Submitted by
elvishawk
a Weekend Warrior
from leeds UK Date Reviewed: July 22, 2009
Favorite Trail:
Yorks Dales
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$2000.00
Purchased At:
chevin cycles otley
Strengths:
light bike, very responsive, excellent geometry, confidence inspiring, rides like a hardtail - fast..........
Weaknesses:
slightly light front end when climbing very steep/technical, still getting used to sram gearset
Similar Products Used:
trek 6500 1999
Bike Setup:
standard, end bars and cateye cordless to fit.
Bottom Line:
needed to upgrade from my 10yr old trek 6500 hardtail to a full sus as was losing out to my mates on technical fast downhills. needed discs, light weight and a firmish ride so i wouldnt lose speed on the hills etc but with enuf sus to cover me on the hard stuff.
demod 29er hardtail, hated it - too much weight on the hills and not enuf controlability in technical climbs and terrain.
took out a marin with quad link sus - too twitchy and massive pedal bob when climbing - very fast tho.
then took out this lttle fella and i can honestly say she rocks !!
geometry felt right immediately and i can climb anything, go faster and is comfortable to ride all day.
the juicy 5's are great and adequate for me, am still getting used to sram gearset but i went out 2 days back in heavy mud and it NEVER slipped even once.
very light frame and plenty of firmness from the sus to maintain rigidity on the road and good surfaces so i dont lose momentum/energy when climbing. sus is single pivot and it shows - i love it. unlike the majority of quad link bikes which concentrate on using the sus to do all the work and relies on propedal to neutralise pedal bob, the GF hifi deluxe uses the whole rear end as suspension and the shock just as a damber. the brilliant result is a bike thats as fast a hardtail most of the time, but which will absorb the really heavy downhills when necessary.
only downer is the front goes light in extreme climbs.
having said that, i went out for 2 hs the other day and i never unclipped my feet once !! thats a real result considering the terrain.
a brill all rounder and has made me 30% faster already. i nearly went for the ex8 but im so glad i didnt.
ps - went for the 17.5 inch. im 5feet 10inches tall and weight 10stone.
well done on a fantastic package gary, phillip.
pps - managed to get a price reduction to £1600 due to a scratch on the frame.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
big mountain riding
a Racer
from Lynchburg, VA, USA Date Reviewed: July 16, 2009
Favorite Trail:
Porcupine Rim - The whole thing
Duration Product Used:
2 Years
Price Paid:
$2000.00
Purchased At:
LBS - Bikes Unlimite
Strengths:
Can do it all, pretty much! Rails the descents, climbs with agility, great balance, feels lighter than it is.
Weaknesses:
Low Bottom Bracket - or at least feels that way at times. I have the 2007, and the next year they upgraded to a Fox fork and a stealth black paint job. Doh!
Similar Products Used:
Klein Palomino, Giant Trance
Bike Setup:
Stock, except Chris King headset, Thompson seat post, WTB Rocket seat, platform clipless pedals
Bottom Line:
For years, bike companies and magazines touted this bike or that as the "one" bike that could do it all. As someone on a budget, I loved the idea of a bike that could handle most of the standard trail conditions confidently, however I don't think they lived up to the hype until 2006-07. I test rode a Giant Trance, and it performed everything well. However, it wasn't exciting. A great bike needs the design and capabilities to excite.
Enter the Gary Fisher HiFi. While there are other bikes out there that probably excite more, and can handle even more (i.e. the Yeti 575), the HiFi does it all and costs less. I'd say I regret not waiting a year to buy the one with the black paint job with a Fox fork, but then I would have missed out on a great year of riding. And, I love the Manitou Minute fork. I actually have one on my Klein too. This Minute with the thicker stanchions is rock steady, as is the whole bike. In the first six months of owning it, I placed the best I ever had in an epic (100KM) race, took it to Moab for a week and rode local trail features I had never imagined being able to ride. I use the ProPedal feature on the Fox rear shock almost every ride. Yes, the bike will climb fully open, but the stiffer setting makes those long climbs just that much more bearable. And with practice, your hand will find the lever without looking down.
Problems have been few: At just under two years, the rear triangle broke. And not the carbon seat stays. I think the asymmetrical chain stays are under a lot of torque forces. Gary Fisher replaced the part for free inside of two weeks from start to finish. So, this is not the bike for regular jumpers ... Additionally, replace the stock tires with something with more grip if you ride in loose or wet conditions. I ride an old set of Panaracers 2.1" with a tried and true tread design.
Oh, and yes. As other reviewers have warned, this bike can goad you to go faster than you may be ready for. On Moab's Porcupine Rim Trail, my brother and I passed a motocross bike in the r-r-ruff on the downhill running from the rim overlook back to Sand Flats Road. A pinnacle moment for a mountain biker. The guy about fell off his motorbike when we flew past on his left :-0 That's the kind of bike this one is. Surprising competent and tougher than it looks. Great for true all mountain riders that need to pedal up to rail down.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Keefer
a Cross Country Rider
from Woodstock, GA USA Date Reviewed: June 26, 2009
Favorite Trail:
Blankets Creek
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Price Paid:
$1900.00
Purchased At:
Free Flite
Strengths:
Easy to ride.
Rolls over roots and rocks much easier than a 26".
Weaknesses:
Brakes are noisy after 20 miles of single track. I have to remove the pads and rub them against sand paper. It's good for another 20-25 miles. I've tried organic as well as metal. It's a Juicy thing and not a Fisher issue.
Highly recommend this bike as it's just an all around awesome bike. It can ride anything you throw at it. The 29" wheels make a huge difference in smoothness and ease of rolling.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
JNorcia
a Weekend Warrior
from Chattanooga, TN Date Reviewed: May 30, 2009
Favorite Trail:
Racoon MTN
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Price Paid:
$2300.00
Purchased At:
Owen Cyclery
Strengths:
Acceleration, climbing ability, agility and turning ability really give you confidence (after switching the tires)
Weaknesses:
Rear suspension firms during braking on decents. Tires just werent made for the rocky, wet southeast hills.
