Submitted by
Scott
a Weekend Warrior
from Boise, ID Date Reviewed: July 17, 2003
Favorite Trail:
gotta go with porc rim
Duration Product Used:
More than 3 years
Price Paid:
$1250.00
Purchased At:
World Cycle
Strengths:
Super lightweight Easton Frame and the Hayes Discs of course! The riser bar works for me too.
Weaknesses:
There's a pretty noticeable creak in the frame when I'm cranking hard uphill, fork is leaking fluid out the top of the right side stanchion.
Similar Products Used:
Nothing REALLY similar, but previous hardtails I've had include a '98 Trek 8300 and a '97 GT Karakoram
Bike Setup:
Swapped pedals for M545's, tires for Velociraptors (still my fave tire of all time), and saddle for WTB Ti Rail. Everything else is stock.
Bottom Line:
A do-anything-once hardtail made for the trail rider who doesn't want full suspension. This bike is NOT intended to be a racer with its stock set-up, so if you come across this bike in the classifieds, please bear that in mind. I did Moab in the spring of '99 with my Trek and now wish I would've gotten the X-Cal in time for the trip. The bike has made me a much more confident descender, and with the slacker geometry and heavier weight, has also made my climbing style much more powerfully efficient. And it's also managed to go more than three years without any major rebuilds or repairs. I'll be moving on to full suspension in the near future, but the X-Cal will always be remembered as the catalyst for my "new-and-improved" riding ability. Four and a half flamin' chilis picantes for value since I did have to swap some parts and a full five for overall because it is so d*mned fun.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Halvard Avdem
a Weekend Warrior
from Norway Date Reviewed: August 7, 2002
Favorite Trail:
everywhere
Duration Product Used:
2 Years
Price Paid:
$1500.00
Purchased At:
bikeshop
Strengths:
The frame,perfect geometry,climbs like there were no tomorrow. Hayes brakes, bontrager stuff, excpt the wheels.
Weaknesses:
Manitou fork, Bontrager rear hub, I managed to bend the axle when i was way out in the woods, suddenly the freehub did not work. Bad paint.
Similar Products Used:
GT Ruckus 1.0, 2.0, avalanche, Zaskar x. Gary fisher x caliber 2000.(better fork) Trek 8900, 8500 and many more
Bike Setup:
Sid fork (upgrading to Black or Sherman or fox) SRAM 9.0/9.0sl all over, selleitalia seat, tioga XC tires, THE fender
Bottom Line:
Great bike superb handling both uphill and downhill,tioga really sticks to anything.The SID will have to go its to flexy, wheels will also have to go, as soon as i can afford it. Sram kicks ass never any trouble.Perfect for all day thrashing. A few minor upgrades and it would suit almost anyone.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Rob Wilson
a Downhiller
from New Hampshire Date Reviewed: November 15, 2001
Favorite Trail:
anywhere with drops
Duration Product Used:
More than 3 years
Price Paid:
$1300.00
Purchased At:
Summer's Backcountry Outfitters (Thanks John, you RULE!)
Strengths:
The frame has absolutely AMAZING geometry. For the most part the components spec. is great.
Weaknesses:
The fork - Can you say "pogo stick with blown seals?" The saddle - Easily changed though The wheels - What were they thinking?! these things look like they belong on a road bike! I cracked the rear wheel two weeks after buying the the thing.
Similar Products Used:
None
Bike Setup:
'01 Psylo XC set at 5" Sun Mammoth front wheel 24" Doublewide rear wheel on a Hugi hub. XT rear der. LX chain rings and driveside crank arm Specialized non-driveside crank arm (I rounded the square taper on the LX on a 6' to flat) Primo Super Tenderizer pedals SDG Bel Air saddle Hayes 6" hydraulic discs (YEAH BABY!) 2.35 IRC Kujo DH front/rear tires
Bottom Line:
Let me say this: I LOVE THIS BIKE! This bike is 100% sure footed in almost any terrain. With the 24" rear wheel it's a bit of a pig up the hills, but throw a 26" back on and BAM! You my friend, have yourself a billy goat on crack. I've done as big as a 7' to flat on this thing with absolutely no complaints from the frame. The landings are a bit harsh, but hey, its aluminum, so i'm not complaining on that. If they had just put on a better fork and wheelset, this bike would blow away most of the competition right off the show oom floor. Now...all I need are those Azonic 454 cranks, and the Evil chain guide...
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Artemus
a Downhiller
from Napa Valley California USA Date Reviewed: November 1, 2001
Favorite Trail:
Buckeye/Skyline Park
Duration Product Used:
More than 3 years
Price Paid:
$1000.00
Purchased At:
employee purchase (bike shop)
Strengths:
geometry/easton tubing/high speed stability stiff rear triangle/disc brakes/wheels berzerker DH saddle/quik release seat post clamp/ climbs like a billygoat/descends like a speeding bullit
Weaknesses:
weak production fork/I upgaded with an aftermarket 98'dual- crown XvertR 4" stroke fork.this fork was made for this bike steel crow bar/stock tires suck.switched to Specialized Team tires after two rides Gary emblazed his name on the frame nine times!
Similar Products Used:
Klein Mantra comp/Santa Cruz Chameleon Specialized Sworks M2 comp
Bike Setup:
98'Manitou XvertR/gold Pro Taper 2.5 riser bar/generic short stem/MRP dual slalom chain guide/Carumba cranks/black and yellow EXUS DH clipless pedals/00' SRAM 9.0 Halfpipe 9 speed shifter & derailer/IRC MythosXC 2.1 on the front/Specialized Team Control 2.0(front specific)on the rear yellow roll-a-ma-jig is a nice touch
Bottom Line:
When I got my hands on my xcaliber lata in 98', it was the first and only long travel, or "freeride" hardtail on the market.I saw it at Interbike98' and had to have it!(despite the paint job) The genisis geometry is great for climbing,and bombin'down. This summer it placed me in the top five in sport class-dual slalom five times,twice in the final.It rips with precision! The ultimate go anywhere,do anything bike.With three bottle cage mounts you can go faaar.Not quite an XCracer,but works for that too. Highly recommend.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
joe doone
a Racer
from midland Date Reviewed: August 7, 2001
Favorite Trail:
i like them all
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Price Paid:
$550.00
Purchased At:
a house
Strengths:
29 speed is excellent the. it is not very heavy compared to so bikes i have tried for the same price range. i just bought a thud buster they are great the colour of the bike is great lots of people notice it because of it. the disk brakes are great they work like a charm.
