Pioneering makes initial costs high and risks evident yet the rewards are pure treasures. Today, the Ostar remains in limited custom lights with the expected higher costs of a rare product. LOL…if manufacturers would oblige us then the great Ostars would make awesome lighting. As it stands, Ostar lights dwell in the realm of custom makers and the serious, all rare people.
The website in Japan shows the cousin Ostar lights, the R2X - what I affectionately call the "Light Saber." They were built at the same time with the Japanese lights specifically designed for Osram's rolling exhibition so they have a futuristic flavor. Amazing machining with the same internal dimensions. Ours are more for use in the field so a more compact design with hard-anodizing required.
Many have looked over the advantages of the Ostar for performance because they don't know how to get it to work. From a hobbyist standpoint, the P7 is the winner because initially it is easier to work with but may show problems later. The Ostar is high-tech and not hard to deal with - it is something a manufacturer could handle with ease. For the near future, Ostar lights will remain rare as hen's teeth.
Comparing performance between the Ostars and the P7s, Ostars wins on reliability. Sounds like an arrogant declaration? Performance is not just light output.
Direct-drive with P7s are good for a while as they use low-voltage but require massive current. To keep them running, get a few batteries with lots of capacity. But this is known; with high current switching you eventually get switch-fouling, an insulating carbon build-up like a build up of oxidation. It's a slow build up and additive so your performance decreases every time the light is used. At the worst, they could suddenly wink out. Yeah, regular maintenance with Deoxit would work but I'd rather pass the extra work and go riding.
P7s with converters is the next step up, a better combination, but the electronics have to be rather big to support large current draw making a bigger converter bigger, heavier, converter. Heat sinks have to be bigger and that adds more weight. On a bike, space and weight are desired premiums so thinking small means thinking light-weight. If you can live with the limitations then by all means give the P7 lumen emitter a try.
So we come to the Ostar. The Ostar is the counter to the others, an unseen advantage. It wants voltage but uses little current. Initial thoughts would be to stack lots of heavy batteries to get the required minimum of 18-volts so the shortsighted wrote it off. Uh, too heavy…
good-bye! What is so wrong about using a boost converter? They have been used for years and are cheap. Ostars are high-tech devices so they use a converter and a few lightweight batteries. Parts can remain small because of little current. You've seen the pocket-able light with the small Surefire KL4 head - something a P7 can't do because the parts are too big. Even if the Ostar was direct-drive, there would be very little switch-fouling because of little current flow. Of course the initial obstacle remains - getting a converter to bump up the voltage but as you can see it's been done many times. There is no magic; there is current drain from the batteries to the converter as the voltage is stepped up but high-performance batteries are common. In fact, rechargeables are preferred because they can take the big current drain. But in an Ostar light, the switch controls the converter with little current demand. Bottom line - no switch-fouling.
One more for ya. The Ostar has a more apparent advantage. A P7 using low voltage is very dependent on secure connections. A questionable connection or any fouling could lower the voltage, perhaps 10%, so the emitter instantly quits. A higher voltage emitter has a broader voltage and is much less dependent on the flow of current making a 10% reduction less or not unnoticeable. Nice design.
We were playing with the Ostar light versus a 15W HID diving light and the Ostar kept up. Of course Ostar could do the "insta-start", brightness change, and could do the flip and bounce off the grass trick better.
I hope I don't sound too preachy. We've done lots of study and tests.