Similar Products Used:
Fuel ex, giant trance,
Bike Setup:
stock with upgraded crank to an shimano xt and specialized eskar tires. Also Fizik aliante xm saddle
Bottom Line:
Great bike for the price. Climbs great and after converting the tires to tubless, it only made it better, up and down the mountain. The only downfall is there is a significant firming of the rear suspension during braking. Other than that its a solid bike that keeps you in a comfortable position for hours of solid riding. Feels as quick as most 4 inch cross country bikes I've ridden with an extra inch of travel to help you throuhg the tougher lines down the trail. A perfect bike for someone who is looking for their first full suspension bike since the rear end stays pretty firm (with or without the propedal on) compared to many other rear suspension designs.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Twenty Times
a Cross Country Rider
from Holbrook, NY, USA Date Reviewed: April 28, 2009
Favorite Trail:
Glacier Ridge
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Purchased At:
Brands (Wantagh, NY)
Strengths:
Trek and Gary Fisher equipped this bike very well! The mix of Shimano and SRAM components allow for a nice mix. The FOX suspension is amazing.
Weaknesses:
White seats are horrible!!
Snapped a chain under 100 miles
Similar Products Used:
First full suspension bike.
Bike Setup:
Stock other then pedals
Bottom Line:
The bike is awesome. It handles moguls, small drops and tight single track incredible. The bike climbs nicely and bullets down hills. The frame style and color scheme on the 2009 is a "must see to appreciate" because the pictures do not do it justice.
The benefits of the Deluxe component wise makes the bike worth the extra few dollars over the plus model. I debated the 2 models and decided the Deluxe, with the Juicy 5's and FOX RL suspension was enough of a reason to upgrade. I am glad I did! For those who puts high miles and a confidence inspiring bike, this is it.
The white seat is the only negative. In fact, white seats on mountain bikes should be outlawed.
The price (over 2K) is very good for the quality of the bike you will receive. While doing research, everything kept pointing back to the HiFi Deluxe.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
trailmonkey
a Weekend Warrior
from Dillard, GA USA Date Reviewed: April 5, 2009
Favorite Trail:
Scaly Mtn.
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Price Paid:
$1650.00
Purchased At:
used
Strengths:
Great looking bike. Good rear deraileur and suspension.
Weaknesses:
BRAKING: almost does not exist on mine. I can clamp down on the brakes, with enough force to where I think the levers may snap, and still turn either tire with my hand. On my litespeed with Hayes 9s, you CAN NOT do that. Maybe I have a problem specific to my bike, but this is my experience.
Paint: really flimsy....I think finger paints may be more durable. THEN, Fisher Does not sell stickers or paint (as far as I can tell)??? You mean to tell me, a bike company that claims to be legit, doesn't even offer replacement stickers or any touch-up paint? I tried my lbs (GF dealer) and they didn't have any either. They'll call the rep and "get back to me". When a company doesn't even supply their own stickers, on their own website, I have to say "thanks, but no thanks. Let me know when you are real company and actually support what you sell."
Similar Products Used:
Specialized Stumpjumper Pro, Litespeed Ocoee
Bottom Line:
Nice looking bike, nice suspension and seems pretty smooth. Great rear deraileur and shifts quite well. But, the paint and lack of support in terms of even offering stickers and paint from their website causes me to give them a "D". To me, if you don't support what you sell, I don't see how you different than a no-name company who imports frames from China and adds shimano components. That's just me.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
wharfrat27
a Cross Country Rider
from monterey, ca Date Reviewed: December 11, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Goat Trail
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Purchased At:
BikeLine
Strengths:
Great climber... great slow speed steering, fox fork is plush and tracks very well, fox rear suspension gets the job done, bike handles all types of trails effortlessly.
Weaknesses:
Stock seat and tires needed to be swapped out. Avid Juicy 5's have been a pain and are noisy- but work well.
Similar Products Used:
Gary Fisher Sugar 3, Old Stumpjumper Singlespeed
Bike Setup:
Stock except bars/tires.
Bottom Line:
I think Fisher finally got it right. The handling is superb on this bike... both at speed and through the tight technical stuff. No chainline issues like I had with my old Sugar. This bike climbs like a billy goat and accelerates very well. it has inspired alot of confidence in me and I'm a better rider because of it.
The Fox fork and rear suspension w/ Propedal are spot on and the geometry of the bike works for me. I have not ben super impressed by the Avid Juicy's but they get the job done. I would recommend this to anyone that likes to ride hard and needs an excellent 'do it all' rig.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
drool
a Weekend Warrior
from Carnatin, Wa Date Reviewed: September 26, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Rader Creek (now)
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Price Paid:
$2200.00
Purchased At:
Singltrack Cycles
Strengths:
I no longer worry about wanting a locking rear shock like my last bike. I flip it to stiff and no worries. See my previous post.
Weaknesses:
Frail paint. If powder coat was an optioin I'd go for it. My 1988 Mongoose has better quality paint. Screw the weight of paint. Make it good.
Similar Products Used:
Specialized FSR XC
Bike Setup:
See my previous post. I now have a Blackspire big ring protector and some skull/crossbone sickers to make it faster.
Bottom Line:
This is a follow up post now that I have a summer on the bike. 9 months total now. I am still in love. I managed some higher speed stuff late this summer and she just ate up the trail. It was comfortable at speeds I never would have dared before. I managed to use up all the rear suspension travel while going fast and it was a dream. Climbing up the forest service roads to get to top is no problem the shock set stiff. I do not miss the locking rear shock......much. Having 120 mm up front instead of my previous 100 is fantastic. I will not be replacing this bike for a loooooong time. We are one.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
hoppersailor
a Weekend Warrior
from Alexandria, VA Date Reviewed: July 31, 2008
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$2200.00
Purchased At:
The Bike Lane
Strengths:
The cockpit feels great. Everything is positioned to be in the most efficient, ergonomic position possible. While riding the day I picked her up from the shop, I found myself leaning to get through even some of the tightest turns. It reminded me of being on a motorcyle and how you don't actually turn the wheel as much as throw your weight into a turn. I have an old (2001) GF Hoo Koo E Koo and it's extremely hard to lean into anything without almost busting tail. The HiFi also feels a bit lighter then the other bikes I tried.
