I lied a little in the title, it should be Neuvation S1 vs Neuvation S2 saddles. The An-Atomica is out of the running because of cost, but the Neuvations are $59, so I am trying to make up my mind. I know saddle preference is a sore subject, but I would like to hear from S1 and S2 owners with what you like/dislike about those saddles. If I could know for sure the An-Atomica was absolutely the most comfortable saddle out there FOR ME, I would manage to come up with the cash, but it is too iffey for that price. This will be for use on my road bike.