[macman73]

I am 5'7", 200lbs, like walks on beach...oops...wrong site. Seriously, I would appreciate your input to my dilemma of determining which bike to purchase. I have been out of riding for years, though I have a road bike with minimal miles. I also have some lower back issues.

Dilemma: Specialized RH Exper 29er, Specialized RH Comp 29er, or Trek 6000.

I am leaning toward the 29er in either 15.5" or 17" frame for smoother ride and better control over obstacles (thinking of lower back issues). I have ridden all three and they ride/stop/shift good.

I know there is a different (preference) in components. However, any personal experiences or incites would be appreciated.

Thanks...

 

[mlevinson]

I would not buy a hardtail, esp with your back issues. Yes a 29er is better than a HT 26 but it will still beat you up more than a FS. Buy a used full-suspension if your budget won't allow you to move up into a new FS bike.

Just my 2 cents... Good luck.

 

[airs0ft3r]

2nd'd for buying used. Even if the used bike has issues, it will end up costing hundreds less than what you'd expect.

 

[PVR]

Two good pieces of advice IMO. I don't have lower back issues but a full-suspension bike is a lot more comfortable if you plan to ride over obstacles. Exploring the trails on a hard tail probably made me a better rider but I will be doing for longer on my full suspension.

 

[Baked_Beans]

I've had 2 lower back surgeries and 1 upper and would also recommend a full suspension bike vs hardtail. Supporting Mlevinson's post. My back feels much better after riding my full suspension bike in comparison to feeling a little stiff and beat up after riding my hardtail. Just my two cents, good luck with your decision.