Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner

1 - 20 of 27 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
I bought my 2011 white SC Butcher (size large) last April. Two weeks ago, I was cleaning it and noticed the bottom of the crank case had a bunch of cracks in the paint (not from impact as no scratches). Nothing you can get your finger into, but there are a lot of them...looks like a spider web or a custom crackled finish, which it's not. It's the factory white. I started looking around and noticed it's also on the top of the crankcase, around all the welds, the seat tube and basically on every other tube on the bike...not covering the bike, but a good portion. I wouldn't expect the paint to do this. I'm concerned the paint will eventually start chipping as the cracks get worse and will cover more of the bike. I'm bringing into my LBS this week. Anyone have this issue or ever heard of something like this? If so, any information on how SC handled it?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,045 Posts
so the paint is cracking underneath the clearcoat? no idea what SC would do. havent heard of this happening.

i would imagine that unless its really bad, SC wouldnt do much. id be pretty annoyed if that happened to my bike so i certainly feel your pain.

post a pic. id like to see if you can portray it in a closeup pic
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
I just broke down and decided to call SC. I spoke to a tech and he said it sounds like the paint didn't cure properly. He asked me for pics, but based on my description he sounded fairly confident of the issue. I will bring it to my LBS this week to re-confirm. He said if that's the issue, it would need to be sent back to them, they would strip it and re-paint it. Bad news, it sounds like SC messed up and I assume that means there's more out there. Good news, it sounds like I'm getting a fresh paint job.

Anyone else have this issue?
 

·
boxcar
Joined
·
564 Posts
I bought my 2010 white SC Butcher (size large) last April. Two weeks ago, I was cleaning it and noticed the bottom of the crank case had a bunch of cracks in the paint (not from impact as no scratches). Nothing you can get your finger into, but there are a lot of them...looks like a spider web or a custom crackled finish, which it's not. It's the factory white. I started looking around and noticed it's also on the top of the crankcase, around all the welds, the seat tube and basically on every other tube on the bike...not covering the bike, but a good portion. I wouldn't expect the paint to do this. I'm concerned the paint will eventually start chipping as the cracks get worse and will cover more of the bike. I'm bringing into my LBS this week. Anyone have this issue or ever heard of something like this? If so, any information on how SC handled it?
I built up two Butchers this past Fall. I installed the HS upper cup on the first one and as I was looking to see if the cup was flush with the HT noticed dozens and dozens of "spiderweb, small cracks" in the paint. I thought it happened as I installed the HS and looked at the other brand new Butcher frame and noticed the same "cracks" on that one. Carefully installed the HS, was pretty sure the paint was gonna flake, but it did not and while the cracks are still there, that's just it, aesthetic with no progression of the "damage" from then till now. I never contacted SCB. Please post up what you find with them as I am curious on how they treat it. FWIW I did view it as a bummer, but ultimately a non-issue, so again will be interested in what SC says.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
See pics...is this what yours look like? Not the clearest, but you get the idea...they're everywhere. I'm bringing to LBS on Thursday so I will let you know where this goes. The way I look at it, just aesthetics or not, it was painted for a reason...to look good. If the paint gets ruined, I want it to be from something I did...
 

Attachments

·
boxcar
Joined
·
564 Posts
Whoa. Wow. That is exactly what our paint looks like but in a MUCH more minimal area, near the (mostly) top and less on the bottom of the head tube. Like you said, they are EVERYWHERE on your frame. I agree dude, only aesthetic or not, I would want that addressed.
Good luck, keep us apprised and thanks for posting.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,045 Posts
yea that would kind of annoy me. hopefully SC takes good care of ya although your bike might be out of commission for a month or so...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
It seems like winter might finally be arriving in the Northeast, so probably the best time I can think of to be without. Although my luck it'll be 55 degrees for the next month. Definitely don't want to go through this in May...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
31 Posts
I built up two Butchers this past Fall. I installed the HS upper cup on the first one and as I was looking to see if the cup was flush with the HT noticed dozens and dozens of "spiderweb, small cracks" in the paint. I thought it happened as I installed the HS and looked at the other brand new Butcher frame and noticed the same "cracks" on that one. Carefully installed the HS, was pretty sure the paint was gonna flake, but it did not and while the cracks are still there, that's just it, aesthetic with no progression of the "damage" from then till now. I never contacted SCB. Please post up what you find with them as I am curious on how they treat it. FWIW I did view it as a bummer, but ultimately a non-issue, so again will be interested in what SC says.
Same thing and same place on my white Butcher. They are really small paint cracks and I didn't even notice earlier but one time when I was cleaning the bike and used additional light I saw these. I tought it was because headset installation but seems like there has been some quality issues on the painting process.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
Quick update: Santa Cruz has confirmed its an issue with the way the paint cured and they will repaint the frame under warranty.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
23 Posts
Discussion Starter #14
Update: She's back...and black? Ha yes, they gave me option to change colors and I said..."s*%# why not"! They only thing I had to pay for was one way shipping to SCB. First ride on her in about T- 3 ..can't wait to get back out there.
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
50 Posts
powder coat

Michaels55,
Most bike companies do not do their powder coating process correct , what other people were saying was correct as far as the powder coat cure time . I have powder coated many frames over the years and big companies are trying to push out products as fast as possible . A normal bake time on powder is around 20 minutes at 375-400 degrees depending on the powder company and the material thickness. The BB area is a machined out area just like the HT and a few other parts of frames so the bake \ cure time need to almost double to cure and adhere properly to the material in those areas . SC is an amazing company and glad you got it all cleared up .

enjoy the ride !!
Scab
 

·
Butcher
Joined
·
529 Posts
Damn. Thanks for the head's up. Just found this thread and had to go check my white Butcher. The rear triangle is littered with these spiderweb paint cracks. Can't really tell on the front yet, but will check again with better lighting tomorrow.

Couldn't hurt to send it back and have them redo it. to the OP... how long did it take for you to get the frame back?

Thanks again.
 
1 - 20 of 27 Posts
Top