Argh, just noticed the sizing chart differences on the SC site. Crud. I'm 6' 1.5" so I'm right on the cusp of their L ans XL in the XC carbon. I have only test ridden a 2008 Alu XC, and Large seemed about right, or maybe a teensy bit small ... which makes me think maybe XL for the carbon. BUT I've been on bikes that were too small and others that were too big, and I'd take too small any day ...
Dang it, nobody local seems to have any XC carbons in stock (unsurprisingly) ...