I rode both and they are amazing bikes, that's for sure. I however personally prefer the Scott but that doesn't mean that one is better than the other. Simply choose whatever fits you best.I've all but refined my search to a 2013 model of either the Scott Spark RC 900, or the Trek Superfly 100 Pro SL.
Has anyone got any head-to-head experience with these bikes?
Scott is changing order right now and things are supposedly going to get better. The new CEO of the company is changing their home base from Sun Valley, ID to Park City, UT and will be focusing on the biking industry in the years to come as their main cash source for the US. My buddy works for them as a Ski/Running rep for the west coast and he was only 1 of 4 reps that were kept on after the change (he has a multi-discipline in climbing, bikes, running, and skiing) and the CEO told him at their last big rep meeting that things were going to do a general shift towards biking for the use as a focus.Both are dreamy, fast and sweet bikes. The Superfly is a tab more nimble, and Trek's warranty is second to none.
I had a carbon Scott road bike and the warranty process was a complete nightmare, for a premium, imported frame maker. Trek wins hands-down here....
Yes the Santa Cruz Tallboy 2 is a very good option. No experience on the Scott but the Tallboy against the superfly I compared for a time. The superfly does not seem to confidence inspiring as the Tallboy did plus the Tallboy seemed a really sharp and snappy in turns. The VPP suspension was more plush in the rough rocky areas compared to the Trek and it seemed to pedal with the least amount to pedal bob. For context, this was a tallboy with a 120mm front fork. I have heard about the Scott warranty problems but as said on the previous post, maybe the new leader will steer the ship in a better direction. Yes Trek has a good warranty but the cracking problems are well known with Treks. Not worth it for carbon if you are having to swap out your frame due to cracks. The inconvenience, tear down, and time not riding is no good even if they warranty it well. Plus most shops charge for a tear down and rebuild and that is not covered in a warranty. Another option is the newly redone Niner Jet 9 RDO as well.santa cruz tallboy.