Hot Tomato without a doubt. I'm biased however. My crew and I have been visiting Jen and Anne since back in their Over the Edge days. We got to eat at the HT back when they were on Main St, and still serving sammiches on their own home made bread. We were there for all their big changes, and still visit twice a year regardless. I think the HT has so much charm, and soul, and the pizza is authentic, and delicious. Their new location is a lot of fun to hang out in. The girls still make time to chat with us when we come in, even though the line is almost always out the door (Because the food is good). I usually HATE standing in line, but for Jen and Anne, I hop right in and wait with a smile.