So, I tried it...and dig it for sure. I bought a 2019 DPS and in the couple of short rides so far I'm not missing the LT.
My motivation to try ST mode was threefold:
1. The short travel shock size was on closeout
2. I was interested in the snappy pedaling that the ST reviews have mentioned (I haven't
had concerns with the snappiness in LT mode, but was still a little curious. I mean, can
15mm make that much of a difference? I have a Transition Patrol for bigger days, so
giving up some rear travel on the Knolly isn't much of an overall sacrifice.
3. I ride a small frame and can't fit a water bottle with a piggy back shock (seriously, this
was some of my motivation and I didn't want a non piggy back in LT)
Current build highlights:
Lyrik Ultimate at 150mm, 42mm offset
DPS shock at 120mm
DT Swiss M1700 30 wheels
GX drivetrain with Zee brakes
It's a relatively budget build (all things considered), but it was built for durability in a max budget of $4200
So far, I've ridden this frame with a 160mm 51 offset Lyrik RCT3 and the following LT shocks: RS Super Deluxe, Fox X2, and Fox DPX2
The picture here in 150 / 120 mode is so far my favorite. It is noticeably snappier with the ST shock in the ups and flats. I don't feel like I've given much up on the downs either. My local trails are Mt. Galbraith in Bellingham, so I certainly have access to some gnarly stuff. I would not hesitate to ride much of it in this current configuration. It doesn't feel unbalanced at all - in fact I think it's more balanced than when it's been in 160 / 135 mode.
At any rate, I'm super pumped about it and will be keeping it as is for a while. I think it's the perfect trail bike.
In a different thread, I'll share some more details and thoughts about all the various configurations I've tried with this frame.
FYI, I'll be selling at least one of my LT shocks if anyone is interested (Fox DPX2 and Fox X2).