Weaknesses:
Tires, tires, tires!!! the Jones tires on this bike are a real disapointment for the pricepoint. Between the Genisis 2.0 Geometry and the feel of the cockpit, you should have the confidence to tackle just about anything that comes at you. Unfortunately, the underperforming tires plant the tiniest seed of doubt in your mind which grows like a weed and can lead to some major and minor wipeouts. Tires are the first thing to get swapped out!!
Having some issues with the rear derailleur but I belive it will fix itself when the cable stretches a bit.
Similar Products Used:
Trek Fuel EX8, Cannondale Rush 3, Marin Rift
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
I picked this bike over the others for two reasons:
1. I was actually able to test ride a demo bike on the trail vs. riding around in a parking lot at REI and other shops. There's nothing like actually test riding a bike on a trail that you're actually gonna ride on.
2. I have a Fisher hardtail that has lasted me the better part of 7 years. I've never had a problem with it and to me a high quality product is one that deserves my loyalty.
I'm giving the value rating 3 chilis just b/c I expected something better in the way of tires with a bike for $2200!!!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
xcmtber
a Cross Country Rider
from MD Date Reviewed: July 22, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Dirt
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Price Paid:
$1800.00
Purchased At:
LBS
Strengths:
ATTN:MTBR.COM. This is a trail bike not an all mountain.......
G2, Handling, Weight, Light, Weight, Light
Weaknesses:
ATTN:MTBR.COM. This is a trail bike not an all mountain.......
Tires are an accident waiting to happen.
Similar Products Used:
Dakar, FSR, NRS
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
Fantastic climber, even with shock in the open position and handles unbelievably. Gary has made a winner with this one... Tested as many bikes as I could and this bike won hands down. Love the travel and low stand over height. If you buy this bike please be careful because it flies and makes you try things that you may not be ready for.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
John
a Cross Country Rider
from Maryland Date Reviewed: July 22, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Dirt
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Price Paid:
$1790.00
Purchased At:
LBS
Strengths:
ATTN: MTBR.com This is a trail bike not an all mountain.... G2, handling, light!!
Weaknesses:
ATTN: MTBR.com This is a trail bike not an all mountain...... Tires are an accident waiting to happen.
Similar Products Used:
Dakar, FSR, Rainier
Bike Setup:
Stock, with Kendas
Bottom Line:
Fantastic climber, even with shock in the open position and handles unbelievably. Gary has made a winner with this one... Tested as many bikes as I could and this bike won hands down. Love the travel and low stand over height. If you buy this bike please be careful because it flies and makes you try things that you may not be ready for.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
dirragon1
a Cross Country Rider
from Albuquerque, NM, USA Date Reviewed: July 13, 2008
Favorite Trail:
All
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$2199.00
Purchased At:
Sportz Outdoor
Strengths:
Light, light, light!
Weaknesses:
There are some Shimano parts on the thing. Soon to be remedied.
Similar Products Used:
Gary Fisher Wahoo, Specialized Hard Rock, GT Backwoods, Giant Reign
Bike Setup:
Stock for now (with carbon monkey bar).
Bottom Line:
The bottom line is that this bike is 25 pounds on tubeless wheels. It's only two pounds heavier than the Fisher Carbon. What does that mean? It means you can do anything with it. It climbs like nobody's business, and descends like a mountain lion on rails. Mountain bike tech has really come along in the last few years. This is truly an amazing bike. The Fox ProPedal works pretty well on the ascent, though it could always be better. The Shimano crank isn't great, but it's passable. Sram shifters and rear derailleur kick butt, and the Avid Juicy 5's feel great and offer plenty of stopping power.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
noot
a Weekend Warrior
from Edmonton, AB, Canada Date Reviewed: July 7, 2008
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Lightweight, good looks, great geometry
Weaknesses:
Stock tires, grips
Bike Setup:
Stock w/ Maxxis Crossmark UST
Bottom Line:
I bought this bike to replace my stolen 2005 GT Avalanche 0.5. I originally wanted a Commencal Meta 4.2, but they didn't have any left in my size (XL). They had a 2008 Hifi Deluxe in the shop, so I read some reviews. Well, the reviews say it all, this bike is great. Not having ridden much twisty XC/AM stuff for a couple years, this bike has been a great way to get back into it. Somehow, it DOES feel like it wants to climb. The suspension is excellent (be sure to set it up according to your weight), the geometry is perfect. The bike has saved my butt several times, and has given me the confidence to keep pushing. The top tube "curve" is nice... has saved me from a couple close calls :)
I'm 6'6", 210lbs. I haven't done any major jumping, but when I have, the bike takes it no problem. Not sure I would go roof-dropping, but for any XC/AM stuff, I'm far more worried about ME surviving, not my bike :)
I'm far from being a pro rider, but this bike is the best I've ridden. Lighter than my friends hardtails, smoother than my friends full suspension bikes. If you're looking for a perfect all-around bike (other than freeride/etc), this is the one for you.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
drool
a Weekend Warrior
from Carnation Wa Date Reviewed: July 1, 2008
Favorite Trail:
St Ed
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Price Paid:
$2200.00
Purchased At:
Single Track Cycles
Strengths:
Suspension travel. Climbs like a goat. Great on low speed tight single track stuff considering it's a 5 inch travel bike.
Weaknesses:
Could use a locking rear shock for the price.
Similar Products Used:
05 Specialized FSR XC (the bike that was replaced by this one)
Bike Setup:
Specialized Fast Trak Armadillo Elite tires for hard pack, Velociraptors for loose/mud (two sets of wheels) WTB Rocket V saddle, ODI grips, Assorted lizard skin protective stuff, getting a Blackspire big ring protector this week after crashing my chainring really hard.
Bottom Line:
I wanted to upgrade to more suspension travel and an air fork. I was thinking of a Yeti 575 but couldn't find one to test ride. I wanted the SRAM X9 and this bike had it. I test rode it and fell in love. I absolutely love the bike. I have heard stories of this bike ghost shifting but I have never had it happen to me. Maybe it's with a different derailleur setup.
If you're looking at a Specialized Stumpy FS , look at this bike too.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
guitarguru13
a Cross Country Rider
from Plattsmouth, NE Date Reviewed: June 12, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Swanson Park
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Purchased At:
Employee Purchase
Strengths:
XTR rear, Light weight, love the fox rear suspension and the manitou minute up front, geometry is a plus. i wish mine had a lock out though.
