Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 32 Posts

·
steep fast and loose :)
Joined
·
3,270 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
X-Post with the Nicolai forum :

Tim Flooks told me today that air shocks simply cannot work on a 6" plus frameset :eek:
All to do with the spring rate curve being exceeded onto the ramp up point after 70% of stroke.
Apparently, higher volume air cans will suffer even greater mid stroke blow through than normal volume cans, as they have less capacity for mid stroke damping than smaller reservoir canisters.
Of course, he suggests a PUSH Ind. kit will assist in the stroke control [RP23, no Monarch kit just yet] as it replaces the flexible stroke washer internally with a more robust 'shim'...
To be fair, he made a valid point about the mid stroke blow through being in conjunction with air shocks' inability to provide sufficient high speed rebound control. The lack of rebound ability means that most air shocks fitted to 6" travel plus bikes, irrespective of leverage ratio, simply causes pack down and the subsequent effects of such.
Thoughts ?
 

·
Crazed Country Rebel
Joined
·
6,345 Posts
The_Lecht_Rocks said:
X-Post with the Nicolai forum :

Tim Flooks told me today that air shocks simply cannot work on a 6" plus frameset :eek:
All to do with the spring rate curve being exceeded onto the ramp up point after 70% of stroke.
Apparently, higher volume air cans will suffer even greater mid stroke blow through than normal volume cans, as they have less capacity for mid stroke damping than smaller reservoir canisters.
Of course, he suggests a PUSH Ind. kit will assist in the stroke control [RP23, no Monarch kit just yet] as it replaces the flexible stroke washer internally with a more robust 'shim'...
To be fair, he made a valid point about the mid stroke blow through being in conjunction with air shocks' inability to provide sufficient high speed rebound control. The lack of rebound ability means that most air shocks fitted to 6" travel plus bikes, irrespective of leverage ratio, simply causes pack down and the subsequent effects of such.
Thoughts ?
It would be much easier to respond to your post if it made more sense.

But let me say this.

The spring and the damper are two, totally separate things.

You state that air sprung shocks have limitations, then all you talk about is limitations in damping.

Which is it?
 

·
trail fairy
Joined
·
9,546 Posts
Not too be rude but we all discovered this some 3 years ago when the DHXa air came out, on the Packs RFX and Spots, its been the same with Nomads and other bikes not all but enough for serious riders to upgrade to coils for the most part, who want real performance and not worried about a few grams! Course many went Ti springs as well..

My poo air is there to hold the frame up while I injured nothing else :D
I have other plans but no point right now, gathering dust!

Such a beast as ya Nicolai I can;t understand why ya running such a can myself be like F1 running a Koni shock on there carbon stays! I like Sram but Monarch for that puppy really :confused: I do wish Sram would make the darn Vivid in smaller Is2is darn it that peaves me off a bit! Have you thought of a BOS stoy with Ti spring yet :D ;) :p
 

·
I dig trails!
Joined
·
5,611 Posts
I'll bite.

Any suspension that is designed for the characteristics of an air spring will work well with an air shock (spring).

I can't think of any current designs of 7" frames that are designed around air springs, they are all designed for coils - huckin' & bombin'

Newer 6" frames are starting to pop up that are more designed around air shocks. It will be interesting to see how they play out. New Nomad, New Enduro, and Remedy come to mind, but I have already seen posts of conversions to coil in all these models with claimed improved results.

The future is bright with sub 30 pound huckers... ;)

 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,471 Posts
After running an avalanche chubie coil over the summer, I recently picked up a PUSH'd LV rp23 for my RFX.
All I'm gonna say is I'm very impressed. :thumbsup:
The avy does feel noticably better, but it's also 1.5lbs heavier, even with a ti spring. So, all things considered, I'd call it even- it's great to have both options! Horses for courses.

I'm pretty stunned by the progress air shocks have made in the last 3 years.

I don't know much about Tim Flooks, but he seems to be full of hot air, hence:
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,416 Posts
On an 08 RFX my pushed low volume Rp23 blows away the Rp23 with high volume can. For anyone approaching or over 200 LBS don't bother with a high volume can or go on a diet -the LV rp23 it is almost as nice as my Roco coil.
 

·
Committed
Joined
·
1,775 Posts
I have had little love for the Fox DHX air on long travel bikes, but the Marzocchi Roco Air WC is a whole different beast.
Feels great on both my DHR and my Highline.
No mid stroke wallow and very plush off the top. On the DHR I can't quite get full travel due to the progressive nature of the DHR's suspension. This is not an issue on the Highline due to it's more linear suspension rate.
Not every air shock is the same, just like every coil is not the same.
I love the feel of a coil sprung bike, but I have been experimenting with air sprung gravity bikes for a few years now. In the right environment air can be very effective.
I ran air front and rear at Sea Otter this past year, and found it suited the course perfectly. There is also some local riding that this set up works well on. I wouldn't run air all the time on a gravity bike, but it has it's place.
Here is a photo of the DHR set up for the Otter with Roco WC Air rear shock and Totem Solo Air in the front.
Sub 36# race bike.
 

