I know "best" is a relative term, but I'm looking for opinions on decent quality mass production mountain bikes. Everyone can't afford a Potts, Cunningham, Ritchey, Bontrager, etc. No Diamondback will compare with the mistique, attention to detail and overall quality that went into a Yo Eddy. However, there must be a few decent mass produced bikes out there? What brands made good quality for the price in the 80's and 90's? I'm thinking Specialized, GT, Trek, Cannondale, etc. I don't want to get into a bash session that a Trek 970 is a POS, just honest opinions for those that want to restore or get into vintage without having to automatically jump on one of the "cool brands." There are no "right" answers, just opinions. Let the fun begin!
11 Years on from the first post.
I bought loads of bikes in the 1990's. Every manufacturer had a Niche back then. Cannondale were all Aluminium, Trek had decent frames, Fisher had odd groupsets (to hit price points), Orange were built to your own spec and you had a big choice of build options. Orange were my favourite to buy as you specked the bike and then it was built for you. you chose Frame, Size, Colour, stem size, wheels, forks and groupset. When the bike arrived it was a perfect fit.
At the time I always thought Breezer, Bontrager and Ritchey were behind the times. However I now ride a retro Breezer Storm and it's wonderful to ride. The bikes that are most sought after are not necessarily the bikes I thought would be. Rockhoppers and Hardrocks seem very sought after being sensibly priced and Iconic with the 1990's.
The best buys I have seen are Muddy Fox bikes and it was Muddy Fox that brought MTB to the UK in a major way. Yet these bike are very cheap and people seem to think MuddyFox and Muddy Fox are the same. Some of the Muddy Fox range was made in Japan using the same steel and dropouts as the Breezer or Ritchey bikes. A Muddy Fox Monarch can be a very cheap bike.
The bikes I see being worth money in the future are Breezer, Fisher, Bontrager, Ritchey, Stumpjumpers and anything else historically connected to MTB's. The big thing is that these bikes all started off as rigid bikes. It's important that they stay this way. The only things I change on older bikes are saddles, grips and tyres. Everything else I leave original as possible.
Bianchi and Cinelli bikes are also worth keeping an eye on as both have a used following. The Cinelli Bikes were the best painted bikes in my opinion. The Bianchi bikes often bringing new ideas to Mountain biking. My Favourite is the FY620 which lead the way for Full Suspension bikes. (Good Luck finding one.)