Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 29 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,730 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I was a specialized dealer yesterday looking at a stumpjumper comp FSR 29 and an Epic comp. This is the first time I have seen an epic in person. They had a 2012 in black and a few 2013's in. BTW the green and black 2013 is great looking. I have ridden the 2013 Stumpjumper on the trails a few miles and liked it but it is kind of alot of bike for alot of the riding I do. The epic caught my eye though. In the past I did a trail demo of a Trek Superfly 100 AL Elite and found it to be pretty good. How does the Epic compare? Is the Epic good for a light trail use / shreading tight rooted singletrack? Please expain the brain to me. I dont do much for drops. I cant recall doing anything over 2.5' for sure. How does the Epic decend? I liked how the Epic seems so compact, just like my Fuel EX8. From what I see on the 2013 I would change the Tires to something alittle wider and run them tubeless, Put a riser (10-15mm) bar. Probably wheels such as a roval or crest after a couple months of riding. I really like the stand over on the Epic and Stumpy as I am 5'10 with about a 30 inseam. I weigh about 170 with gear.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,918 Posts
Epic trails

Epics are the happiest on a steady diet of tight rooted single track. Its the same old advice that you hear all the time but test ride the various models on trails and pick the one you like the best. Consider the Camber. It already has the more relaxed fit and bigger tires you are wanting to swap to an epic. An epic is easily capable of some light trail use. If you like the more aggressive xc race geometry and handling its a good fit.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,730 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
I did not care much for the Camber. After looking it over I thought the Stumpy was a better buy. I dont like how the camber jumps to carbon along with a huge price jump.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,331 Posts
The Camber rides REALLY nice though. It's a great short travel, all day riding kind of bike that descends better than the Epic.
 

·
And I'm out.
Joined
·
506 Posts
when did 120mm become short travel?? damn... that means my 150mm enduro is medium travel.... guess it's time to go for the demo 9!
 

·
GONE
Joined
·
25,875 Posts
I rode my '09 Epic on the same stuff I rode my '04 SJ FSR on. It's a fine trail bike but it's not gonna live long if you are doing regular drops along your trails. A 2.5' drop is too much for it, IMO. Get the SJ FSR, it will handle anything you can throw at it with ease. It'll be much more plush, too.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,730 Posts
Discussion Starter · #7 ·
I like the concept of the Camber but the model line up kind of leaves more to be desired. They need the Camber Expert carbon specs offered in Aluminum frame at a price about $3800. They can skip the dropper post if necesary to do so. I guess my major hang up with the camber is no Fox suspension and no 15qr on the front.

I have ridden the SJ FSR 29 comp some.....how does the camber differ? I did a small parking lot ride of the camber and it did feel pretty good.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
443 Posts
The epic can handle more then some people give it credit for. I've taken mine off 3ft jumps and regularly do 2ft log drops on it. I find it handles big hits good but it is a little more harsh for smaller bumps. To me if you want a bike that goes up hill great and downhill good go epic. Want something that's more of a compromise in all directions go camber. Want to go fast downhill and looking for drops and jumps go SJ.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,137 Posts
Can the Epic handle some trail stuff ? Of course,and you may enjoy the bike bouncing back at you a bit when things get rougher ( I used to). Is it more fun than the Stumpy fsr ? It may be for some and it's true that the Stumpy makes things a bit too easy and safe,take it from a guy that gets chickened out quite easily and feels like it's cheating when riding the Stumpy . Easier,safer and sleepy but in the long run it's the bike for me. Glued to the ground,unstoppable uphill,stupidly slow but you can't ask this bike speed.
Camber it's an interesting concept,too bad they are not fitting it with a Brain( are you listening Specialized ?? ) otherwise it would probably be a great bike to have. Currently I would get the Epic anyday over the Camber. Take the Epic,place a shorter stem,beefier tires and you'll have the best of both worlds.

Ps : two days ago I've had a bad crash with my F29,landed on my face. Stitches and black eye,I'm in such a pain right now,not a single scratch in on that ***** bike. Selling my F29,happy to have my easier and safer fsr29. Still missing my Epic 29 A LOT !!! But I have the road bike for fast rides :thumbsup:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,576 Posts
Ps : two days ago I've had a bad crash with my F29,landed on my face. Stitches and black eye,I'm in such a pain right now,not a single scratch in on that ***** bike. Selling my F29,happy to have my easier and safer fsr29. Still missing my Epic 29 A LOT !!! But I have the road bike for fast rides :thumbsup:
What happened? Would you have been able to avoid that crash if you were riding a full suspension bike?

I think the Specialized Epic is a capable bike that works well for general riding. Changing from the stock Specialized Fast Trak tyres to a tyre that's suited to your riding terrain makes a big difference to how well it performs.:)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,137 Posts
What happened? Would you have been able to avoid that crash if you were riding a full suspension bike?
Probably it would have been 10 times less as hard. This ***** F29 is all about speed. My bad anyway,I was not on a trail,it was a marina pier an I was keeping an eye on a 5 years old kid with it's bike.Did not see the obstacle coming,I was at speed as usual...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,576 Posts
Back in 2009 I managed to fall off my 2009 Specialized Epic riding on the local cycle track, smashing my helmet to pieces in the process.:eekster:

http://forums.mtbr.com/specialized/my-new-s-work-epic-impressions-507890-3.html#post5927377

It was almost as lame as falling off my 2012 Specialized Epic 29er at a roundabout and breaking my leg last August.

http://forums.mtbr.com/xc-racing-training/powertap-disc-405775-2.html#post9616126

I don't blame the bike for either of those incidents.