Attachments

·
Yes, that's fonetic
Joined
·
3,893 Posts
FM said:
After running an avalanche chubie coil over the summer, I recently picked up a PUSH'd LV rp23 for my RFX.
All I'm gonna say is I'm very impressed. :thumbsup:
The avy does feel noticably better, but it's also 1.5lbs heavier, even with a ti spring. So, all things considered, I'd call it even- it's great to have both options! Horses for courses.

I'm pretty stunned by the progress air shocks have made in the last 3 years.

I don't know much about Tim Flooks, but he seems to be full of hot air, hence:
I'm with FM, sounds like Tim doesn't know what the Flooks he's talking about...
 

·
steep fast and loose :)
Joined
·
3,270 Posts
Discussion Starter · #14 ·
thanks guys - food for thought.
fwiw, nicolai have designed the action of the Helius AM around the monarch 4.2 , 200mm i2i 57mm stroke !
i'll be slapping on a CCDB to determine differences and settings next week sometime.
 

·
carpe mañana
Joined
·
7,309 Posts
The_Lecht_Rocks said:
i fitted a CCDB to my HL 6 Pack - Phenomenal improvement once dialled in.
I'm experimenting with air shocks on my Nicolai Helius AM but have wallow mid stroke and pedal strike issues :(
I replaced the CCDB on my RFX with a PUSHed RP2. I just couldn't get the air shock to feel good. I got the Agrresive/Trail tune on it. It felt really wooden and it felt like it was packing down on fast, bumpy descents. When I sped up the rebound, it would try to launch me off on landing. It lasted a handful of rides, but I just couldn't endure the downgrade in the name of saving weight.

_MK
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,471 Posts
This being the Turner board, we really should be more specific ;)


I was never quite stoked on the performance of air shocks on my old '02 RFX (tried both a DHX air and RP3). Aside from the higher leverage ratio, the suspension felt a lot more linear, I always had a hard time balancing small bump compliance and bottom-out.

DT made a lot of changes starting with the '07 to make the bike more air-shock friendly. Lower leverage ratio, etc. Most people running the low-volume RP23's on the newer RFX's seem to be stoked with that particular combination. Hard to say how much is the frame design and how much is the shock, but again I'm very impressed with the PUSH'd low-volume rp23 on the '08 RFX. With %30 sag it doesn't bottom out, mid-range support is excellent with the low volume sleeve, and the pro-pedal feels unobtrusive.
 

·
Bite Me.
Joined
·
4,531 Posts
Air shocks are getting better and better I think and can get you quite close to a coil feel w/o the weight..

A bit off topic, but how would a low compression tune, low volume air sleeve RP23 compare to a high compression tune high volume air sleeve RP23 on an '08 RFX? 190lb rider - I'm on the cusp of getting the LV sleeve weight wise and currently run the HC/HV combo - wondering if PUSH and a LV sleeve would make much difference.
 

·
Moosehead
Joined
·
1,908 Posts
cutthroat said:
190lb rider - I'm on the cusp of getting the LV sleeve weight wise and currently run the HC/HV combo - wondering if PUSH and a LV sleeve would make much difference.
+1, would think it may even be more beneficial on your RFX. Works well on the Spot with Clyde at 225lbs.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,407 Posts
FM
I agree that there's too many factors involved and we need to be more specific. However the OP was regarding an unspecific statement(not a quoted statement mind you) from arguably the UK's most respected suspension tuner.

As you said, there's large variables year to year within one brand(06>07 RFX for example) that make sweeping statements regarding shock suitabilty irrelevant.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,471 Posts
cutthroat said:
A bit off topic, but how would a low compression tune, low volume air sleeve RP23 compare to a high compression tune high volume air sleeve RP23 on an '08 RFX? 190lb rider - I'm on the cusp of getting the LV sleeve weight wise and currently run the HC/HV combo - wondering if PUSH and a LV sleeve would make much difference.
I'm not sure rider weight is even that much of a deciding factor! I'm 180 and the LV definitely feels better than I remember the HV can feeling- of course it's been 6 months since I rode that stock hv-rp23.

I think the LV can offers more mid-stroke support and more progressiveness. It doesn't blow through travel like other fox air shocks I've owned. I also don't feel the pro-pedal, this shock feels active, not all choked up like propedal sometimes feels. Stays active, doesn't blow through travel, feels real good.

The avy coil still smokes it at high speed chop (not much surprise there). Not sure about bigger hits yet.
 
1 - 20 of 32 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top