rojogonzo said:
From the riv article: "They work great with
our Sneaker pedals, and on any ride that didn't involve dragging the bike up steep, loose trails (hiking with it), they're perfect."
It's not like Grant/Rivendell doesn't have their own axe to grind: they're selling something too.
For any mtb ride I do, there's heck of a lot less dragging the bike when clipped in than when on flats. I'm old enough to have ridden pre-clipless days, with and without toeclips, and I'm as much a retro-grouch as the next guy but this is one thing where cycling has been seriously improved on. Sure, the townie has flats, but nothing else 'cause I'd rather be riding than pushing or dragging. And from the "racer or racer-like" perspective, I can't remember the last time I was beat in a race by someone using flats, and I ain't fast.
The opinion was considered and found wanting.
And the argument that SS is simple so you should use flats its just silly -- cotterless cranks are less complicated than those mated to sealed bottom brackets or external bearings, so you better use them too. Ever try and take apart a freehub? There's simpler ways to deal with the rear sprocket, but it doesn't mean it's better.