epi/ asr 5c
Just went from a epiphany to a yeti 575. My epi was a fairly light build at 25.2 lbs and it was an amazing climber/descender, I don't know if your going to find a 5+ inch bike that is as good up as it is down. I got to ride a new asr-5c but only in the parking lot. Felt very quick, but was a little more XC feeling than I was looking for, so I went with the 575. I guess it really just depends on your intended use, the asr 5 kinda had that "high" feel as well. I can't give you an in-depth report on the asr 5 but I can assure you, you would not be disappointed with the epiphany. You could go and hit the narly aggressive stuff and turn around and hold your own in an xc/endurance race with the epi. Good luck with your decision, make sure you demo both before you pull the trigger