Weaknesses:
well there is no weakness with this bike well except for the seat but thats not a big deal
Similar Products Used:
none that i am a ware of
Bike Setup:
xt,lx,hayes
Bottom Line:
garyfisher is the way to go it is the best and the genis geometry is wicked if you have a chance to buy a a bike buy this one its awsome the reason i paid 550 for this bike is because i bought it off my uncle
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Dave L
a Weekend Warrior
from Vancouver, WA Date Reviewed: July 11, 2001
Favorite Trail:
Lewis River, Woopty, Siouxion Creek
Duration Product Used:
2 Years
Price Paid:
$1300.00
Purchased At:
Bike Gallery, Portland, OR
Strengths:
Great frame geometry, awesome brakes, excellant climber, good overall componants
Weaknesses:
bad tires, horrible seat, disk brake roter bolts come loose, seat post clamp had to be messed with a lot to prevent seat from creaping down
Bike Setup:
Rock Shocks seatpost, Specialized Body Geometry seat, SKS fenders for our 9 months of rain, bar ends to make it an even better climber.
Bottom Line:
Super fun bike. Been riding serious single track trails since 1988 in Californin, Oregon & Washington and this is the most fun bike I've had. I'm a big rider, 6'1" & well over 200 lbs and this bike (large frame) handles awesome, from technical climbing and switchbacks to hauling a$$ downhill and everything inbetween. I've only bent the back rim & 1 spoke once and it trued up beautiful. Didn't like the bright color at first but it grows on ya. Nobody thats tried my bike didn't like it. Great ride!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Mark
a Cross Country Rider
from Upland Date Reviewed: April 3, 2001
Favorite Trail:
Anything Really Sick
Duration Product Used:
2 Years
Price Paid:
$1095.00
Purchased At:
SuperGo
Strengths:
Frame, frame geometry, brakes, and fork before it breaks. This bike climbs what most riders only ride down. Descents are fast, precise and confident. The best at any price for hardtail free ride.
Weaknesses:
Fork when it breaks, LX chain rings, stock chain, rear hub, and paint. The fork is sweet before breaking. For 170-lb. rider it bottoms a couple times on each ride and eventually disintegrates. For my riding style, bottoming the fork a couple time a ride is good, I know I’m using all the suspension. I replaced the original fork with a 2000 Manitou Xvert (only $199 from Price Point) and after several adjustments (as expected) it works great. This fork is a little on the heavy side. Time will tell if it holds up. The LX cranks are supriseingly strong; however, the chain rings wear out fast.
Similar Products Used:
Klein, GT
Bike Setup:
2000 Manitou Xvert, SRAM pc-99 chain (after trying several this is the best), otherwise stock.
Bottom Line:
This bike would be a good cross country racer, but not for the highly competitive. With Hayes disk brakes, long travel fork and other hefty components, it's about 2 lbs. too heavy. Go buy another bike for that, but keep this one for all around fun. You will beat the average rider up anything and pass up most FS bikes on the downhill. The FS riders will never keep up with you on the switch backs.
I have about 3000 mile of nasty mountain riding on the bike. The brake pads will last a about 1500 miles. When changing the pads, I change the break fluid also. It was suprisingly contanimated. There was no noticable change in performace, and that's good.
I run higher than average tire pressure (50-55 lbs.) so the wheels remain straight. The bearings in the Bontrager hub are weak. That's it for complaints.
This bike is a great ride and has taken me on many great epics. It has a certain flow to it, it's stable and comfortable at high speeds (38-42 mph) and can also handle tight technical sections like a trials bike. I've been mountain biking for 12 years and have had more fun on this bike than any other.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
The Burner
a Racer
from Glendale, CA Date Reviewed: March 10, 2001
Favorite Trail:
El Prieto, La Canada
Duration Product Used:
2 Years
Price Paid:
$2000.00
Purchased At:
SuperGo, Santa Monica
Strengths:
This Xcal is the ultimate uphill machine with a stable & f'n fast downhill! The stock Hayes disk brakes, Bontragger rims are perfect together, the X-vert fork it came with I switched to the new Bombers and have the perfect hardtail racer. It wieghs a meer 25.5lbs and the Easton tubing gives me a great stiff push into turns. I would recomend this sled to anyone who can push her fast and hard, because she is a bullett...
Weaknesses:
Look somewhere else, this one has no weekness but the rider on its back! late....
Bike Setup:
Hayes disk, Bontragger rims, Xtr/Xt, X-vert shock
Bottom Line:
Get one!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
david k
a Racer
from Cleveland Ohio Date Reviewed: February 8, 2001
Favorite Trail:
Downtown Cleveland
Duration Product Used:
2 Years
Price Paid:
$1300.00
Purchased At:
Spoke-n-wheel Chagrin Falls
Strengths:
Great geometry. Luv the long travel up front. Flashy looks.
Weaknesses:
X-vert E fork bites!!! I'm a jumper, luv dat big air, but I'm light (160#). Rebound damper busted in a month. Waranty to the rescue. Rebound damper busted 4 months later and the top of left tube blew out (probably due to poor reassembly after service). I was covered w/oil.
Bike Setup:
Stock.