Weaknesses:
tires, and crank (has some flex, clicks) upgrade to xtr and your gold
Similar Products Used:
Everything that comes through the shop i ride, so ex8's, 9, 7, a cake 3, a caliber, super caliber, and a fat possum XT to name a few. plus hardtail 29ers...all fisher
Bike Setup:
Stock, waiting on my XTR crank to arive, bar ends, tubeless
Bottom Line:
This bike is great. Unlike everyone else i love the 07 color because it doesn't show scratches very bad. they actually make it look sweeter. the bike sits nice, and the geometry rocks. great everywhere i take it. The rockies...no problem, the Appalacians... no problem, nebraska?...a joke, but hey you got to live somewhere. Climbs better than my hardtail 29er. descends better too, but not a freeride bike like a fat possum. Get this bike and you won't look back, unless your trying to find your buddies out on the trail
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Katie LaRue
a Cross Country Rider
from Asheville, NC Date Reviewed: June 1, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Tsali trails, several in The Pisgah area
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$2000.00
Purchased At:
Youngblood
Strengths:
Great components, much better control then my last bike, durable, lightweight, all around badass bike!
Weaknesses:
so far the paint job sucks otherwise I have no complaints
Similar Products Used:
I had a 1999 Rockhopper A1 fs comp for 9 years
Bike Setup:
Fox fork and rear suspension, juicy five brakes, shimano xt front and sram rear
Bottom Line:
I have ridden this bike hard since i bought it. I ride at least 4 times a week for an hour sometimes 2 or 3. I have done one 18 mile race and a 9 mile race today and it has been amazing! I'm faster and have more control then before. Downhills are much easier to ride and i can go faster. I am not "big" jumper but I do get air on occasion and the landing has been great so far! I LOVED my specialized and still do (refuse to part with it) but this bike has improved my riding by a lot. The paint chipped the first day I had it, but honestly, it's a bike who cares? (and I'm a chick, so I should care and I don't) It's the men's version in black size small.
This bike is probably a little much for someone who isn't pretty serious about mountain biking. However, if you love to ride and want to upgrade this is a wonderful option!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Chris H
a Cross Country Rider
from Negaunee, MI Date Reviewed: May 18, 2008
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Purchased At:
Quick Stop Bike Shop
Strengths:
Everything
Weaknesses:
Tires and seat
Bike Setup:
E13 Supercharger Bash Ring, Kenda Nevegals 2.35 front and 2.1 rear, Crank Brothers Mallet pedals, and WTB Devo saddle. Next is a Race Face Evolve AM stem to shorten it up a bit more.
Bottom Line:
This is a follow up review after adding the above parts. The most impressive part of switching these things out are the tires. With the Nevegals this bike tracks on everything from hardpack to wet and muddy rock rides. The Mallets are overkill for xc but for technical rides they offer a stable platform. The Devo is by far better than the Bontrager stock saddle, but is still not perfect. I am slowly but surely pushing the limits of what this bike can handle and it is definitely performing!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jim
a Weekend Warrior
from West Linn, OR, USA Date Reviewed: May 18, 2008
Favorite Trail:
McKenzie River, Oregon
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$2200.00
Purchased At:
River City Bikes
Strengths:
Setup is very comfortable, more than any other bike I tested before buying. Very responsive as well. The geometry of the frame makes the bike extremely easy to handle, especially in tight areas. The suspension is very smooth too.
The bike is very lite compared to its equivalents. I was between it and a Fuel EX8 (which was a couple pounds heavier) and a new '07 Cannondale Rush Carbon 3. The Fisher weighed a little less than even the Cannondale, which had the carbon frame and Lefty shock (I really like that shock). My bike in a large frame, stock, was just under 28 pounds.
Weaknesses:
I do not really see any yet, I am waiting to keep riding and find some--so far I am very pleased. The tires are kind of junky and I am not sure about the saddle; all things to spend more money on.
Similar Products Used:
Compared to the Rush 3, which is the other bike I was down to, this bike was just a lot more responsive, maneuverable, and very easy to turn. I would compare the Rush to a Cadillac and the HiFi Deluxe to a Corvette. It was just much faster in turns and very responsive to the pedal.
Bike Setup:
So far, stock. Will eventually be replacing the bars, seatpost, saddle, tires, and maybe the rims.
Bottom Line:
Everybody has said that test driving a bike is THE must and they are so right. I had a hardtail before this and had to try many things out. The shifters on this bike are fantastic and so are the brakes, they function extremely well. I knew the second I got on that this would be the bike, it just feels very user friendly. It climbs and descends like a champ. The ProPedal on the shock makes climbing much better and it is smooth as silk going down hill.
I ride on the weekends and this was my pricepoint to get into a full suspension. If anybody asked me what bike to get, this would be my first recommendation (and I did a ton or research). In the end, it all comes down to that demo though, I read a lot of great things about a lot of great bikes. I think most all of the reviews were true, companies are making great bikes these days. The HiFi was for me, it fit like a glove.
Go Fisher.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
nathan powers
a Weekend Warrior
from park city, utah, usa Date Reviewed: May 12, 2008
Favorite Trail:
hole in the ground (tahoe, CA), steam donkey (woodside, CA), glenwild loop (park city, ut)
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$1900.00
Purchased At:
piece by piece
Strengths:
wicked handling. light. climbs, floats, and descends like like a ferrari on a triple espresso. elegant refined looks.
Weaknesses:
huh?
Similar Products Used:
my late and stolen yeti 575 wishes it handled like this and cost twice as much. not that i did not love my yeti....but,,
Bike Setup:
recon. crossride wheelset. king headset. xt shadow. raceface evolve crank. fire xc's. easton stem, xc70 post and monkeylite carbons. hayes 10th anniversary carbon discs.
Bottom Line:
pretty awesome ride. buy it you can but build it if you seek the truth. there is no spoon....
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Gary Super Hard
a Weekend Warrior
from Brisbane Australia Date Reviewed: May 8, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Dingo Track Mt Coot-tha
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Purchased At:
Plane Cycles
Strengths:
Great looking bike with amazing turning ability in tight situations, the pro pedal on the rear shock turns this gorgeous machine into a climbing monster.