Now the crash where I span my 2008 Specialized Epic turning off the road into the driveway and somehow ended up crashing into the neighbour's wall. That one I blame the bike for.;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,730 Posts
Discussion Starter · #13 ·
Maybe the SJ would be better for me. I suppose with a set of wheels the SJ would lighten and liven up. Heck I had the bike shop weigh a completely stock SJ FSR Comp 29(med) with the plastic test pedals and it was just a hair over 30lbs. My 2011 Trek Fuel EX8 set up tubeless, slant 6 2.1 tires, Crank Bros candy pedals, SLX brakes came in only .5 lbs less. And a 2012 Epic Comp (left over) in med came in at just over 27lbs all using the same scale. I would think the SJ with a lighter tire, tubeless, and Roval control trail or stans would loose a solid pound or so.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
809 Posts
No experience on the Epic, but I have tested last year's top-end carbon Camber on familiar trails and I loved it. It was also my first 29er experience and I expected to hate the big wheels (I'm 5'5") but the bike felt so familiar from the first ride. I particularly loved the way the suspension felt. Taking the edge off but not disconnecting me from the trail. Dialed cockpit, esp. the 72cm flat bar. I also never thought for one second what wheelsize I'm riding. In fact, I never had to think about the bike, I just enjoyed the riding.

The Camber was great, and I'd easily buy it for my everyday trail fix to allday epics and even the occasional race. If you feel over biked on the Stumpy, the logical step is the Camber after all.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,730 Posts
Discussion Starter · #15 · (Edited)
That was the thing when I was at a demo event. They offer the top line Camber to demo. Of course a $8k bike is going to feel great. It has my wishlist and then some but it is BIG money. I really dont care to ride something way out of my budget.

I was suspect of the rear shock on the camber comp. I read some reviews that comfirmed it. Somewhere on this site it was said "there is fox and then everything else". I dont mind the Reba fork but dont trust the monarch shocks. I would have to spend about $5500 to get a Camber speced well. If they only offered that model in Aluminum and a few less bling items to get the rice down it would be great.

With all that being said I still am drawn to the Epic for is compact feel and look. I have seen a few people riding them in my area....actually just as much as a stumpy. I have yet to see a camber on hy trails. My jumps and drops are few and far between.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
721 Posts
That was the thing when I was at a demo event. They offer the top line Camber to demo. Of course a $8k bike is going to feel great. It has my wishlist and then some but it is BIG money. I really dont care to ride something way out of my budget.

I was suspect of the rear shock on the camber comp. I read some reviews that comfirmed it. Somewhere on this site it was said "there is fox and then everything else". I dont mind the Reba fork but dont trust the monarch shocks. I would have to spend about $5500 to get a Camber speced well. If they only offered that model in Aluminum and a few less bling items to get the rice down it would be great.

With all that being said I still am drawn to the Epic for is compact feel and look. I have seen a few people riding them in my area....actually just as much as a stumpy. I have yet to see a camber on hy trails. My jumps and drops are few and far between.
I'm on my third season with my Epic and our trails are definitely on the more technical side. I think the Epic is an amazingly flexible (not to be mistaken with flexy...) bike. If you look at the geometry it is definitely more relaxed than a race bike, but the brain shock gives it a much more efficient ride. I paired my Epic frame with a Lefty fork and it is a great combination. I generally run a 2.3-2.4 from tire and then a rear tire that is appropriate to the ride I'm doing and it's good to go. Are there better bikes for any given situation? Probably. But as a single quiver bike for any riding from racing through aggressive XC I'm not sure it can be beat. For the records though, I wouldn't mind a Stumpy FSR (with a Brain) for a second FS bike :)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
86 Posts
I have an Epic Comp, I ride it everywhere, especially over the technical rooty stuff, it eats it right up. Also, with the 29" wheels you probably won't need a riser bar
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,730 Posts
Discussion Starter · #18 ·
When I say riser I am only talking 15mm or so. Good to hear general trail use on the epic. However I have ridden the Trek Superfly 100. Can anyone comment on that in comparison to the epic? Unfortunatly I will most likely be stuck with a parking lot demo ride of an Epic. I may have to check more dealers in the ATL area.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
454 Posts
Maybe I'm the only one, but I bought a brand new 2011 Camber Pro 29er and hated that bike, I just never felt right on it. The rear Triad II shock was horrible. It blew several times and I was just about the get an rp23 from push but was offered good money for it and it was gone. Have since had a Stumpy EVO HT, and my current two rides my 11 Stumpy FSR 29 and my 12 Epic Carbon Expert. The Epic is an absolute blast def. harsher than the Stumpy but it more than makes up for it in speed and weight...

IMG_1781.JPG
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,730 Posts
Discussion Starter · #20 ·
Is it just me or does the stumpy feel like a really big bike? I have also rode a rumblefish and it was about the same feeling as the stumpy. The Superfly and stache didnt feel near as big. Maybe thats what keeps my attention with the Epic. It feels compact like my Fuel.
 
1 - 20 of 29 Posts
Top