Bottom Line:
I have never felt so agile on a bike. Something about the geometry just fits my bod and style, let'n me ride this thing like a maniac!!! I can't say enuf about it. The components are fine (LX) and I'm sick of whiners thinking they can tell the difference between a couple of ounces. Lose some weight from your ass! Stock tires suck. Shock sucks but it is part of the geometry. I'm looking for a new shock. My first discs too and I'm having probs. Front has little power and spoke-n-wheel doesn't know how to fix it. Downhills are tuff w/a weak & squeeling front disc.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Hayden Strickland
a Weekend Warrior
from Fort Collins CO Date Reviewed: November 19, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Porcupine Rim
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Price Paid:
$1600.00
Purchased At:
Rock And Road Cyclery
Strengths:
Geometry, Suspension (z1 Flylight)
Weaknesses:
Bontrager Componets seat post
Similar Products Used:
Trek 930
Bike Setup:
Speed Disk Rear wheel, rock shocks seat post, lx crank
Bottom Line:
I have reviewed this bike once before, and here is what I think of it six months later. Bontrager is not a good company. First of all, the wheel set is a 28 hole set for lighter wheels, however if you ever brake this wheel your only choice is to completely rebuild a new wheel ($$$) or by the race disk wheel set again ($$$). I have broken both the front and rear wheel on this bike. I stripped out the rear freehub riding it only three months after purchase. And now just a week ago I tacoed the front wheel. Keith Bontrager needs to quit trying to change standards and instead stick with them. The example, a 28 hole rim, and a free hub that requires a 12 mm allen, and a lot of filling to the bearing race to even fit the allen into the free hub. If you have money, buy the bike, that way when you break it you can afford to buy specific parts. But if not, go with something else.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Nils Broström
a Weekend Warrior
from Gothenburg, Sweden Date Reviewed: August 8, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Chamonix, France
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Strengths:
Brakes, geometry and overall handeling
Weaknesses:
LX in front
Similar Products Used:
Scott comp, team racing
Bike Setup:
Straight from the factory!
Bottom Line:
Love this bike! It´s really great when its going straight up, quick in steering and the brakes... Fits me perfect, i´m 188 cm and i ride a "large" model. I´m not that heavy so the fork fits me perfect. Perfect for the advanced weekend rider with some ambition!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Phierce
a Racer
from Mission Viejo, CA Date Reviewed: August 3, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Holy Jim!! Trabuco!!! The Luge!!!
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Bottom Line:
Oh yeah, listen to the dood below this review, I am a massive 115 lb rider and destroyed this fork in a rock garden. Rock I hit musta been at least 3 inches high maybe 3.5 ....Itz getting repaired now, suckz cuz now Im on the road bike for 2 weex. Avoid this situation and throw a better fork on. I gotta hand it to the fork though, 11 months of pretty hard use, I mean what should I expect. I dont hate manitou, they are good; zokes are better
.....god I hope this doesnt happen again anytime soon
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
goose
a Downhiller
from Moab, Utah Date Reviewed: July 20, 2000
Favorite Trail:
porcupine rim
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Strengths:
Brakes are incredible, much better than the cable actuated brakes that were spec'd in the catalog, frame geometry is awsome, seat is comfy for long rides, and the wheelset is bombproof.
Weaknesses:
Manitou X-Vert E is very easy to break, the LX cranks are not as stiff as the Bontragers that were originally spec'd on the bike.
Similar Products Used:
Fisher Hoo Koo E Koo, Big Sur. Diamond Back X-2, and Zetec Comp, A few GT's, Santa Cruz Heckler.
Bike Setup:
Hayes, Marzocchi Z-1 QR-20 (5" of travel, wahoooo!!!) Race face cranks, Chris King.
Bottom Line:
I dumped the fork off this bike before I even began building it because I was familier with manitou from previous experiences. A friend that rides the same bike affirmed my worst fears about the X-Vert when this massivly huge 135 pound rider took the bike off a whopping 10 inch drop (huge I tell ya!) and cracked the left side lower. Didn't bang the fork on anything, it just decided to break. For those complaining about the bontrager cranks originally spec'd, I should remind you that the brakes originally spec'd were the cable actuated Hayes, however I heard that Hayes didn't meet the demand. Consider it a good thing cause the full hydros are ten times smoother. Loosing the good cranks but getting better breaks is worth the trade off. New cranks are far cheaper than new brakes. Other than above stuff, I love the bike ! Frame is bombproof, as well as most of the components.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Phierce
a Racer
from Mission Viejo, CA Date Reviewed: June 15, 2000
Favorite Trail:
HOLY JIM!!! TRABUCO!!!! ThE LUGE!!!!
