Mountain Bike Reviews Forum banner
1 - 20 of 38 Posts

·
Harmonius Wrench
Joined
·
8,254 Posts
Observations

Single speed: Cool color! EBB and integrated headset add weight. Also, it's got hydro brakes, which are heavier. That said, it wouldn't surprise me if the listed weight is incorrect. But it's probably close. A Raleigh XXIX weighs in at 27lbs on my scale with a rigid fork. Finally, if that rig comes with a radially laced front wheel like the picture shows I'd not be pleased about that!

Hardtails: Why is a shade of green on everybodies 29"er? Spec seems about right, although the "Pro" weight seems a bit optimistic. Prices are pretty well on the mark considering other 29"ers I've looked at. Standout spec items are the Avid hydro brakes and Ignitor tires. Finally, something other than an Exi!

Ibex has a 29"er coming out that looks to have the identical frame to these for their hardtail FS model. You can score that one for a grand if you pre order it.

As for me, I'm not an integrated headset fan, so that's a deal killer for me.
 

·
Doesntplaywellwithmorons!
Joined
·
10,939 Posts
Wish I Were Riding said:
Wonder why the SS is heavier AND the same price as the geared bike??? 70mm BB drop? cool
Higher spec disc brakes and cranks, trail bike rims instead of xc rims, felt custom hubs, different frame with an EBB, also it looks like the SS includes platform pedals but the nine elite doesn't have pedals pictured. Just including platform pedals alone would account for about a pound and a half of weight probably.
 

·
If you have to ask...
Joined
·
720 Posts
Guitar Ted said:
Single speed: Cool color! EBB and integrated headset add weight. Also, it's got hydro brakes, which are heavier. That said, it wouldn't surprise me if the listed weight is incorrect. But it's probably close. <snip>
"It has hydro brakes, which are heavier" than what? The entire line has hydros.

Also, hydros are only heavier than mechanicals if you use reverse math. Weights for the hydraulics always are a complete front brake assembly- rotor, caliper, line, fluid, and lever whereas mechanicals only call out the weight of the caliper and rotor set.
Therefore weights would need to be normalized-
Hydro system < mechanical system including cable, housing, and brake lever

For example, Avid calls out 428g for their Juicy 5. However, the BB7 weighs in at 318 (325 for the BB5). Their lightest lever is the Speed Dial SL, at 150. We're up to 468g already, and we haven't factored in the cable or housing, both of which are heavier than their respective hydro counterparts.

Hydraulics ARE lighter than mechanicals. It's that simple.

miles
 

·
Always Learning
Joined
·
9,608 Posts
cobblestone said:
http://www.feltracing.com/news/default.asp#11

I like the spec on these like the 180 cranks on the biggest size. 29lbs for the ss seems a bit heavy though!
I like the geared version of the Nine Pro. Weight claim of 25.75 lbs (doesn't say what size that is), but a wheelset upgrade could easily trim a pound off of that.
 

Attachments

·
Bored
Joined
·
1,982 Posts
Guitar Ted said:
Finally, if that rig comes with a radially laced front wheel like the picture shows I'd not be pleased about that!
I think that image of the Solo is computer generated, and its easier to model radial lacing.
 

·
Harmonius Wrench
Joined
·
8,254 Posts
Sorry!

miles said:
"It has hydro brakes, which are heavier" than what? The entire line has hydros.

Also, hydros are only heavier than mechanicals if you use reverse math. Weights for the hydraulics always are a complete front brake assembly- rotor, caliper, line, fluid, and lever whereas mechanicals only call out the weight of the caliper and rotor set.
Therefore weights would need to be normalized-
Hydro system < mechanical system including cable, housing, and brake lever

For example, Avid calls out 428g for their Juicy 5. However, the BB7 weighs in at 318 (325 for the BB5). Their lightest lever is the Speed Dial SL, at 150. We're up to 468g already, and we haven't factored in the cable or housing, both of which are heavier than their respective hydro counterparts.

Hydraulics ARE lighter than mechanicals. It's that simple.

miles
I stand corrected. I had forgotten the weights of mechs did not include the levers and lines. Thanks for pointing that out.
 

·
If you have to ask...
Joined
·
720 Posts
Guitar Ted said:
I stand corrected. I had forgotten the weights of mechs did not include the levers and lines. Thanks for pointing that out.
A very common mistake. Perpetuated by the component manufacturers, no doubt.

miles
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
375 Posts
miles said:
"It has hydro brakes, which are heavier" than what? The entire line has hydros.