Weaknesses:
Keeping it clean around the rear suspension and bottom bracket areas.
Similar Products Used:
GF Cake, Trek 8500, Trek Fuel
Bike Setup:
HiFi frame, Hone running gear with XTR front derailleur, Mavic 819 wheelset with crossmark tyres, Fox Vanilla front shock, leopard skin debomb seat, thompson seatpost, fox sp3 rear shock, XT disc brakes with EBC gold pads, lizard skin lockon grips. AY UP MTB light set for night riding.
Bottom Line:
I get so excited thinking about my ride that I almost can't sleep at nights.
I got the HiFi as a replacement frame after i cracked the frame on the GF Cake four times. Gary Fisher and my LBS have been fantastic with warranty and have become a life long customer to both.
I thought my Cake was an excellent XC/freeride bike until I got on the HiFi. It was dolby stereo surround sound in the forest that very first day. Handling, turning, and climbing are all outstanding. My riding buddies comment that my fitness has improved, but honestly its the bike that has made me a better all round rider.
Apart from some awkward spots on the rear of the bike when it comes to cleaning it down, I haven't got anything but praise for the HiFi. However, after my frame cracking experience with the Cake, I nervous check out the frame after each ride. I'm 95kgs and naturally I am a bit harder on the bike. In defence of the CAKE, my mate Soft Hands also owns a CAKE at 72kgs, he has never had anything break or fall apart on his Cake which he still rides today.
Great bike that would suit many riders who push there riding beyond cross country.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Taylor
a Racer
from Asheville, NC, USA Date Reviewed: May 5, 2008
Favorite Trail:
All Bent Creek Trails!
Duration Product Used:
Tested or demo'ed only
Purchased At:
Demoed at Youngblood Bikes
Strengths:
Bike is sooo light, avids stop you on a dime - the larger front rotor is a nice touch, moderately nice components, GEOMETRY!, this thing can climb hills like you wouldn't imagine!!, fast...fast...fast bike...
Weaknesses:
Seat, grips & tires. I will immediately replace these as soon as I convince myself I have the $$ for this bike. If you buy this bike, I would also say you should expect to budget for a nice seat, set of grips and tires too. The stock ones suck. Period.
Bike Setup:
stock
Bottom Line:
I demoed the 2008 HiFi Deluxe today, and it is one damn sexy machine. First of all, I don't know what they were thinking last year with that weird sea-green color... They got it right this year though, and this bike is some damn fine eye candy - all black with white decals, silver components and the lovely metallic blue of fox suspension.
You can't buy a bike just cause it looks pretty though. So I demoed it, and this bike rides exponentially better than it looks!!! I have never had so much fun on a bike before! Right now I own a 2003 Tassajara disc that I've souped up and raced many times, and the HiFi blows my old bike away! I guess that should go without saying.
It turns on a dime, and yes, the slow speed handling is definitely noticeable and awesome. I'm convinced that this bike climbs better than my old hardtail... and that's saying a lot! This bike climbs like there's somethin pushing it! You can really crank it and you don't really feel the rear shock move at all!
Did I mention it's damn sexy?
This is just my first impression, but it's the best damn first impression I've ever had with a bike. Kinda infatuated.
Oh yea...and this bike hauls ass! Before you know it, you'll be goin so damn fast you might enter shock. And when you're goin that fast, you'll still be able to turn on a dime and maneuver the bike any way you please.
This bike is awesome. As a Fisher fan to begin with, I love the new geometry, and I love how the bike just feels. Now all I have to do is convince myself I can spend a couple grand.... hmmm......
I cannot rave about this bike enough. (except for the lame seat, tires and grips - which are really a non-issue)
This bike is perfect for those who want a super fast, light trail bike that can take some serious hits and moderate drops! Definitely not full downhill or free ride material though.
I'm sad I have to give it back tomorrow.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Chris H,
a Cross Country Rider
from Negaunee, MI Date Reviewed: May 5, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Gorgeous
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Price Paid:
$2200.00
Purchased At:
Quick Stop Bike Shop
Strengths:
Slow speed handling, component spec, weight, stability at speed.
Weaknesses:
TIRES!!! I hate these tires.
Similar Products Used:
Trek Fuel EX8
Bike Setup:
Stock. Yep, even the saddle.
Bottom Line:
This bike is awesome for the type of riding I do...a little bit of everything. It tracks well, climbs well, descends well, and is just fun to ride. I cannot beleive how well it handles in the tightest spots at the lowest speeds. My only complaint is the tires. The Bontragers are pretty much useless when on anything but dry hardpack. I will be replacing the Jones with Nevegal 2.35s or the Excavators ASAP.
If you are looking for a lightweight speed machine then this is your steed. Looking for something to handle some light all mountain stuff then this is it...but do yourself a favor and get some different tires! I am a clydesdale at 225 and I love this bike.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Russell
a Cross Country Rider
from Rockville, MD Date Reviewed: May 4, 2008
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Strengths:
This is an update to my review from 3/27 - I guess my comment about now component failures was premature.
Weaknesses:
On an easy cross country ride this morning both chain stays snapped off just aft of the pivot. While I am a big guy (230#) and I do ride aggressively, I am doing the type of riding for which this bike is advertised. I do not hit massive drop offs or little ones for that matter. In fact, if there is ever more than 6" of air between my tires and the ground it was not intentional and will probably end badly.
Bottom Line:
When the HiFi is not in the shop waiting for warranty parts (assuming that this is a warranty claim - the LBS was not very supportive when I dropped off the bike this afternoon) it is a good handling bike and a pleasure to ride. Unfortunately, this is the third time in 3 years that I have lost my Fisher bike to rear suspension failures (the first two were with a Cake). The first year it took over 4 months to get my bike repaired, the second year I was without a bike for 8-10 weeks and today they just quoted my 6-8 weeks.