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Strengths:
Strengths..hrmmm...well for 1 its the best trail riding hardtail in the world. Not really somethin to race (sure you could), but it goes up and down in serious style
Weaknesses:
-I've loosened those bolts once..no biggie..just tightened 'em down good and they havent done it again. -The weight is a little high..but I dont really notice it, and it hauls a$$ downhill -The FREAK 9 spd DRIVETRAIN!! I hate that thing!..worx tho, but the chain has a free spirit
Similar Products Used:
Cannondale m300, m400, m700 among a few others
Bike Setup:
stock baby! thats all you need!..hey! stop whining about the LX, I ride hard and the stuff worx fine..ur problems are comin from the thin chain\9spds Oh Yeah..I put on some ODI clamp-on grips (theyre cool)
Bottom Line:
Yeap this one is a classic. Its darn near impossible to endo, becuz of the giant fork travel and giant front triangle. This climbs and descends very well, certainly not the best in either category, but thats why it makes for a good training\trail riding bike. the HAYES ABSOLUTELY HAUL A$$! this bike is a full on monster, so have urself phun and make sure ur wearin a helmet..4 chilis for being a good all around bike but not the best at anything (except maybe fun)
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Haydon Strick
a Cross Country Rider
from Fort Collins CO USA Date Reviewed: June 5, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Porcupine Rim
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Strengths:
This bike has a nice frame, and some good componets. Nice Front Shocks
Weaknesses:
Where to start... Chain rings are really weak Seat post sucks, $$$$$$ Peadals Rear hub
Similar Products Used:
Trek
Bike Setup:
LX Mega Nine Crank, Speed Disc Rear Wheel, Rock Shox Seat Post
Bottom Line:
I ride hard, and have broken just about everything on a bike in the past 4 years. I bought this bike in hopes of getting a quality bike that I would not have to mess with to much. I bent the seat post after the second ride. No crashes, no hard hits, I just noticed it was bent. Later on, the derailrue striped out and got stuck in the rear wheel. I bent the dropout and Fisher would not even send me a new one. (You would think that if you spent $1,700 on a bike they would send you a $20 part). Just recently I striped the rear hub, or the free hub. I wanted to replace just the Free hub but in order to get the free hub loose you have to file down the bearing cup (that is the only way to fit the 12mm allen key in there. Even called fisher and they said that was the only way). So that is in the shop again. Bottom line, if you have the money, and don't mind replacing parts buy the 2000 X cal. I don't have either. Get's three because of Hayes and Marizocchi componets.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Len
a Weekend Warrior
from QC, Iowa Date Reviewed: June 1, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Any
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Strengths:
Still those Hayes discs; geometry; all-around components
Weaknesses:
Gotta loc-tite those disc lugs--so what big deal
Bike Setup:
Stock w/Selle Italia trimatic gel
Bottom Line:
I had to add to below--I love this bike still!! I've been hitting small local trails 3-4 times a week treating my X like a sacrificial lamb and it takes all I give it with a smile. Did add the seat above; am considering upgrading from LX to XTR front derailluer more for bragging rights & coolness factor over necessity. Thinking about entering my first race with X since I love it so much! Read more below! Gets 5x5 chilis
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Kevin
a Weekend Warrior
from Huntington, NY Date Reviewed: May 17, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Rocky Point Envi Conservatory
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Hayes Disc Brakes, great componentry for the price
Weaknesses:
Disc bolts tend to come loose during hard riding, a seat made for fatasses
Similar Products Used:
GF Ziggurat Specialized Stumpjumper Pro Raleigh M80 GF Paragon
Bike Setup:
Stock, w/Italia Flite Gel saddle, Bontrager RE-I clipless, Bontrager Race Lite barends, Yeti Hardcore grips w/Lockjaws
Bottom Line:
Wow, what a bike. After shopping this spring for a '99 leftover, I had my heart set on GF Paragon. I'm glad I shelled out the extra coin for the X-Caliber. I was fortunate enough to find it a local shop for $1,100, and it was the best money I have ever spent. It rides smooth, and climbs even better. The Hayes discs are terrific, although the bolts on the discs came loose on the rear hub twice. I used a little Lock-Tite and the problem was solved. The only other complaint I had was the saddle; it's made for oversized-riders. Chances are, if you're an average sized rider, this seat isn't going to work too well. For the money I spent, and the components that I got, no other bikes even came close. If you're looking for a great hardtail and can find one for around $1100-1200, you can't go wrong with this bike. Five smokin' piles of horsepoop!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Christian
a Cross Country Rider
from Montreal Date Reviewed: May 3, 2000
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Hayes disk Brakes and the Manitou 4po fork
Weaknesses:
Shimano LX shifter. It'd prefered XT Shifter
Bottom Line:
The bike géometrie is very good for xcountry biking. The bike is pretty light and respond very well. I dont know why I've waited so long to have hydrolic disk brake, it's incredibly efficent in every weather condition and you'll never have to mind about further brake pad adjusting. A good bike.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Kent
a Weekend Warrior
from Minneapolis Date Reviewed: May 1, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Chaska Farm
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
I decided to add some stuff to my post below after riding the bike and beating it up a bit more.
Still.....Fun, Fun, Fun til Daddy takes the T-bird away....
Weaknesses:
Just like below...you MUST lock-tight those discs to the hub. Darn things come loose ALL the time!!!! BIG PROBLEM with the bike.
Also, it definately does not climb like a billy goat. It's a friggen long travel bike and the increase in front height takes away from the up-hills.
Tires are rather wimpy and don't provide as much grip as I would like.
Similar Products Used:
blah, blah..read below
Bike Setup:
Stock STILL
Bottom Line:
The bike is still fun minus the above problems.
Still give 'er 5 stars.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Geoff King
a Racer
from Scott Depot, WV, USA Date Reviewed: May 1, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Ballin' the jack at snowshoe
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Strengths:
I've had my x-caliber for a littel over a year now. Man that thing accellerates fast i race a lot and the disc brakes are so awesome and the shocks are like butter.
Weaknesses:
I've had a lot of problems with my bike. Tighten the screws that hold the disc to the hub! My 7th chain ring fell off! The seat could go i got a specialized body geo. seat
Similar Products Used:
gary fisher big sur. hoo koo e koo
Bike Setup:
nanoraptor tires, different crank arm, new shifters
Bottom Line:
The bike is phat! I recommend it to anyone at first i got it for just weekend riding but i'm racing with it now and let me tell you. I get a lot of comments on it. I'm doing the 24hrs of snowshoe in june after that I'm going to upgrade to a sugar1. The x-caliber is by far the best bike i have ever rode. I'm going to take the disc brakes off my x-cal and put them on my sugar. The bike is sweet i paid 1,700.00 for it! I was a little worried that i was wasting my money, but it IS WORTH EVERY PENNY!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Len
a Weekend Warrior
from QC - Iowa Date Reviewed: April 24, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Do I hafta choose...
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Great geometry that Genesis design the Fisher boys came up with. Great components. Most excellent brakes!!!
Weaknesses:
Maayyybe the saddle?--only personal preference presides here.
