I'd be very concerned
RM27 said:
Just installed the 4mm version on my 16" frame. It has plenty of clearence now since mine bairly rubbed with the stock King race. I do have some new concerns now, that I hope someone can shed some light on. The mechanic at the LBS said he would never install this on any bike for 2 reasons. 1) Said it will eventually become loose, due to the fact that a large portion of it sits above the area on the fork where it was meant to go and that portion of the steer tube isn't thick enough. 2) It will put too much stress on the steer tube causing damage to the fork or possibly frame. Not to mention the changing of the degree of the head angle. Now for the record, my money is on Sherwood and I believe he would take all these potential problems into account. The change in the head tube angle does have my attention. Any thoughts?
especially if you got that bike shop to do any work on your bike. I'd make sure you avoid that place like cancer. If you said the guy was a salesman, I'd say he's trying to steer you toward the Waldo 1000 headset that he sells that will do the job much "safer". The fact that it's a mechanic (assuming he doesn't sell stuff too) just makes me laugh.
1) If the crown race were like 4 inches long, his claim might actually have some mechanical validity. That fact is, the diameter of the steerer which is accurately machined is usually around 5mm. If the crown race is 4mm high, the entire diameter of the crown race is in full contact with the steerer tube. And the fit is an interference type press fit, not some running press fit that would allow movement. Additionally, where does the guy think the crown is going? Is it going to slip down over the crown and fall on the ground? Oh, I know - it's going to unpress itself from the steerer and actually move up the steerer, despite the fact that all the force is pushing down on the thing and the entire stack is held tight in tension by the stem clamping interface. In other words, the stem would have to move up the steerer for that crown race to have any place to go. I guess that guy thinks the top cap is a safety device to keep the stem from just popping off the end of the fork steerer.
2) This is funny at so many different levels, I'm not sure where to start. Let's just say, you can get more head angle variation over/under inflating your tires than you can switching from a standard to 4mm crown race. Your fork sag changes the head angle about 10 times what that 4mm crown race changes it. Also, there is more variance in the axle to crown lengths of some 100 mm forks than the 4mm crown race height introduces. I could go on and on, but this isn't even worth addressing.
Rest assured, you will be fine with the new crown race.