While it is nice that (at least so far) GF has stood behind their products with a solid warranty, I would much rather be riding than telling you about their wonderful warranty. When I do get my bike back from the shop it is going up for sale - I need a bike that is durable enough for the type of riding that I do and obviously that will not be a Gary Fisher product.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
a Weekend Warrior
from Lawrenceville, GA, USA Date Reviewed: April 22, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Tribble Mill
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$2279.00
Purchased At:
Atlanta Cycling
Strengths:
Extremely light, handles well, adjustable rebound, great shifting, stops very well with the avid juicy brakes
Weaknesses:
Avid Juicy 5 makes slight noise in the front because the pads are not aligned quite right. I have managed to get some of the noise out just by using front brakes more and re-aligning caliper but there is still a slight problem. It does not compare to the noise I was getting out of the regular HiFi which was like blowing a whistle the entire ride. The paint on this bike scratches really quick. The shifters are easy to trip on while climbing. The seat hurts at first. The grips are very thin.
Similar Products Used:
Gary Fisher HiFi
Bike Setup:
Stock except pedals
Bottom Line:
This is an awesome bike. I have put it through a lot and even found out it floats in quick streams (I fell while trying to cross on the bike). It handles well, the brakes stop on a dime, and the suspension is responsive and adjustable to any degree required. The grips are really thin so my big hands feel awkward, and the seat was horrible in the beginning. Now I'm used to it. The bike goes uphill and downhill as if it has a motor. I have no problems climbing and love the quick downhills. I don't like the finish being so easy to scratch and the chainring is very easy to mess up. Overall this bike is a pleasure to ride. It is light, agile, and makes me want to go to the trails every day. I would say this bike is overkill for the novice and great for the advanced rider but if you have the money to spend at least try out the bike because it is definitely worth it.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
john sharp
a Cross Country Rider
from pacific grove, ca Date Reviewed: April 9, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Goat Trail
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Purchased At:
Bro's Bike Shop
Strengths:
Slow speed handling is excellent, fox suspension is more than adequate, drivetrain gets the job done. Climbs well and handles the rough stuff beter than advertised.
Weaknesses:
Avid's squeaked like crazy despite adjustments. Seat had to be replaced after one ride ( I'm still sore) Tires were swapped out before ever riding.
Similar Products Used:
Gary Fisher Sugar 3 (2003) Would still be rockin it if it had not been stolen.
Bike Setup:
Stock (except Eggbeaters, Exiwolf 2.1s and old WTB seat)
Bottom Line:
Sweet Ride. Handled some rocky, technical terrain in both Fruita and Moab easily. I felt like the bike wanted to climb and really did not need to mess with the propedal or lock out the fork on long climbs. Descended very well and the suspension felt plush. The slow speed handling of this ride was 10 times better than my old Sugar and really was noticeable right out of the gate. The Avids did the job but the squealing drove all of us nuts. Gary does need to start spec'ing better seats/tires but overall I am more than satisfied and feel like it performs as well as advertised. Cross country riders and those who like long epic rides should consider buying the HI FI. Will review again after putting more miles on her.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Russell
a Weekend Warrior
from Rockville, MD, USA Date Reviewed: March 27, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Watershed
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Purchased At:
Revolution
Strengths:
(1) Out of the box the handling was outstanding. This bike replaced a GF Cake that required trying a few different bar/stem combos that I liked. (2) This bike has proven to be extremely durable. I weigh 240+ when geared up and with a full years of abuse on very rocky trails I have not experienced a single component failure. In two years with my Cake I had numerous frame/suspension issues.
Weaknesses:
(1) Factory tires are beyond attrocious! Inexcusable. (2) The bottom bracked is about 0.700" lower than on the Cake. I now find myself clipping a lot more rocks/branches than on my old bike even after a full year of riding.
Similar Products Used:
GF Cake
Bike Setup:
Stock except for 180MM XT Crankset (which also contributes to my ground clearance issues)
Bottom Line:
After 2 years of frame/suspension issues with my Cake and some very slow warranty service from the factory I was pretty much done with GF. I called the factory and when a rep went through my warranty record as saw the number of problems that I had experienced they replaced my Cake with a brand new HiFi Deluxe. I was impressed that they took that action but still not won over yet because if the HiFi had performed like my Cake, it would have spent as much time in the shop as in my garage. I can now say that after a year of hard riding on the HiFi that not only does GF stand behind their product, they can also build a great handling FS ride that is well built and durable.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
David Shabat
a Cross Country Rider
from Toccoa, GA, USA Date Reviewed: March 17, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Frady Branch
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Price Paid:
$1850.00
Purchased At:
Cycleworks Inc.
Strengths:
Update from November 2007 - This bike only gets better as time goes by! Singletrack, forest service roads, and rock gardens are no match for the Hifi deluxe. The crank is solid, the shock and fork turned out even better than I expected. I can do anything I want to with this bike! You can't ask for more than that.
Weaknesses:
Let's see, I am a short guy at 5'7" so I bought a small - and a 24 oz. water bottle doesn't easily fit into the bottle cage on the inside of the frame triangle. That's about it.
Similar Products Used:
Trek Fuel EX8
Bike Setup:
As it was from the start, stock except for the pedals. Let me tell ya, thank goodness I got away from SPD years ago cause it's just too darn hard to deal with in sub-prime conditions.
Bottom Line:
If you are not taking your bike off cliffs (or if you are and don't care what happens to you or your bike) this bike can do anything. You won't be left unsatisfied. The ride is so plush that I'd replace my living room couch with it, if my wife wouldn't kill me over it.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Frazier
a Cross Country Rider
from Greensboro,NC USA Date Reviewed: January 17, 2008
Favorite Trail:
Angler's Ridge & Tsali
Duration Product Used:
1 Year
Price Paid:
$1800.00
Purchased At:
Paceline
Strengths:
Great Bike, Very good on single tracks. No problems with any of the components so far(over 1200 miles). Most of the folks I ride with have tried out my bike and love it(one has a GT I Drive the other a Fuel EX9).
Weaknesses:
None
Similar Products Used:
Trek Fuel EX8
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
Great Bike!!! I highly recomend this bike if you like to ride single tracks.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
David Shabat
a Cross Country Rider
from Toccoa, Georgia, USA Date Reviewed: November 20, 2007
Favorite Trail:
Frady Branch
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Price Paid:
$1850.00
Purchased At:
Cycleworks, Duluth, GA
Strengths:
Lightweight frame and components, Interesting Geometry, Long Travel Fork (for what I do), Highly Adjustable Shock (you don't HAVE TO make it use all 5" of travel)
Weaknesses:
I'd have preferred a straight handlebar, so the acclimitization to the change in geometry wouldn't also include compensating for a riser bar. The tires leave a lot to be desired (even 2 different bike shops had big trouble helping me go tubeless - and I wonder if I'll ever be able to repair a flat on the trail without a high-volume air compressor like we have at the bike shop).