Bike Setup:
stock
Bottom Line:
The X-Cal is an EXCELLENT bike for the money. I got the 99 for under $1100 here in the flatlands. Yes we have our little abuse arena's to play with bikes. The brakes are GREAT in all conditions--put locktite on the disc bolts tho (or have your dealer do it before buying). It's not XTR components but they work perfectly for 99% of you out there. If I was racing and making money off the sport I'd spend more than $1K for a bike--but I'm a weekender that loves to play--the value can't be beat!! Five ju-lep-uh-knowz all around!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
robbie
a Weekend Warrior
from cork ireland Date Reviewed: April 13, 2000
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Strengths:
beautifull spec
Weaknesses:
my frame snapped at the bottom bracketaround the seat tube watch for cracks inside the chainring side of the seattube new frame on the way!
Bike Setup:
full xt groupset avid flackjackets
Bottom Line:
what a bike, forks work better with different weight oil disks superb! what can i say i broke one.rear disc bolts came loose once as well,see it on our site mtbcork.8k.com
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Kent
a Weekend Warrior
from Minneapolis, MN Date Reviewed: April 8, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Chaska Farm, MN River, Murphy, Lebannon
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Strengths:
Size, Size, size...fits me like a dream! Frame/Fork, Wheels, and HAYES BRAKES!
Weaknesses:
Crank set, LX Shifters, rather obnoxious color (oh well)
Similar Products Used:
Trek 8500 LT, GT Zaskar LE, Specialized M2 comp
Bike Setup:
Stock (for now).....will upgrade shifters, seat post, cranks, and front deraileur as stuff breaks....
Bottom Line:
After demolishing my FSR Comp last year losing confidence in XC FS bikes, I wanted a beefy-quick hard tail. The Xcal meets the bill. This bike fits me like a dream! Normly, I would ride a 19", but was able to jump down to a Medium Xcal with the Genesis frame. Wow...did I say this thing riders nice! Very fun, loves to jump, bunny hop, wheelie. All around FUN bike. Very nimble in the corners, climbs like a goat, and stops on a dime. The tires are a bit irritating cuz I don't feel they are gripping like my old Ground Controls. This bike certainly isn't a light XC racer, but it's darn fun for the 4 day a week rider that's looking for a "Down Hill HardTail". (If that's a category) After testing this bike and deciding it was "the one", it was tough to find a deal, so I settled for around $1350 at a local shop....I would have paid full 1999 retail knowing what I know now. The only change I will make is upgrading the shifters and throwing on a Rock Shox seat post. I would like to swap out the LX cranks and LX derailuers, but I deal with them til they break. This bike doesn't come with the spec'd Bontrager black cranks!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Erich Hawk
a Weekend Warrior
from Vancouver, B.C., Canada Date Reviewed: March 22, 2000
Favorite Trail:
anything North Shore
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Strengths:
Brakes, brakes, brakes! The Genesis geometry. Manitou fork.
Stock except for a rock shox seat post and specialized, leather, ti-railed seat.
Bottom Line:
This bike is the best I've ever ridden. I was skeptical about the genesis geometry as being just a gimick until I tried it. This bike is heavier than ones I've ridden, with a larger travel front fork, yet still climbs the best, is the most nimble and quick through tight trails, and still can take all of the drops that I can throw at it. The Manitou fork though not as adjustable as some, is the smoothest I've tried in the 100mm's available. I managed to pull this bike off for just under 2000.00 CAN and there was nothing anywhere near this bike with Hayes hydraulics in the price range. I can't imagine brakes getting any better!! This bike is for the rider who wants a machine that can tackle anything. The parts that are important, ie: frame, fork and brakes are rippin'. For those who think that a Shimano LX/XT set up is not substantial enough for weekend warriors, I'm sure after market dealers will be glad to trade up for you and take your money!! I've had this set up for years and although it may not be the lightest and most technologically advanced, if your not a world class racer, it will never let you down. All of the other parts can be upgraded or not depending on rider preference. For me, aside from installing the Rock Shox seat post(which rules by the way), I'm keepin' this machine as is. It performs, performs, performs. A full 5 flamers!!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
pascal disewiscourt
a Cross Country Rider
from luxembourg, europe Date Reviewed: March 19, 2000
Favorite Trail:
fast fuzzy
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
frame:light,rigide,agressive look fork: satisfying, doesn't swing too much at uphills hayes brakes:neverending brake power but still squeezing after 500 km.
Weaknesses:
tires:the wtb enduroraptors suck in mud because they are shifting away but they have normal traction on dry ground.the richey megabyte i used before was better.
Bike Setup:
factory setup
Bottom Line:
great bike which invites u to ride over your limits. good handling in dangerous or unknown trial situations.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
yo gigilo
a Racer
from cali Date Reviewed: March 7, 2000
Favorite Trail:
death row DH
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Sweet breaks,Sweetest wheels, light frame, great for crosscountry and downhill, Sick bars, and some sick pedals, this bike is freakin fast.
Weaknesses:
Crappy cranks, Sucky front derailer, and could use a bit more travel
Similar Products Used:
Speacilized M2
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
Phat bike for the money if you want speed action and excitment!!!!!!!!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Steve
a Weekend Warrior
from Zionsville, Indiana Date Reviewed: January 8, 2000
Favorite Trail:
Hickory Ridge
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
This bike handles like none I've ever owned. It can climb, descend and is quick off of the line. And the disc brakes are truly outstanding
Weaknesses:
Add a suspension seatpost to smooth out the ride even more.
