REVIEWS DEALS BIKESHOPS TRAILS

Anyone running this on a 1X10/9 Setup?

2894 Views 14 Replies 12 Participants Last post by philw86, Mar 9, 2011

joshuagore

Discussion Starter · Mar 4, 2011

http://www.e13components.com/product_xcx_st.html

I have a MRP 1x its bb mounted, and the plastic cracked so I am looking to replace it, but would prefer seat tube mounted. I know that area is 'tight' to say the least... anyone try this or anything similar?

bike 2009 Sultan
Josh

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

expatrider

· #2 · Mar 4, 2011 (Edited)

Never seen the point of these. If you have a spare front der. lying around then you could just use that, as it will do the same thing. If you want good chain retention, then run a chainguide with at least a lower pulley to increase chain tension. I have used the Lopes SL which is pretty minimalistic, light, but excellent. This is a good option if you don't need a bash, which I assume you don't as the xcx won't work with bash either.

MAX LLOYD

· #3 · Mar 5, 2011

Hi,
Am currently building up my 2011 Flux with the E13 guide,BB mount.Waiting for a few parts! Will let you know how i get on in a few weeks!
Thanx Max

joshuagore

Discussion Starter · #4 · Mar 6, 2011

expatrider said:
Never seen the point of these. If you have a spare front der. lying around then you could just use that, as it will do the same thing. If you want good chain retention, then run a chainguide with at least a lower pulley to increase chain tension. I have used the Lopes SL which is pretty minimalistic, light, but excellent. This is a good option if you don't need a bash, which I assume you don't as the xcx won't work with bash either.

I agree a lower chain guide is probably optimal but I was avoiding it as I have not needed it. I was mostly looking to replace and avoid mrp as I am not a fan of the plastic they use in my 1.x and was equally not impressed with the plastic they use on the g2.

I will checkout the options from ethirteen including those using a lower pulley.
Josh

sennaster

· #5 · Mar 6, 2011

I'm running a bbg inner guard in place of my little ring, and a race face bash on the outside. I've never had any issues.

http://www.bbgbashguard.com/Mountainbike.html

Tenzing

· #6 · Mar 6, 2011

sennaster said:
I'm running a bbg inner guard in place of my little ring, and a race face bash on the outside. I've never had any issues.

http://www.bbgbashguard.com/Mountainbike.html

Same here. Although, I find there's a bit of chain rub in the two lowest gears on my 2010 Spot (with BB spacer installed on the non-drive side as well). Never had any issues when I had this set-up on my Burner though.

Sparticus

· #7 · Mar 6, 2011

2

The ethirteen xcx-st... I don't see an adjustment for distance between seat tube and chainring -- only for up & down. Is there an adjustment for moving it inboard / outboard?

Love to have one of these on my new Sultan, but not sure if it'll do what I need it to. Thanks.

--sParty

P.S. Will be running 195mm square taper cranks on 122mm spindle. Single 30t ring + Shimano 11-36t 10-spd cassette. Also considering running a bashwich but don't know if there'll be room for the inner bash. Bike's not built yet... awaiting custom ti chainring...

See less See more

scrublover

· #8 · Mar 6, 2011

Sparticus said:
The ethirteen xcx-st... I don't see an adjustment for distance between seat tube and chainring -- only for up & down. Is there an adjustment for moving it inboard / outboard?

Love to have one of these on my new Sultan, but not sure if it'll do what I need it to. Thanks.

--sParty

P.S. Will be running 195mm square taper cranks on 122mm spindle. Single 30t ring + Shimano 11-36t 10-spd cassette. Also considering running a bashwich but don't know if there'll be room for the inner bash. Bike's not built yet... awaiting custom ti chainring...

