong.
 

Attachments

Discussion starter · #4 ·
I'll just add labels to the last picture but hopefully I can describe it.

Insert your fork into the head tube (with the headset already there) and then the stem. Because you have a shorter steerer tube, a significant portion of your stem will not have any surface to clamp. That's what the shim will be for. Insert the shim until the lower portion butts against the fork steerer tube. Now insert the quill body (with the bolt AND cap attached but just barely threaded in). I positioned the quill body to be in between the fork steerer tube and shim to provide maximum reinforcement. Anyway, tighten the bolt until the stem pushes down on the fork and preloads the headset unit. Then tighten the stem pinch bolts and you're done.
 

Attachments

Get video of you hucking it off some sweet jumps. The landing might hurt. You might be eating all your food through a straw for a couple months, but damn, the LULz will be awesome.
 
Discussion starter · #10 ·
LOL! There will be no hucking on this bike. Love the LULZ!!! LOL!

This will be more of an XC bike type fun bike. As far as the stem integrity goes, well, I'll just have to find out, won't I? This really isn't ingenious, I just took inspiration from the extender that's commercially available and I would even think that my mod would be far better than the BBB unit (click the link on my original post so you have an idea) because the quill unit is inserted between the steerer tube and the shim I created.

Lastly, would it still be sketchy if I bought one of those low profile stems (again, click the link in original post) as opposed to now having two pinch bolts applying pressure (lower bolt pinches against steer tube 100% and upper bolt pinches shim/quill combo)?

Anyway, good thing I have awesome insurance. =P
 
this is going to become one of those epic, classic threads where someone tries to do something stupid, everyone tells them not to do it, they do it anyway, and it fails as everyone predicted. go get some popcorn.

I would not do so much as ride that off a curb, let alone any sort of trails.
 
Discussion starter · #12 ·
Love your spirit, Mack. I'm sure the Wright brothers would have loved your heckling when they decided to build a plane. =P

What did bikes used to have to secure the stem before the advent of threadless headset systems? Quill-type stems. And if this was so dangerous, why is someone actually selling a fix-it system commercially? I bet they have a ton of lawsuits from failed installations.

I appreciate all your concerns (sarcastic or otherwise), but someone has to be the guinea pig... although I don't feel like I am since I'm copying off another product.
 
Love your spirit, Mack. I'm sure the Wright brothers would have loved your heckling when they decided to build a plane. =P

What did bikes used to have to secure the stem before the advent of threadless headset systems? Quill-type stems. And if this was so dangerous, why is someone actually selling a fix-it system commercially? I bet they have a ton of lawsuits from failed installations.

I appreciate all your concerns (sarcastic or otherwise), but someone has to be the guinea pig... although I don't feel like I am since I'm copying off another product.
The Wright Brothers had some actual build experience and a reality based concept by the time they got around to aircraft.
 
Discussion starter · #14 ·
The Wright Brothers had some actual build experience and a reality based concept by the time they got around to aircraft.
Granted I am not a mechanical engineer, but we're talking about extending the steer tube 1 inch! I'd like to hear how my mod, which is a copy of a commercial product, is unsafe. If I get a good answer, I'll take it off.
 
Granted I am not a mechanical engineer, but we're talking about extending the steer tube 1 inch! I'd like to hear how my mod, which is a copy of a commercial product, is unsafe. If I get a good answer, I'll take it off.
If you leave out the less than ideal tolerances, a steer tube that was never intended to have a wedge in it and the additional piece that you added I guess you would have a "copy" of a commercial product. Sometimes you look at something and you get that little nagging "that just doesn't look like a good idea", otherwise refered to as "Preservation of the Species". Good luck to you.
 
This seems a logical useful option when you think about the stresses involved. There isn't much trying to pull your fork down out of the head tube. All the force pushes it into and up.
I've pounded tech sections for lots of miles over time with a stem gabbing with just the lower bolt.
Zero problems even through crashes. The bars would show looseness side to side before they would pop off anyway.
Everything is dangerous if you don't think about it for a minute.
 
1 - 20 of 34 Posts