Similar Products Used:
Trek 8000 Cannondale F700
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
This is a fabulous bike, great frame, nice parts group and great ride especially if you can get it on a close out for @ $1100.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
James
a Weekend Warrior
from Jersey. Channel Islands Date Reviewed: December 17, 1999
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Frame, brakes amd gears
Weaknesses:
none
Similar Products Used:
Scot FX-3, Trek 8000
Bike Setup:
Set up is out of the box with the addition of a suspension seat post
Bottom Line:
An excellent bike for dirt and tarmac use. Fast light and a great climber. Brakes are great giving confidence in wet and muddy conditions.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Greg
a Weekend Warrior
from Ottawa, Ontario, Canada Date Reviewed: October 25, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Anything Tremblant & Camp Fortune Canada Cup XC + Downhill
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Frame, Frame and Frame. Hayes brakes are incredible, nothing stops better. Rims are tough and very rigid. Titec DH seat is comfortable.
Weaknesses:
Fork could be better, with a little more travel (Marzocchi Z1 Drop Off, for examble). WTB Enduroraptors suck in muddy conditions.
Stock : Hayes hydraulic disc brakes, Manitou XVert-E Fork, Medium.
Bottom Line:
This bike is capable of doing anything. (well, downhill only to a certain extent) It's not too heavy, which means it climbs fairly well. The Genesis geometry makes the cockpit feel like that of a 19 frame, without putting the center of gravity too high. It's an awesome bike.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
chris
a Weekend Warrior
from ny Date Reviewed: October 12, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Adirondacks
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Geneis Geometry Disk brakes stop on a dime huge and smooth shock smoothe rear derailer
Weaknesses:
hard seat
Similar Products Used:
paragon
Bike Setup:
stock
Bottom Line:
This bike is the best bike for its price
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Gus
a Weekend Warrior
from Lake Forest, CA Date Reviewed: September 7, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Peak Trail (Breckenridge, CO)
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
The Hayes Disc brake system. Overall comfortable feel of the bike. Shifters/derailers (smooth as silk)
Weaknesses:
None so far, but the other reviews citing loose parts of the brake system have me looking for lock tite
Similar Products Used:
Stumpjumper FSR/xc Cannondale Raven & Super V GT XCR 2000 & 3000 w/I drive
Bike Setup:
Factory
Bottom Line:
i have been on a grueling search for that perfect bike for months now. I'm a novice rider (though i have been @ it for 12 years) who doesn't know about all the tech talk. i just know what i like & this bike feels right! i will be honest & say that i walked into the store planning to buy the Stumpjumper FSR/XC for the exact same price & a more experienced friend (Pat) & the bike mechanic on duty persuaded me to consider this hardtail over the full suspension. They explained that the upkeep on a full suspension would be more intense & the braking system was not even in the same ballpark. They also seemed to think American built vs. Tiwan built frame was a must. It also didn't hurt that i found it on sale @ SuperGo for $1,099!! If you're like me & can't follow all the hype about the different components & people's different preferences, find something in your price range, make sure its a company you feel comfortable with. Make sure you feel comfortable on the bike- then, just ride & enjoy! Don't look back. Leave the regrets to the pedestrians.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jim
a Weekend Warrior
from Gary Fusher,Alabama Date Reviewed: August 14, 1999
Favorite Trail:
foo man
Duration Product Used:
tested or demo'ed only
Strengths:
none
Weaknesses:
everything
Similar Products Used:
none
Bike Setup:
stock
Bottom Line:
this is a e/n bike
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Nate
a Racer
from Gardner, MA Date Reviewed: August 11, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Vietnam/Lynn Woods
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Light frame with sweet geometry, Hayes Brakes, nice riser bar, decent wheelset
Weaknesses:
The X-vert fork broke after a couple months of use, the LX cranks bent, 9 speed shimano chains suck, paint chips off, huge saddle, tire sidewalls ripped shortly after purchasing
This bike, despite the flaws I explained above, is an incredible deal. I put bikes through hell, even though I am a light rider at 155lbs/5'10. 3- 6' drop offs are not uncommon for rides I do around here. The brake, frame, and wheels alone are worth the money! The ride is so sweet! The fork upgrade made the front end super-light, but still plush and plenty of travel on the downs. The gussets make this frame super strong, but it is still one of the lightest frames available at 3.2lbs. I have raced it successfully this season, and it has been a lot of fun.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jim
a Weekend Warrior
from Oregon Date Reviewed: July 25, 1999
Duration Product Used:
tested or demo'ed only
Strengths:
great front suspension. Love that long travel. The Hayes disks breaks are sweet, but the bike I demo'd had the bolts come loose on the rear disk. This bike can be found now for 1400.00 in Portland.
Weaknesses:
LX cranks-not the speck'd bontragers. The bike I rode already had a nice big paint chip on it.
Similar Products Used:
Treck 8900
Bottom Line:
Very nice ride, but I may wait for the 2000 model since they should be out soon. Maybe the bike will be equipted with the components that it is spec'd with.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Steve B
a Cross-Country Rider
from Maryland Date Reviewed: July 19, 1999
Favorite Trail:
SML
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Hayes disk brakes Good drive train 100mm ssmmootthhee
Weaknesses:
Screws that hold rotor to hub came loose
Similar Products Used:
Trek 8500lt
Bike Setup:
stock (may add USE sus. post)
Bottom Line:
Very happy with this bike. It is new to me after comming off of a Cannondale F2000. Man, this bike flows. I've only hit 3 good solid rides since my purchase - Man! I'm already as one with this bike. It's sort of wierd - the bike is like a body part or something. The rear end is solid but not abusive, and the shock eats roots and rocks well. I initially thought the x-vert to be a weakness (being a rock shock & Zoke fan) but after some rides, other then a top out here and there, the shock perfoms well. SSWWEEEETT!!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Dan
a Weekend Warrior
from Santa Fe NM Date Reviewed: July 17, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Glorieta Baldy
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Long travel (100 mm) fork on a hardtail is a great way to go. The Hayes discs are awesome! The Genesis geometry fits me really well too. Huge fun factor on this bike.