Sparty-

the instructions show some shims to adjust things in the lateral plane, but not sure if that would be enough. Suppose it would work unless you're running some completely whack chain-line or something.

https://www.e13components.com/setup_instructions/xcx_st_etype_web.pdf

Sparticus

· #9 · Mar 6, 2011

scrublover said:
Sparty-

the instructions show some shims to adjust things in the lateral plane, but not sure if that would be enough. Suppose it would work unless you're running some completely whack chain-line or something.

http://www.e13components.com/setup_instructions/xcx_st_etype_web.pdf

Thanks Scrubs. Damn, a guy can get all of 1mm of lateral adjustment out of that device? Whoa. Hope I've got clearance to run a bashwich.

Anyway, thanks for doing that research for me.

I'm getting kinda itchy to get this beauty built. Other than my wheels, crank, stem & bars, everything's gonna be brand new. I haven't built a dream bike in 9 years. Thought the Salsa Big Mama I built 2 years ago would be that, and it was indeed a fine bicycle... I mainly didn't like the color.

Well, that plus it was no Turner.

--sParty

Sparticus

· #10 · Mar 7, 2011

...bashwich pic. Not what I'll end up with but it proves that there's clearance to run bashwich on the Sultan frame. Plenty of clearance.

--sParty

See less See more

CharacterZero

· #11 · Mar 7, 2011 (Edited)

joshuagore said:
I agree a lower chain guide is probably optimal but I was avoiding it as I have not needed it. I was mostly looking to replace and avoid mrp as I am not a fan of the plastic they use in my 1.x and was equally not impressed with the plastic they use on the g2.

I will checkout the options from ethirteen including those using a lower pulley.
Josh

IF you are using an "unapproved" lube for either the MRP or the e.thirteen, you will see premature plastic failure.
e.thirteen list

MRP says these are ok:
Regular Tri-flow (NOT Triflow Dry)
White Lightning
White Lightning Wet
Pedros Syn Lube
Finish Line Wet

I had to change from my favorite Prolink to Triflow when I moved to a taco-bash setup on a new bike.

NoahColorado

· #12 · Mar 8, 2011

joshuagore said:
I agree a lower chain guide is probably optimal but I was avoiding it as I have not needed it. I was mostly looking to replace and avoid mrp as I am not a fan of the plastic they use in my 1.x and was equally not impressed with the plastic they use on the g2.

I will checkout the options from ethirteen including those using a lower pulley.
Josh

Sorry about that. I handle all the warranty claims for MRP and we don't see many plastic failures unless bolts have been over torqued or one of the lubes listed in the post below have been used.

Hope you find a guide that fits your needs, cheers :thumbsup:

In any case I'd recommend a guide with lower retention, 1x-style guides are aimed at hardtails and short travel bikes...

6thElement

· #13 · Mar 8, 2011

I think it's lubes with mineral oil in them which have issues with some plastics. My normal prolink gold destroyed a couple of different plastic bash guards.

WHALENARD

· #14 · Mar 9, 2011

Just an FYI Rohloff makes a seat tube mount upper chain guide. It includes spacers for precise chain alignment and fits several diameter seat tubes. Nice plastic and very simple well thought out peice. With that said I didn't run it long because I to prefer just running a lower pulley for trail riding

philw86

· #15 · Mar 9, 2011

Sparticus said:
Thanks Scrubs. Damn, a guy can get all of 1mm of lateral adjustment out of that device? Whoa. Hope I've got clearance to run a bashwich.
--sParty

50-53mm Chainline adjustment via the included 3 cams...should have no issues with the majority of 50mm cranksets on the market. Simple and strong.

6thElement said:
I think it's lubes with mineral oil in them which have issues with some plastics. My normal prolink gold destroyed a couple of different plastic bash guards.

Unfortunately, many of the harsh solvents used in some chainlubes (for dissolving that dirt) will chemically attack the bonds in the plastics. There isn't one chemical compound that does it...there are quite a few. Over-torquing and impacts (micro-vibrations) speed up cracking as well. Our Approved Lubricant Summary is worth taking a look at.

Cheers,
philip @ theHive/e*thirteen

See less See more

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.