[Hogleg]

I am looking to move to an X-5 from my old Pantera. I can not decide between a 19 inch, 21 inch or some custom size configuration.

I am 6 - 2 with a 36.5 inch inseam (using wrench science measuring method) and long arms - relatively short torso. The 21 inch Pantera fits well; however I would not want a bike that feels much bigger. I am currently dialed-in running a 100 mm stem.

Looking at the charts the XL X-5 is slightly larger than the Pantera: effective top-tube is 24.9 versus 24.7, Seat tube length is 21.9 versus 21, wheelbase is 44.8 versus 44.2 and stand over height is 30.6 versus 27.5. I realize that the measurements for the X-5 probably assume 125 mm fork, while the Pantera assume 100 mm. I typically ran my Talas fork at 115 mm with the Pantera. I plan on using the Talas on the X-5 for now; however I will probably want to move up to a 130 mm Marzocchi at some point.

Has anyone ridden the two bikes in the 21 inch size and notice if the X-5 feels much bigger? I live in Houston and none of our local bike shops carry a regular stock of Ventanas on the floor. Any help is greatly appreciated.

 

[uktrailmonster]

I'm 6'1" and fit nicely on the 19" frame. There is plenty of seatpost adjustment left and I'm only using a 90mm stem. I would try to avoid going up to the XL size because it uses a full X-braced frame, which I think makes the bike look ungainly. Of course this last point is purely a personal preference!

 

[jk99]

XL for me (6' 2")

I'm 6' 2", 35" inseam, and ride an XL/21 inch (04) X5 with a 110 stem. Works great for me.

 

[Enel]

6'1" with 36.75" inseam

Like you I have long legs and a short upper body. I ride a large Saltamontes, and think the TT length is about right. I do have to run a 410mm seat post, however. I would strongly think about the XL, and think I could be comfortable on either if the build were tailored correctly.

Consider a semi custom build with the TT from the large, and everything else XL. I think they can do this for under $200, but you would have to talk with Sherwood for the details. I will probably do this with my next Ventana.

Eric

 

[Hogleg]

$200 is what Sherwood mentioned for semi custom. I'm seriously considering it.

Like you I have long legs and a short upper body. I ride a large Saltamontes, and think the TT length is about right. I do have to run a 410mm seat post, however. I would strongly think about the XL, and think I could be comfortable on either if the build were tailored correctly.

Consider a semi custom build with the TT from the large, and everything else XL. I think they can do this for under $200, but you would have to talk with Sherwood for the details. I will probably do this with my next Ventana.

Eric