Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 59 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Long time lurker, first time poster. I conducted a search and haven't found much.

I'm finally ready to purchase a re-entry into MTB ride. I used to spend hours and hours on trails in my neighborhood as a kid, and because I really hate running and really love anything on wheels, I have decided to get back into MTB riding.

I'm not into brands/labels as much as I am quality and value. I realize that I'm not going to get a quality USA-made frame in my price range. I can't seem to find a better 'most bang for your buck' deal than the Moto Fantom 29Elite for $999 shipped.

Save up to 60% off new Mountain Bikes - MTB - Motobecane Fantom 29Elite

Can anyone talk me out of it?

Happy shredding,

Brad
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
Discussion Starter · #4 ·
I know folks with Motobecanes and they are fine bikes and a good value. Are you sure of your size?
I am about 5'7, 145-150lbs. According to the 'shove a book in your crotch and measure where it hits the wall' method, my inseam is about 30.75". I guess that sort of puts me between sizes-- although I've read it is better to size down. Yes?

The Airborne Guardian is an interesting choice as well, at only $675 shipped + pedals. I'd probably end up upgrading the FD and the fork at some point down the road, but it's a really good value as well. The Goblin is a bit too much at over $1300 including shipping and pedals.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
385 Posts
Put the Trek Cobia on your list. Picked up mine for $1050. 10 speed drivetrain and Recon Air Shock. Great bike.

My road bike is from Bike Directs. They are a good value.
 

·
Rogue Exterminator
Joined
·
4,951 Posts
Both bikesdirect and airborne are good values.
Have some wrenching skills for when it arrives/

The Morobecane is specked out much nicer than the Guardian.
Airborne also has the Goblin for $1200 which has nicer components than the Motobecane.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
Discussion Starter · #8 ·
Put the Trek Cobia on your list. Picked up mine for $1050. 10 speed drivetrain and Recon Air Shock. Great bike.

My road bike is from Bike Directs. They are a good value.
The Cobia has the Recon fork and 10spd drivetrain, but has a X5 RD and elixir1 brakes. I wonder if I'd find similar prices compared to their $1200 MSRP.

The Gravity 29.4 [that I somehow just discovered on bikesdirect] has the recon fork, 10spd drivetrain, but X9 RD and elixir3 brakes for $899... but after a bit of googling, is it true that the Recon fork also comes in a spring version? I guess if it doesn't say air, it is spring..? That's annoying. Haha.

In the specs list for the Moto Fantom29 Elite it says 'ROCKSHOX RECON SILVER TK29 SOLO AIR 29" QR 100mm LongTravel W/External rebound and TurnKey lockout'.
 

·
Rogue Exterminator
Joined
·
4,951 Posts
If $1200 is your range this is probably the most nicely spec bike for $1200 or less.

Airborne Bicycles. Goblin

You are kind of all over the board though in your shopping.
Figure out what you want to spend and go from there.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
11 Posts
Discussion Starter · #10 ·
If $1200 is your range this is probably the most nicely spec bike for $1200 or less.

Airborne Bicycles. Goblin

You are kind of all over the board though in your shopping.
Figure out what you want to spend and go from there.
I'd really like to be under $1000 when its all said and done. The Fantom29 Elite is right there on the nose. It has the DynaSYS transmission, Recon Air fork, Elixir3 brakes. It wouldn't really need any upgrades out the box aside from maybe pedals and saddle.

Even with all the floundering I'm doing, I still can't seem to find a better deal than that for the price. The Gravity 29.4 would be nice if I could easily convert the fork from spring to Air. It has X9/X7 10spd and the recon [I assume spring] fork. Is that possible? Sorry for the noob question there.
 

·
Rogue Exterminator
Joined
·
4,951 Posts
I have not heard much good or bad about Novara but I will say that nobody beats REI's customer service. Some places may match it but nobody will beat their lifetime satisfaction guarantee. That being said, if you have an REI near you, I would say go for it. If you are not satisfied with the bike, they will give you a full refund no questions asked and you can get something else from them or someplace else.

For $800 that bike is nicely equipped.
 

·
reading comprehension wat
Joined
·
328 Posts
How about this BMC Team Elite TE29 SLX from Backcountry for $1200? Lifetime returns. Good name brand, good parts, good geo, good looking, and good price. Only in large though.

BMC Team Elite TE29/Shimano SLX Complete Bike - 2012 | Backcountry.com



SizeSTETTStackReachHTHASACSBB Drop
Large21.1in
(53.6cm)
25.2in
(64.0cm)
24.8in
(63.0cm)
17.7in
(45.0cm)
4.33in
(11.0cm)
70.0 deg73.0 deg16.9in
(42.9cm)
2.25in
(5.7cm)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
115 Posts
How about this BMC Team Elite TE29 SLX from Backcountry for $1200? Lifetime returns. Good name brand, good parts, good geo, good looking, and good price. Only in large though.

BMC Team Elite TE29/Shimano SLX Complete Bike - 2012 | Backcountry.com



SizeSTETTStackReachHTHASACSBB Drop
Large21.1in
(53.6cm)
25.2in
(64.0cm)
24.8in
(63.0cm)
17.7in
(45.0cm)
4.33in
(11.0cm)
70.0 deg73.0 deg16.9in
(42.9cm)
2.25in
(5.7cm)
That bike is sweet!!!! Great components and looks tight.....why no XL size????
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
37 Posts
Not a fan of motobecanes, Windsors or their Gravity lines. i have ridden them and hated everything about them. They geometetry is way off, they don't handle well and have many structural problems. The sales guy even tried to tell me it was the same exact bike as a Giant or Specialized but with a different sticker. They can sell them for less because they don't advertise like the big companies, but it was the same bike! What a crock of poo!! They aren't even close to any other brand except their own!
My suggestion is go rideone, then test ride a few others in the same price range from Cannondale, giant, Specialized, niner, etc and feel the difference. I sold my Giant XTC composite 3 and replaced it with the $1000 Giant Talon 29er 0. I figured at almost half the price I could save the money for a nice set of road racing wells since my real passion is the road. I would rather have a new pair of Zipp Firecrest 404's then a carbon frame that gets ridden only a few times a year while the Zipp 404 will get thusands of miles..

Try other brands besides what is sold at Bikesdirect.com or Cycle Spectrum (same company, same guy) and you will be so glad you did!

just my thought's... oh and I love the Giant Talon 29er 0. Fast, light, and handles great. I was shocked at how nice it was for the price. best money move I made all year... well, so far.

Good luck!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
20 Posts
Hey guys, I am a long time lurker of the board but had to chime in here with my first post. Brad - my story is right in line with yours. Over 10 years ago I received my first Schwinn hardtail (about $700 at the time) and have continued to shred it every year (even though the frame is 2 sizes too small for me lol). Don't mean to hijack your thread here but I am getting ready to purchase a new bike around the $1000 mark as well. I had my heart set on a Trek Mamba but then started reading this board and the Airborne Goblin really caught my eye for $1199 (plus shipping/pedals/assembly if needed). My problem arose after reading more into the 'all mountain' forum where the more agressive frame/geo/shock seems like something I am extremely interested in. My question to the posters in this thread - Is it even worth looking for an 'all mountain' setup with a budget of around $1300 max? I live in Missouri and the trails are mostly rocky singletrack with some techy sections as well. Not really any DH/extreme terrain so thinking the XC style would still tackle everything I threw at it. Also came across the Kona Taro for $1299 which is considered 'all mountain' but has low end components compared to what I could get on the Goblin. Let me know if any of you guys have any input!
 
1 - 20 of 59 Posts
Top