Also, hydros are only heavier than mechanicals if you use reverse math. Weights for the hydraulics always are a complete front brake assembly- rotor, caliper, line, fluid, and lever whereas mechanicals only call out the weight of the caliper and rotor set.
Therefore weights would need to be normalized-
Hydro system < mechanical system including cable, housing, and brake lever

For example, Avid calls out 428g for their Juicy 5. However, the BB7 weighs in at 318 (325 for the BB5). Their lightest lever is the Speed Dial SL, at 150. We're up to 468g already, and we haven't factored in the cable or housing, both of which are heavier than their respective hydro counterparts.

Hydraulics ARE lighter than mechanicals. It's that simple.

miles
Your also listing the weight of 2 levers, with one caliper, which moves you down to 393 plus cables.
 

·
ballbuster
Joined
·
12,718 Posts
Yep...

miles said:
"It has hydro brakes, which are heavier" than what? The entire line has hydros.

Also, hydros are only heavier than mechanicals if you use reverse math. Weights for the hydraulics always are a complete front brake assembly- rotor, caliper, line, fluid, and lever whereas mechanicals only call out the weight of the caliper and rotor set.
Therefore weights would need to be normalized-
Hydro system < mechanical system including cable, housing, and brake lever

For example, Avid calls out 428g for their Juicy 5. However, the BB7 weighs in at 318 (325 for the BB5). Their lightest lever is the Speed Dial SL, at 150. We're up to 468g already, and we haven't factored in the cable or housing, both of which are heavier than their respective hydro counterparts.

Hydraulics ARE lighter than mechanicals. It's that simple.

miles
Thread Hijack alert!

I shaved 2/3 of a pound off my bike by dumping my BB7s and going with Magura Claras. Another plus side, they felt way better. In the negative side, they sucked in a fat air bubble once a month, requiring a bleeding... and ruining my rides. Swapped those out for some Hope Mono Minis, lost a few more grams, and gained some great frickin brakes.
 

·
Doesntplaywellwithmorons!
Joined
·
10,939 Posts
Guitar Ted said:
Single speed: Cool color! EBB and integrated headset add weight.
As for me, I'm not an integrated headset fan, so that's a deal killer for me.
EBB's add weight yes, but intergrated headsets do NOT. If anything, most intergrated headsets (whether they be internal or zero stack) are lighter than conventional headsets. It would be nice if they gave a better model identity for the headset. Internal and Zero Stack do have some differences.
 

·
Harmonius Wrench
Joined
·
8,254 Posts
You're right, but.....

DeeEight said:
EBB's add weight yes, but intergrated headsets do NOT. If anything, most intergrated headsets (whether they be internal or zero stack) are lighter than conventional headsets. It would be nice if they gave a better model identity for the headset. Internal and Zero Stack do have some differences.
By necessity, the head tube itself has to be reinforced to accomodate the bearings and spread the loading forces adequately so as to not deform the head tube. This weight must be accounted for since it is in effect part of the "head set" of the bike, as it were. Usually this means that the overall weight will end up being more than a conventional headset and frame, but this is difficult to demonstrate.

But be that as it may, the thing that I really don't like is that integrated headsets on mountain bikes introduce a higher risk of frame failure and limit your head set choices. It's something that is just not necessary. What problem does an integrated headset solve anyway?

Back to the initial discussion: The Felt 29"er line. It's an interesting line up, but it really isn't all that different than some others. Some spec differences, yes. The standout seems to be the Pro model, which leads the way as far as a nicely spec'ed 29"er for the money. The SS seems a bit pricey for the weight and spec, and the Elite seems about right in terms of what else is out there in that spec and price range.

Nice to have more choices. Nice to see the hydro brake spec and Maxxis tire spec -that is different. I wish they would have avoided the integrated headset. That to me is the lineups downfall.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
268 Posts
heythorp said:
1500 for a 29 lbs SS is just stupid. i was really interested when i saw this thread but not anymore

I just got off the phone with the engineer that designed this bike and he has informed me that the weight of the Nine Solo is wrong. As soon as they have the correct weight the website will be changed.
 

·
If you have to ask...
Joined
·
720 Posts
Fulton said:
Your also listing the weight of 2 levers, with one caliper, which moves you down to 393 plus cables.
I don't believe it. That would put each lever at 75g, which isn't much more than the incredibly delicate Kooka levers from days gone by. I'd have to see them weighed to be convinced.
In fact, over at Weightweenies, they specifically call out 188g for a pair of Speed Dial Ti levers.

miles
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,087 Posts
Rob M. said:
heythorp said:
1500 for a 29 lbs SS is just stupid. i was really interested when i saw this thread but not anymore

I just got off the phone with the engineer that designed this bike and he has informed me that the weight of the Nine Solo is wrong. As soon as they have the correct weight the website will be changed.
thanks rob, did he give you any indication of what it actually weighs?
 
1 - 20 of 38 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top