[Jim311]

Yesterday I wasted an almost brand new X7 derailler, and I'm wondering if I should switch to mid cage to give myself a little more clearance? I typically only run a 32T rear cassette anyway.

 

[tiSS'er]

If you are running a triple in the front, you can get away with a mid cage, assuming you will not use the extreme gear combos. If you are running a dual ring, go with an X9 shorty. I just put one on my RFX and love it. Lots of clearance, really quick shifts, and less chainslap.

Larry at Mountain High has them for about the price of an X7 at my LBS.. Plus, the X9's are stronger. The composite cage worried me a bit, but has taken a beating in its first outing.

 

[Jim311]

I rarely ever cross chain and if I do it's 1x9 combo. Rarely ever use the big ring at all much less the big ring and the small cog!

 

[Jim311]

I rarely ever cross chain and if I do it's 1x9 combo. Rarely ever use the big ring at all much less the big ring and the small cog!

 

[62kona]

I put a med cage on my coiller and love it! Crisper shifting, less chain slap, more clearance. I'm sure a shortie would be even better though.

 

[PissedOffCil]

I use a short X9 on my 2X9 setup. I "lose" 2 gears though : the 26x11 and 26x13. Not being really usefull I didn't mind!

 

[daleksic]

Be sure you don't get too short with the shorty. A 2x9 should go with the Medium (i think). I dropped my 3rd gear in front and popped a medium lx derailleur in the back. I have enough clearance but I don't think a short one would do. Also I have a 22/32 in the front (not the 36) and the back I run 11-32.

 

[matt1976]

Should answer your question:

http://forums.mtbr.com/showthread.php?t=205890&highlight=long+cage

:thumbsup:

 

[savagemann]

I run an X9 in medium cage.....but bailed my 44t for a bashy. So I have a PG990 11-34 cassette, and 22-32-bash up front, and if I'm in the middle ring up front and 34 in the rear, all is good.
I'd say go medium cage. Shifts are faster/crisper and drivetrain seems quieter, less slap. Toss in additional clearance and it's a win-win.