Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 10 of 10 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
201 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
I'm currently using 2004 shimano XT dual control levers with XT hydraulic discs. I don't much care for either of the two, so I'm going to upgrade to X.0 shifters and an unknown (probably Hayes) disc set up. However, I have the center lock XT rotors on my wheels and that's the only kind of rotor I can use without buying a whole new set of wheels. So my question is, will other hydro discs work with XT rotors? Are there any drawbacks to mixing and matching rotors and calipers?

Thanks
 

·
Derailleurless
Joined
·
9,122 Posts
Shimano's centerlock rotor offset conforms to IS standards, so there is no problem with cross-compatability with other brands of calipers. Just pay attention to the XT rotor track width (pad contact area) -- they look slim, and I imagine there are some brands with wider pads that may end up making partial contact with the rotor's spokes.
 

·
"El Whatever"
Joined
·
18,889 Posts
Speed?e said:
Shimano's centerlock rotor offset conforms to IS standards, so there is no problem with cross-compatability with other brands of calipers. Just pay attention to the XT rotor track width (pad contact area) -- they look slim, and I imagine there are some brands with wider pads that may end up making partial contact with the rotor's spokes.
Amen.
 

·
Derailleurless
Joined
·
9,122 Posts
Lucky13 said:
XT rotor's width is 2mm
It's acutally 1.8mm, but that's not the dimension I'm referring to. I talking about the brake track width, as in the pad contact area.

1.8 is almost universal for 160mm rotors, but a brake caliper can handle a 2.0mm thick rotor if that's what you throw at it. With few exceptions, you really don't begin to find 2.0mm thick rotors until you get into the 8" range.
 

·
"El Whatever"
Joined
·
18,889 Posts
Speedüb Nate said:
It's acutally 1.8mm, but that's not the dimension I'm referring to. I talking about the brake track width, as in the pad contact area.

1.8 is almost universal for 160mm rotors, but a brake caliper can handle a 2.0mm thick rotor if that's what you throw at it. With few exceptions, you really don't begin to find 2.0mm thick rotors until you get into the 8" range.
Backing up what Nate said... standard brake track width is 16mm for Shitmano BR-M515LA, Avid Mechs and Hayes. I couldn't tell for any other brakes as I hadn't got my hands on any other. (Outer Radius minus Inner Radius)

If centerlocks are 16mm brake track width, you can use them with Avid or Hayes brakes at least. Let us know how much they measure.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
34 Posts
sorry to but in...

Speedüb Nate said:
It's acutally 1.8mm, but that's not the dimension I'm referring to. I talking about the brake track width, as in the pad contact area.

1.8 is almost universal for 160mm rotors, but a brake caliper can handle a 2.0mm thick rotor if that's what you throw at it. With few exceptions, you really don't begin to find 2.0mm thick rotors until you get into the 8" range.
hey Speed?e,

You mean any rotor with 2mm thickness will run on hayes hydro?with no problem... I have HFX 9 will this be true also? ... sorry i really need to but in...im planning to put a 180mm rotor on my 6" existing setup...and i found a 180mm with 2mm thickness at online store...i check also with the other forum, by using the rear frame adapter on front will give you a good clearance to put a 180mm rotor. i hope you can help me if you have some info on this...thanks in advance...btw..my fork will allow only upto 185mm rotor so i wont messup the warranty...thanks in advance.
 

·
"El Whatever"
Joined
·
18,889 Posts
arlopex said:
hey Speed?e,

You mean any rotor with 2mm thickness will run on hayes hydro?with no problem... I have HFX 9 will this be true also? ... sorry i really need to but in...im planning to put a 180mm rotor on my 6" existing setup...and i found a 180mm with 2mm thickness at online store...i check also with the other forum, by using the rear frame adapter on front will give you a good clearance to put a 180mm rotor. i hope you can help me if you have some info on this...thanks in advance...btw..my fork will allow only upto 185mm rotor so i wont messup the warranty...thanks in advance.
Yup... pistons will retract accordingly. Remember they compensate for pad wear, so they will move the pads back or forwards as needed. Otherwise you couldn't use different thickness pads for example (not all brands have same thickness in pads, koolstops are thicker than EBC's for example).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
34 Posts
Thanks

Warp2003 said:
Yup... pistons will retract accordingly. Remember they compensate for pad wear, so they will move the pads back or forwards as needed. Otherwise you couldn't use different thickness pads for example (not all brands have same thickness in pads, koolstops are thicker than EBC's for example).
Thanks...i'll post here what ever happen to me after installing this setup...if after a month i didnt post here heheheh prolly something happen to my brake..and me...heheheheh thanks...have a safe ride.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
34 Posts
i'm still alive!!!

oh yes...very much alive...I tested my 180mm rotor on hayes hydro on rock-it and rattle snake on alisso canyon...and it work awesome.... this is just to let everybody know that 180mm with rear 6" hayes adapter really work...just incase anybody wants to upgrade...no washer no shim...thanks to shiggy..and VT and to all with their advice and comment .....enjoy life.. safe riding...peace!!
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
Top