Similar Products Used:
Nothing Full suspension. I worked my way up. I still don't have a "racing" bike, but if I can do anything my courage will let me do, my strength and speed will follow. I believe this bike will not hold me back at all.
Bike Setup:
stock except pedals, Eggbeater Candy - yellow- to match the decals (ain't that cute).
Bottom Line:
Buy one. They got even better with a Fox front end for 2008. When I turn on the propedal to full - I can, and do, climb trails that have everyone I saw in my last adventure race - hike-a-biking. I don't think it's just skill, cause I remember carrying my old Novarra hardtail up those hills I was riding on my HiFi. If you don't buy this bike, consider the new Trek Fuel models (with the new rear suspension setup). I have had Novarra (REI) and Cannondale - but Gary's team really got something right with this HiFi. I don't know what it is, but my confidence is stronger. My riding is more aggressive. I don't give up until my body's beat - and that's before the bike wants to quit. I can't ask for more than that.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Alan Botten
a Cross Country Rider
from Cape Town Date Reviewed: July 29, 2007
Favorite Trail:
Tokai or Sedgefield
Duration Product Used:
6 months
Price Paid:
$4000.00
Purchased At:
Bowmans
Strengths:
Light, great handling after you get used to the direct steering, stable.
Weaknesses:
I had ghost shifting but sorted it out by shortening the cable casing,2mm, that links the swingarm and frame and not attching the cable in the last attachment point on the frame. Paint chips and scratches easily. Jiucy 5s need constant adjustments.
Similar Products Used:
Tested the Titus motolite and Trek fuel8
Bike Setup:
Stock, shock pumped 110psi and forks about the same, I weigh 90kg.
Bottom Line:
The bike is amazing, climbes brilliantly, handles the singletrack with ease and is stable on fast downhills. I am going to try metal back disk pads as in winter the standard ones only last me a month.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Genjutsushi
a Cross Country Rider
from Leeds, UK Date Reviewed: July 26, 2007
Favorite Trail:
Dalby Forest
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Purchased At:
Chevin Cycles, Otley, UK
Strengths:
This bike is Lightweight. By far the lightest full susser that ive come across and consequently nails every climb. It doesnt feel unsubstantial on descents, but agile and controllable (as soon as you adjust to the handling).
The forks perform brilliantly, as does the ProPedal on the rear shock which eliminates bob on hard climbs
The G2 geometry is also fantastic for slow, considered, winding technical track.
Weaknesses:
The clearance on the bottom bracket is sometimes a little tight for the type of riding i do, and ive found myself catching on rocks that my old trek used to clear without too much hassle.
The paint work is getting very quickly damaged as well and could have been more robust.
Big problem for UK riders - there is no way (that i have yet found) to attach a crud catcher on the main frame, so ive come home from every ride plastered in mud.
Stock tyres are appalling. Change em quick. Similarly the handlebar grips are worth changing at the earliest possible juncture to someting larger and easier to hold on to.
Similar Products Used:
This is my first full squish. Old bike was a Trek 4700 hardtail with horrendous forks.
Bike Setup:
As stock but with Panaracer XC Fire Pro tyres, Yeti grips, rear crud catcher, CatEye wireless Computer.
Bottom Line:
The major factor that stopped me from looking at Full Sussers before was my perception that the weight was much greater, and the flex in the frame would reduce the amount of power in each stroke of the pedals. This bike has totally changed my mind. It is perfect for cross country riding i prefer, and for more substantial mountain exploits.
The forks supplied with this range are bespoke to accomodate the G2 geometry, but that is a great advantage as if you do not want or like the G2, then swapping to another fork would move the geometry back to 'regular' Gary Fisher / Trek territory.
The accessories on this bike leave a little to be desired however. As stated above in the weaknesses, ive found the contact points on the bike frame a little cheap (tyres, grips, saddle).
I'd definately reccommend this bike for anyone looking for a lightweight full susser for cross country and technical rides. I dont do freeriding, or big downhills, and i think this bike wouldnt really be suited to that sort of rider.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jeff Ball
a Cross Country Rider
from Kennesaw, GA, Cobb Date Reviewed: June 15, 2007
Favorite Trail:
Tanasi
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$2200.00
Purchased At:
Atlanta Cycling
Strengths:
Offset fork provides turning on a dime and superb control at slower speeds. Weight and "G2" Geometry of bike makes it an awesome climber. New 07 Shimano LX shifters are nice - option to fingershift or thumbshift! Avid Juicy 5's are awesome, after coming off of a Trek 4500.
Weaknesses:
Offset fork makes me feel as though I'm about to go over the handlebars at faster speeds when braking and doing switchbacks (I'm 6'0" 200lb - maybe i could have swapped the 90mm stem for a 100mm to solve this???) Geometry of bike is ok on downhills, but unable to lift up front end at will if need to ride the rear wheel over obstacles or if need to suddenly hop off a skinny log (i found out the hard way several times). Bontrager crankset seemed to be defective - I rode the bike on singletrack 10 times and 9 times the chain fell off when downshifting from middle chainring to low gear and climbing a hill (not at the same time, for those of you who think it may have been pilot error).
Similar Products Used:
Trek Fuel EX8, Cannondale
Bike Setup:
Stock
Bottom Line:
Atlanta cycling has been very patient and cooperative with me and was willing to swap out the defective crankset with a Shimano Deore LX; but weighing all the factors - constant chain slippage, feeling as though i was going to be thrown over the handlebars, unable to lift the front end at will...I decided to trade the HiFi DLX for the Trek Fuel EX8. I am much happier now. Maybe the HiFi DLX just wasn't made for my style of riding. I actually preferred my $500 Trek 4500 over the HiFi DLX - believe it or not!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Steve
a Cross Country Rider
from Tempe, Arizona, USA Date Reviewed: May 16, 2007
Favorite Trail:
South Mountain - Phoenix
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Strengths:
Light Weight, Tubeless, XTR Rear, Wheels, Seat
Weaknesses:
No Handlebar mount for Propedal lockout, have to reach down to turn it on/off. GHOSTSHIFTING.
