hmmm Thinkin I should put more into cleaning the drivetrain more often...
thanks guys!
Chances are, you are over-lubricating.
Seems that's how it goes. Maybe they start out under-lubricating and they get chastised somewhere (riding buddies, LBS, randos on the trail commenting on how awful the bike sounds, whatever) for it, and then they transition to using too much (or maybe they start out using too much because they're afraid of under-lubricating). Either way, it doesn't really matter what chain lube you use, if you use too much, it's going to get really nasty. Some collect grime more than others, of course, and some need to be applied more frequently or less frequently (which means you have to figure that out for yourself, the conditions you ride in, and the lube you've chosen). But the result of over-lubrication is the same. Dirt sticks to it.
When I stopped over-lubricating, the need to
clean it reduced substantially.