Weaknesses:
The Manitou X-Vert E has no adjustments other than preload. After going to a heavier weight oil, I'm happier. I also had some trouble with the Hayes setup, but that turned out to be fork related (the mounting surface on the Manitou was not 90 deg to the disc). I've had a little trouble with the Bontrager hub too. I sheared the freehub.
Similar Products Used:
none
Bike Setup:
The only thing I changed was the pedals. I don't like the DH Shimanos it comes with, so I put my Time ATACs on. I also put a Control Tech suspension seatpost in place of the Bontrager.
Bottom Line:
I love this whole setup! Despite the minor problems I've had, I would buy this bike again in a heartbeat. I am going to go to a different fork, though. It drives me nuts not to have any adjustability. I will stick with at least 100mm of travel though. You can scream down anything and the Hayes brakes will stop you right now!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Mace
a Weekend Warrior
from SLC Utah Date Reviewed: July 16, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Wasatch Crest
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Hayes Discs Bontrager Wheels
Weaknesses:
None found yet
Similar Products Used:
Schwinn Moab Disc
Bike Setup:
Stock X except for Rock Shock Seat Post and Body Geometry Saddle
Bottom Line:
I'm a child of the 60's but this bike beats any trip I've been on! Fun is what I ride for and the X provides it in bunches. My local bike shop had to order one in from the warehouse for me to test ride and when I got there the mechanics were gathered around it like hungry dogs. I bought it right now. When I first saw the X reviewed in MB I bought into their line about it being too gaudy for the average person. But when you see this bike up close it reaches out and grabs you. The component package is outstanding for the bucks. I feel that a suspension post is a must to make this a complete package. We rode the Crest Trail last weekend, which is just a fantastic ride. The Hayes Dics are incredible, with none of the squealing I've read about. I did find some loose rotor bolts when I got home, but evidently Fisher got the message from MB about the Torx head bolts as my bike came with metric allens. These brakes take some getting used too because they require only a fraction of the finger pressure of my old rim units. They will put you over the bar if you get too frisky. I called Fisher about the change in Spec from the Bontrager Cranks to the Shimano's and they said that they pulled the Bontragers due to Quality problems with the chain rings. Makes no difference to a guy like me. This bike rides like a dream and turns heads out on the trail. Look no further if this is the class of bike you are considering. Break out the chilies boys and girls!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Dave
a Weekend Warrior
from UK Date Reviewed: July 6, 1999
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Genesis geometry Hayes disc brakes Overall mix of components and styling is fantastic
Weaknesses:
None, unless you consider the LX front derailleur and shifters to be weaknesses
Similar Products Used:
Klein Attitude Comp Orange Evo2
Bike Setup:
Stock with LX cranks, Manitou Xvert E fork and Hayes hydraulic brakes
Bottom Line:
In my search for the perfect bike, I checked out offerings from Klein, Orange, Kona, Specialized, Scott, Marin, Trek and Gary Fisher. My decision came down to a choice between the Klein Attitude Comp and the X-Caliber, although the X-Caliber is some £250 more than the Klein. It was a toughie. On both bikes, the ride is superb, but the Klein has some cheapo components and my Gary Fisher dealer was the best. OK, I accept that Klein aluminium and finish is top drawer, but if you're looking for a genuine fun hog bike that looks the business, then look no further. This bike is the mutts nuts. Buy one now before they sell out!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Bill Welch
a Racer
from Tennessee Date Reviewed: June 28, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Anything Fast
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Bontrager Hoops kick, Hayes Discs don't get any better, X-Vert is perfect travel
Since my last review, I've bought the bike. The bike impressed me so much when I test rode it, that I bought it! They Hayes haven't given a minute of trouble and don't squeak at all! When looking to buy this bike, I saw that it was spec'd with a Bontrager Race Crank, I asked the salesman about that, he said that Bontrager just didn't make enough and that they were making some now. He said that the minute they got them in, I would get one completely FREE!!! Fisher stands behind their products and I really like that! This bike is the best freeride hardtail on the market right now, and I am happy that I bought it!!!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Bill Welch
a Racer
from Tennessee Date Reviewed: June 26, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Anything fast
Duration Product Used:
tested or demo'ed only
Strengths:
The Bontrager Disc Rims, Hayes Brakes Rule!!!
Weaknesses:
Late 99 model got fitted with LX crank
Similar Products Used:
Trek 8900, Cannondale F900
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
This bike kicks, it's fast on uphills and faster on downhills, this is by far the sweetest hardtail freeride bike that I've ridden. BUY IT!!!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Joe
a Racer
from Muskoka Date Reviewed: June 15, 1999
Favorite Trail:
The scariest ones
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Awesome bike rides awesome. Brakes rule. Downhill!!!!
Weaknesses:
none only all the people who stare at it
Similar Products Used:
none its the best enough said
Bike Setup:
what it comes with
Bottom Line:
the best
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Erin
a Weekend Warrior
from Madison, WI Date Reviewed: June 4, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Cache Creek, WY
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Very smooth, really tight and aggressive. Hayes brakes have saved me from two trees, because this bike makes me want to go faster on the downhills. Makes climbing a breeze. The geometry suits a woman better than others tried.
Similar Products Used:
Trek 8500 Trek ST-120
Bike Setup:
I added a rock shox seatpost and it definitely helps. I loved my full suspension (trek) before, but the climbs really sucked. This bike makes me look for uphills!