Similar Products Used:
Giant NRS, Iron Horse Warrior Elite, Haro, Proflex 454, Trek Y, GF Cake
Bike Setup:
Stock w/ Tubeless
Bottom Line:
Great bike! I've used this in a beginner level Race, training and several fun-rides over the last month. Its a blast to ride, and the new fork rake is a non issue - works great for me. Unfortunately, after 100 miles, I've got a loose link somewhere within the rear linkage. I'm sure the shop will fix that up though. Did I mention Ghost shifting? I thought I'd get away from Ghost shifting with this linkage system, but I guess not. It must be something inherent with all Full Bounce bikes. I've owned a lot of them over the years and they all had shifting issues. This bike gets only 4 chilis because of the loose linkage and the ghosting, other than that it is a great ride with tons of travel for such a light rig. It really does feel like a lightweight speedster when you want it to the most. I can't wait to get back on the trail!
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Flyin HiFi
a Downhiller
from athens ohio USA Date Reviewed: May 5, 2007
Favorite Trail:
Big Bear lake
Duration Product Used:
Less than 1 month
Price Paid:
$1800.00
Purchased At:
Athens Bicycle
Strengths:
light, stiff, strong, climbing, decending, value, new xtr rear derailer, tubeless from the get go, and a whole lot more.
Weaknesses:
doesent have a beer tap on the handlebar and built in brewary
Similar Products Used:
specialized enduro, trek fuel, gary fisher x-caliber, trek 8500
Bike Setup:
just converted it to tubeless, everything else is stock
Bottom Line:
Amazing bike for the price, everything about it is amazing and when i say amazing its an understatement. the bike comes with tubeless tires and rims but ultralight tubes, within 10mins it was tubeless and ready to go. after riding this bike i can tell im so much faster in every aspect of my riding. i race cross country in west virgina and now my weeks feel ten times longer just cuz i cant wait till the next race so i can smoke some little weight weenies on my all mountian bike. it accelerates like a 20lb hardtail and has the ride of a kona stinky(i know cuz i have one). so if you only want one bike in your stable then this is the one to get.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
charlie
a Cross Country Rider
from Pine Plains, NY, USA Date Reviewed: April 30, 2007
Favorite Trail:
fairy lake 500
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Strengths:
Light weight, great climber and very nimble on the downhills
Weaknesses:
haven't found any ye
Similar Products Used:
fisher cake, sugar, Schwinn homegrown xt
Bike Setup:
stock
Bottom Line:
I love the geometry. I was a bit hesitant about the new rake and trail set up at first, but the bike really rips. The riding here is all rollie pollie hills with lots of mud, shale and roots. How the bike would handle the west I can not say. But Ive ridden enough in CO and MT to feel that It would be great there as well
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Nir Tzuk
a Cross Country Rider
from Israel Date Reviewed: January 14, 2007
Favorite Trail:
All Mountain
Duration Product Used:
Tested or demo'ed only
Price Paid:
$1.00
Purchased At:
Calnoa
Strengths:
Light weight , Stable in turns and descending , goog climbing , very fast , very comfortable
Weaknesses:
Didn't find
Similar Products Used:
SUGAR 3+
Bottom Line:
nice bike , it can do everything and do it very well , climbing , racing and descending , I realy would recomended it to every XC\All mountain biker who wants a versatile bike.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Dylan
a Weekend Warrior
from Cleveland, TN USA Date Reviewed: December 30, 2006
Favorite Trail:
the one I'm rolling down
Duration Product Used:
Tested or demo'ed only
Purchased At:
Scotts Bike Shop
Strengths:
Pedals like really smooth Trek Fuel, Its not a race bike though.
Weaknesses:
Low bottom bracket height
Bike Setup:
Intended market: All Mountain trail riders, Basically a do everything bike. Frame geometry is based upon the all new Genesis 2.0 geometry. The frame itself is a mix of Carbon fiber and Alminum. Carbon fiber seatstays paired with asymetrical aluminum chainstays. Bontrager Race Cranks Shimano LX front deraileur and shifters Shimano XTR rear deraileur Avid Juicy 5 hydraulic brakes Manitou Minute Comp Air- 120 mm travel G2.0 Bontrager edition Fox RP3 rear shock Bontrager Race Disc wheelset
Test loop: 25.3 miles Avg Speed: 9.82 MPH
Bottom Line:
Wow, fun ride. I cannot get over how this 5" travel full suspension bike rode so well. I've been strongly against 5" travel designs in the SE TN region just because our terrain does not truly warrant the need, so when I was asked to review this bike, it did not exactly go on my priority list. As time would have it though, this bike became my second test bike. An interesting thing about this bike is the way it rides. The bike felt like I was riding a 3" travel XC race bike due to how stiff it is. Theres no overt plushness or bounce in this suspension design. There was actually less suspension movement while pedaling than that of my 4" travel FuelEX. Climbing was likened to that of a hardtail when the ProPedal setting was turned up the highest on the rear shock.
Genesis 2.0- This is some good stuff. This geometry makes the bike steer completely different from any bike I've ever ridden. Extremely responsive when going slow through technical terrrain like the old geometry of XC hardtails, but then when going downhill at 19 or 20 mph, its very stable like that of a downhill bikes geometry. I'm guessing this principle will only apply to long travel suspension design.
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Jeremy
a Cross Country Rider
from Charleston, SC Date Reviewed: December 21, 2006
Duration Product Used:
3 months
Bottom Line:
Great all mountain bike. Handles Great in all conditions. Love the new G2 geometry with the new fork angle. Cant beat the fell of the 4 inch travel in front and back. extreamly light for alluminum full suspension. def. recomend
Value Rating:Overall Rating:
What's New
»
BEST OF MTBR - Check out the highest rated bikes, parts, & gear!
»
LED BIKE LIGHT SHOOTOUT 3 - We test all the newest products and latest light and battery technology in this comprehensive guide»
$
Overall Rating:
Overall Rating:
Overall Rating:
Overall Rating:
