If a saddle fits well enough, padded shorts are not even necessary. I found one this past fall. Unfortunately, I couldn't buy it because it was on a GT demo bike. I only rode it for 1/2 hour but that was enough time to realize it was the perfect saddle for me. There was only a brand name (Fizik) on it , no model.
When I brought the bike back to the GT Trailer, they asked me how I liked the bike and I told them it was ok but I've never felt a saddle anywhere near as comfortable as this one. They couldn't even tell me the model. I guess it was made by Fizik for GT. WTF! A once in a lifetime find and I can't buy one? I already have one Fizik and it feels like crap.
Does anyone have a 2011GT Sensor, the high end model, who's willing to sell their saddle? I'll pay 100.00 for it as long as it's in good shape - no rips or frayed edges.
Thanks for starting this thread. I will now go on a quest to find one of these "perfect" GT saddles.
My daughter just went through the same thing as you this past summer. One hour of riding made her so sore she had to take two days off before she could ride again. I bought her high quality shorts and it got a little better. but not much. I let her try out 5 of my saddles but they were all pretty much the same. I'm thinking women have wider sit bones then men. So I measured the width of my saddles and found they were all between 5&6" wide at the back. I went to Dick's sporting goods and picked up a comfort road bike saddle which was about 7" wide at the back. That did it! She could now ride 2 days in a row with absolutely no pain! She even rode one day without padded shorts. She felt a little discomfort without the padding but said it wasn't bad.
Before you go out buying saddles, make sure your current saddle is NOT tilted back. Even a very slight back tilt can cause a lot of pain. The longer the ride, the more it hurts.
If your bike fits you properly and saddle tilt is correct and you're still sore after a month of riding, DUMP the saddle.
Sorry for writing a short story. I just got so excited about that perfect GT saddle. LOL