Bottom Line:
Best bike I've ever owned, hope it lasts me a long time.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
anthony morgan
a Weekend Warrior
from lexington, ky Date Reviewed: May 14, 1999
Favorite Trail:
the trail I am on
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
great frame and components
Weaknesses:
none so far
Bike Setup:
race face crank, stiff spring for fork
Bottom Line:
I love it! The more I ride it the more I like it. I am a large rider 200+ so I stiffened the shock and it has yet to bottom out. Climbs great and the brakes are as good as advertised. I let a friend try it out it and he felt he spent too much on a full suspension. the genesis geometry is the way to go. By the if you go with the race face cranks get them red anonized they dress up the bike.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jonathan
a Weekend Warrior
from Montreal, Quebec Date Reviewed: May 14, 1999
Favorite Trail:
Bromont
Duration Product Used:
tested or demo'ed only
Strengths:
Great Pakage
Weaknesses:
Low price
Similar Products Used:
none
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
Hey Jon Blaze, I think you don't know what you talking about. Not enough for your money, them what is. At a price like that, what do you want more... I see you shop for names. Buy a set of hayes, It'll cost 1/3 the price of this bike. The front derailleur, it's an LX, maybe the XT ant XTR is lighter, but can't even see the difference. The geometry, brilliant, it climbs anything, and is very stable in downhill. And why recommend TREK, it's the same thing, made by the same people, same tubing, the only difference, paint and geometry. 2 Hayes disc brakes, bontrager disc wheels, manitou 4 fork, titec berserkr DH sadle, great geometry... For $2200 CAN, now that a deal. And last year I bought a Ziggurat for $2000 CAN.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jeff
a Weekend Warrior
from San Francisco, CA Date Reviewed: May 7, 1999
Favorite Trail:
All singletrack
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Hayes discs are awesome. Feels solid on fast downhills; especially with the 4 of travel on the Manitou. Climbs great. LX/XT setup is very smooth. Thumbs up on the Shimano 545's.
Weaknesses:
To this point I see none. I'll update this review in a few months; if such an update is warranted.
Similar Products Used:
demo'd a Trek 8900 & 8500 SL.
Bottom Line:
I'm very happy with the product to date. I'll check back in a few months with an update. I realize it's still early as far as time of ownership; however, the performance of frame & components has been great. Sweet ride!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jon Blaze
a Racer
from California Date Reviewed: April 19, 1999
Favorite Trail:
There all good
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Strengths:
Lets start off with...NEVER BUY A GARY FISHER. they don't last...and they always come with a cheapo front derailuer...but my xcaliber did have a nice frame design.
Weaknesses:
heavy for price bad front derailuer shock locks up to much ugly paint job not enough for the $$$$$
Similar Products Used:
99'Giant MCM SE 98' Specialized M2
Bike Setup:
all stock
Bottom Line:
DONT BUY A GARY FISHER....SPEND YOUR TIME ON A COMPANY THAT GIVES YOU BETTER QUALITY FOR YOUR MONEY. TRY GIANT, TREK, CANNONDALE OR EVEN HUFFY OVER THIS PIECE.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Nate
a Cross-Country Rider
from Gardner, MA Date Reviewed: April 9, 1999
Favorite Trail:
vietnam
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
Really handles rough handling well, can take big hit. The brakes are by far the best!
Weaknesses:
The fork and cranks. I, like Rob, am getting raceface cranks with the new ramped chainrings, and probably upgrading the fork to a 'zocci, the manitou keeps locking up.
Similar Products Used:
Fisher Joshua (had for 2 years)
Bottom Line:
A great all around bike, great for hard x-c, tough technical singletrack, trials, dual slalom, and some downhill... I'll stick to my full suspension for downhill though! This bike rocks!!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Steve Dominic
a Weekend Warrior
from Georgetown Date Reviewed: March 31, 1999
Favorite Trail:
peak-to-peak, Breckenridge
Duration Product Used:
tested or demo'ed only
Strengths:
The best of race-proven technology, without the extra weight and performance penalty of a full-suspension bike. For me, the Genesis Geometry is a good fit because the longer wheel base adds stability and the short rear triangle facilitates traction.
Weaknesses:
The cost is getting up there for a hard-tail, but those Hayes brakes are currently the industries best design.
Similar Products Used:
Trek 8000, Trek 8500, Trek 8900, GT 2000, GT 3000, Specialized Stumpjumper, Klein Mantra, Klein Mantra Pro, Klein Attitude Race, K2,
Bike Setup:
Thanks to Rob Wilson for posting his upgrades! I decided to go with the B1 Bomber fork. Same travel (130 mm) but even more adjustable. I am also considering a crank upgrade as per his suggestion.
Bottom Line:
The ultimate fun-hog bicycle for the technology enthusiast that needs to go both uphill and downhill and is not interested in buying unproven full-suspension technology.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Greg
a Cross-Country Rider
from UK Date Reviewed: March 29, 1999
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Strengths:
The bike is great, I have rode it for 2 weeks and this is been the best bike I have ever rode, a lot better than £2000 ones, it is great and the brakes are extreamly powerful.
Weaknesses:
The Hayes Disc came lose on a downhill, this scared me a bit, I tightened them and after I sprayed loctite so the nut would not come lose again.
Similar Products Used:
Specialized Stumpjumper M2 Comp is good but the X-Caliber kicks its butt.
Bike Setup:
Standard Setup. Apart from the Bontrager crank was swaped for a LX one, because Bontrager at the moment will not use 9 speed shifting???
Bottom Line:
It is the best!!!!!!!!!!! 10 stars if possible
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Rob Wilson
a cross-country rider
from Keene, NH Date Reviewed: December 8, 1998
Bottom Line:
This bike kicks! It has sweet handeling when going through some really technical stuff. It handels like a dream when flying down your favorite piece of insane single track too! In fact I'm buying one this winter. The only thing is I'm upgrading to a Marzocchi Bomber Z.1 Drop Off fork with 130 mm (5) of travel, and Race Face Cranks. This bike is definitely worth getting.
Overall Rating:
What's New
»
BEST OF MTBR - Check out the highest rated bikes, parts, & gear!
»
LED BIKE LIGHT SHOOTOUT 3 - We test all the newest products and latest light and battery technology in this comprehensive guide»
$ 1599.99
Overall Rating:
Overall Rating:
Overall Rating:
